Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: How do you feel about spanking your children??

who's talking here?

**ASH** 1
Formerly known as Shannon 1
ALEM 1
L4OT 1
Kristin 1
retta 4
Pasha 1
EastCoast 1
CourtesyFlush 1
Pretty Pretty Princess 2
Avash1177 21
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 23
Maureen 1
curlyqgirl 1
His Sally 1
jamieJam 1
♫Symphony♫ 1
*Navy*Wife* 1
Ashleigh$DDCTTT 1
Noah's Mommy 3
MICHELLE**aka MISS 305** 2
FreakinSweetie 19
Jacy's Memorable Moments Photo 1
DEsiree 1
Mommeee Drest 26
Bo§§ Lady 1
All Abouts 1
FixDaPix 1
penguin 17
Princess B 1
Kaci 1
♪Mikayla 4
Braydens Mommy 3
Oliver Clothesoff 1
*DesWithPassion* 1
LittleMissPreggo&Mommy 1
FurMama 1
Bella Vida 1
Goldfish 1
εїзJelly_Bean 1
Mrs. C 1
hawaiian50 1
Lissy 1
hgredhd83 1
Tiki 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: How do you feel about spanking your children??

This is not to start drama at all, I honestly wonder how other parents feel about it. If you do let me know why and if you don't let me know why!!

Totally Agree With It Vote
 
 85.1% (97)
Totally Disagree With It Vote
 
 14.0% (16)
I am practicing it at this moment :) Vote
 
 0.9% (1)
Braydens Mommy --- 17 years ago -

This is not to start drama at all, I honestly wonder how other parents feel about it. If you do let me know why and if you don't let me know why!! 

Pretty Pretty Princess --- 17 years ago -

Isn't it CA law that you can't spank your child? 

Bo§§ Lady --- 17 years ago -

Isn't it CA law that you can't spank your child? If it is SO many people are breaking that law. 

**ASH** --- 17 years ago -

Isn't it CA law that you can't spank your child? Hmm, well when they start supporting her and taking care of her 24/7 then we will talk. Until then it is MY kid and MY choice on how I discipline. 

Pretty Pretty Princess --- 17 years ago -

I was just wondering...I shall research it for myself. 

Braydens Mommy --- 17 years ago -

Until then it is MY kid and MY choice on how I discipline. i agree with this. i think there are limits but ultimately it is your child. sometimes a time out works for some children but not others. i don't want to be that mother that