Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Children W/ Disabilities*Debate*

who's talking here?

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co 4
Mishka 1
retta 1
Cupcake Addict 3
PinkKim 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 5
Sarah aka Tippy 1
Primmy_Mommy 1
Ruthie 4
Mz.MarineWifey 2
Carrie J 1
Lexi-Lou*Dr SmellGood* 5
✧cristina✧ 1
*Living my love song* 1
All Abouts 1
Patricia 1
B*Bright 6
JustAPrincess 1
♪♫Mikayla 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Children W/ Disabilities*Debate*

So I was looking on Discovery Health.com and came across an article called End the "R" Word and it had a statistic in there saying that 90% of babies prenatally diagnosed with Down's Syndrome are aborted. I just wanted to know, would you personally abort a child who was diagnosed in the womb that they would be mentally or physically disabled with either something like Down's Syndrome or maybe deformalities of their limbs or something? Question 1:: Would you abort your child if you knew they would have some sort of disadvantage in the world? (Answer this question with the yes or no options. If you want to answer the others, just explain.) Q2:: Phsyically, mentally?? Does it matter if it's physical vs. mental? Q3:: Scientifically speaking (not emotionally/motherly), do you think the fetus (for the sake of scientifically speaking) should be aborted for sake of "survival of the fittest" or will nature take care of that on it's own later in life? *This is intended to be a debate and share views from both the YES & NO sides. *We do not use the "R" word in here either! I know some people have children who have disabilities or as someone on here said the other day "differently abled instead of disabled" and this is not intended to be a punch in the face to you or your family, I'm just curious as to how people think.

Yes Vote
 
 16.7% (6)
No Vote
 
 83.3% (30)
B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

So I was looking on Discovery Health.com and came across an article called End the "R" Word and it had a statistic in there saying that 90% of babies prenatally diagnosed with Down's Syndrome are aborted. I just wanted to know, would you personally abort a child who was diagnosed in the womb that they would be mentally or physically disabled with either something like Down's Syndrome or maybe deformalities of their limbs or something? Question 1:: Would you abort your child if you knew they would have some sort of disadvantage in the world? (Answer this question with the yes or no options. If you want to answer the others, just explain.) Q2:: Phsyically, mentally?? Does it matter if it's physical vs. mental? Q3:: Scientifically speaking (not emotionally/motherly), do you think the fetus (for the sake of scientifically speaking) should be aborted for sake of "survival of the fittest" or will nature take care of that on it's own later in life? *This is intended to be a debate and share views from both the YES & NO sides. *We do not use the "R" word in here either! I know some people have children who have disabilities or as someone on here said the other day "differently abled instead of disabled" and this is not intended to be a punch in the face to you or your family, I'm just curious as to how people think. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

me..figure I should be the first... Q1:: NO Q2:: IF I were going to do it, IF...it would be because of a mental problem, never a physical. Like if my child were going to be brain dead. (Can they tell that inside the womb?) Q3:: I don't think that any child should be aborted, I think that survival of the fittest will work itself out in the long run (meaning thousands of years through evolution.) 

♪♫Mikayla --- 17 years ago -

No. When I was pregnant with my daughter, the ultrasound showed a shadow over her heart. They wanted to take another advanced ultrasound. They then told me it could me some sort of disability, I don't remember, I didn't care. The doctor asked me if i'd like them to stick that huge needle in my uterus. I asked him what's the point? He said well, if she does, I could abort. No effing way would I ever abort something God-given to me. I made the choice to have sex, get pregnant, I will not abort a life just because I think it might be harder to live, for my child and/or myself. Because I would rather live a hard life than none at all. My daughter by the way, is a healthy baby. That shadow was nothing. Today we have advanced everthing. Survival of the fittest? That doesn't even play in. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

whoever said yes, could you explain or even PM me and explain....it will not leave my PM whatever you post...i'm just a very curious person. 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

Well, my sister was supposed to have Down's and they urged my mother to abort her and told her all kinds of things that would be wrong and just put lots of undue pressure on her. Well my sister is perfectly normal. She had a crooked head when she was born because of forceps, that's about it. Drs can be wrong, and so can tests, obviously. Nothing is 100%, and even if it was I I wouldn't abort a child because they were going to be different than everyone else or any other reason. 

♪♫Mikayla --- 17 years ago -

My younger brothers have friends with Down's. Let me tell you, they are awesome people. 

*Living my love song* --- 17 years ago -

I didn't even have the test done. I mean nothing would change if i had got it done, my child is my child no matter what. I think the people that get the test done already have it in there mind that they wouldn't keep the baby if something was wrong with it. 

Carrie J --- 17 years ago -

Life story that deals with this I was 16 when I got pregnant with my first son, and my doctor CONVINCED me I had to have the test done. My Grandma (my parent basically) also said it should be done, I had the test done. There was like a 70 percent chance that my baby had down syndrome because of my size , my age, and his mearsurements. I use to cry myself to sleep every night knowing that if it was positive my Grandma would take me to a clinic to abort. Our last fight was actually over this, she said I wasn't prepared for a child deff not a special child. So, I grabbed my coat, and walked out the door, almost six months pregnant to my boyfriends house (who's now my hubbs). I never went back, a week later, they tell me my child is a healthy baby boy. : ).. Guess what I said when they asked if I wanted that test with my second one.. No. Just a lil piece of my history.. 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

Just a lil piece of my history.. Your little piece of history brought tears to my eyes. I am just so glad that someone, being young, stood up for what they believe in and knew in their hearts, it just doesn't happen much anymore today, and I like to hear about it. 

Mishka --- 17 years ago -

i never had the test done either.... 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

Question 1:: Would you abort your child if you knew they would have some sort of disadvantage in the world? (Answer this question with the yes or no options. If you want to answer the others, just explain.) I have refused all test with the intent of finding anything different with my kids... I believe that we all have a path to walk.. I believe that life is to be celebrate always.. that angels come in many forms. Q2:: Phsyically, mentally?? Does it matter if it's physical vs. mental? not to me.. even if did not have a heart beat, or a brain.. I would carry till the birth.. Q3:: Scientifically speaking (not emotionally/motherly), do you think the fetus (for the sake of scientifically speaking) should be aborted for sake of "survival of the fittest" or will nature take care of that on it's own later in life? who is to define the fittest?? Nature not people To me GOD has a plan.. people come for a reason.. kids with disabities to me are little angels send by God for us to learn with them, to learn what most forgot.. to stop and enjoy the little things, the smile, the love with no boundries.. and their parents are the guardian and the ones that were trust to help them walk their plans 

JustAPrincess --- 17 years ago -

I would never abort my own child no matter what was wrong with them. I just could never bring myself to do it. A down syndrome child has every right to a happy life. My nephew is down syndrome and he is very healthy and happy and a joy to be arouond. And ultrasound techs do missdiagnose my brother was suppose to be down syndrome and he wasnt so thankfully my mom didnt abort him. And scientifically speaking I would never have an abortion. Every little life deserves a chance. 

Primmy_Mommy --- 17 years ago -

When I was pregnant with my son he tested postive for downs. They told us we needed to consider what path we wanted to take. We choose furthur testing verses aborting. He was born completely normal, the test had been a false positive. 

Lexi-Lou*Dr SmellGood* --- 17 years ago -

oh this is such a hard topic :( to all of these questions, NO, i would not abort...especially because, as these ladies have proven, tests can be wrong! i just wouldnt be able to abort my child... HOWEVER. i can understand the point of view that some might have when they consider the option...you have to remember that raising a child with disabilities is NOT easy, it can be very trying for both parent and child...some people simply aren't strong enough to handle that...and that is their decision...its a sad and awful one to make, and i feel for these people... also, as for the survival of the fittest...(this is going to sound horrible but please be objective) i know many people with disabilities which are so "severe" that marriage/reproduction simply isn't an option...so i suppose, as the OP said, survival of the fittest would take care of itself? i dunno... 

✧cristina✧ --- 17 years ago -

Personally, I won't even have the test done (I didn't have it with my first pregnancy and I'm not getting it with this one) because it doesn't matter if my kid has Down Syndrom or not. I would never abort him/her. I was told by a nurse (who had a false positive when she tested) that the test is still in it's early phase and almost 80% of the time the positive results are wrong. That would be awful to abort a child based on a false positive, especially because you would probably never know it was false. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

Personally, I won't even have the test done I did the same... they kept telling me if I didn't hurry and get the test than it would be too late. I asked too late for what? They said to abort the baby if there's something wrong with it. Well then, that clears it right up. Don't do the test. If it comes out bad then I'll just worry, and I won't abort anyway, so just don't do the test. 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

Absolutely positively NO. I would not. Two things... First, my mom's brother was born with Cerebral Palsy and in the 50's. Back then it was a shame on the family to have kids with disabilities. People would commit them at birth. Some even locked them in attics or cellars. The doctors told my grandma at birth to give him up. He'd die before age two anyway. She didn't. He was one of my grandmother's 6 surviving children. All of his brothers were strong healthy men, all in the military. He is now the only brother of two left living. He is approaching 60 years old now. My grandmother took care of him every day until she had a stroke and could not care for him anymore. He lives in a very nice group home where he has a job, a girlfriend is a member of Knights of Columbus and has more gold medals for the Special Olympics than I can count. He has a fantastic life and is genuinely and wonderful person. Doctors don't know everything. Two, my son is neurologically affected by prematurity. He has several set backs in life. He is otherwise healthy strong smart funny and caring. I think he may have a hard time with it at points but he has a very well rounded life. My uncle is both physically and mentally impaired and my son just mentally. Do I think they have full lives? Absolutely. I think they have better lives than the average person. Because of my uncles condition he has the IQ and mentality of a 7 year old. He doesn't know how bad the world is. He sees everything through a child's eyes. Who didn't love the carefree life of childhood? It's all about perspective. Just because YOU may think his life is not lived does not make it so. He doesn't know any different. 

Lexi-Lou*Dr SmellGood* --- 17 years ago -

Personally, I won't even have the test done (I didn't have it with my first pregnancy and I'm not getting it with this one) because it doesn't matter if my kid has Down Syndrom or not. I would never abort him/her. I was told by a nurse (who had a false positive when she tested) that the test is still in it's early phase and almost 80% of the time the positive results are wrong. That would be awful to abort a child based on a false positive, especially because you would probably never know it was false. see, i did the test. but i just wanted to know if something was up, because if there was i wanted to be prepared...you have to know that when you find out your child has a disability you are going to be DEVESTATED at first...if you say you aren't your lying...everyone kinda expects that "perfect" baby, so to find out that there will be hardships is hard...but you move past it...this is why i wanted to know...so that i could be prepared, learn more about the disability, and be fully ready for the life ahead. 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

Oh, and I think genetic selection is like ethnic cleansing, genocide. It's messing with the natural order of man. I think it is a slippery slope. Where would it stop? 

PinkKim --- 17 years ago -

When they did the ultrasound of my daughter they could not find her heart at all....they went back and did another one and it was there but they said there seemed to be something wrong. They tried and tried to get me to abort. I was really sick will I was prego with her, on bed rest nearly the whole 9 months. I refused to abort her or even consider it. Like others have said I feel that a baby is a gift from God and no matter what issues they may have they still bring something special and wonderful to the world. My daughter was born with a hole in her heart. She is now 4, has no health issues. The hole in her heart closed up by the time she turned 1 year! Never had any issues with her except we worried a little more then normal. I lost a little sleep because I was always up checking on her during the night but she's wonderful. My son is a hemophiliac. They wanted me to do that advanced testing while I was prego with him and I wouldn’t. I know that if they had then they would have tried to get me to abort him as well. There is no way I would give him up for anything. YES, we're in the ER allot! YES, he will never be able to play most sports. YES, he is a wonderful child! Sorry, so long just really passionate about this topic. 

Mz.MarineWifey --- 17 years ago -

this topic ticks me off (not in a drama starting way lol) because its debated alot and i worked with special needs children and they are the most innocent and loving kids ever and yes it is so very hard and draining but I think for every mother who has a special needs child they are so brave and strong but i know a couple people that were really good friends at the time that had kids with special needs possibilities diagnosed and i refuse to talk to them a mother is supposed to love her kid unconditionally not only if they are "perfect" if i got preggo with a baby that was special needs i would understand that god blessed me with them because they knew i would give that baby all the love and care it deserves. 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

I will always have the ammnio done seeing as Im high risk and have a child w a genetic disability, but that does not change wether or not we would have a child, its just to prepare us if need be.IMO we DONT CARE if our child will have issues.... 

Lexi-Lou*Dr SmellGood* --- 17 years ago -

its just to prepare us if need be agreed. 

Mz.MarineWifey --- 17 years ago -

we DONT CARE if our child will have issues.... i am so glad to see people mostly think like this =) i wish that is how everyone would be 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

Doctors don't know everything. So true...they said my eldest has Trisomy 18 and would die within 2 weeks....we did not abort....she ended up having Turners Syndrome and is doing awesome....... 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

Just a note, I didn't start this just because, there was an article I was reading (LINK) that said QUOTE "It is worth noting that over 90% of prenatally diagnosed babies with Down syndrome are killed through abortion, and that figure is climbing." So thats why I asked. It doesn't seem as if 90% of us would do that. more like 90% say no. LOL. Anyways, just thought I would post that. 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

It is worth noting that over 90% of prenatally diagnosed babies with Down syndrome are killed through abortion, and that figure is climbing." says who?? where are they getting this??I see babys with downs all the time in stores wo who is this 90%??? grrrrrrrrrrrrrrr 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

My grandma used to say daily "God gives special kids to special people and he won't give you anything you can't handle." That was before my son was even born. I guess I am lucky to have had the experience with her and see that it IS possible and to know that life is what you make it. I don't think it would ever dawn on me to abort a child. If your child would not survive it would perish in utero. If you get 4 minutes with a child before it passes, to look into it's eyes and say "I'm your mommy" what if that was meant to be. You could become an advocate for whatever condition the child suffered, make awareness of it. I am also pretty passionate about the subject. Both my son and uncle's conditions are "child birth related" not genetic. CP is most commonly caused by lack of oxygen in the birth canal. My son's is neurological prematurity. There is no way of predicting these things. I knew when I went into premature labor with my son that he could very well have any number of problems. We just wouldn't know until we got there. He was born very "physically healthy" It wasn't until he was a few years old that we knew how profound the issues were. Do you give them up then? No, that would make you a cold callous monster. I don't see how it could be any different to abort because something "may" be wrong. 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

I just send this to my gf 3 out of her 5 kids has Downs..... 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

CPP - i don't know where they got their stats....i just seen it in the article... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

health
parenting
polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground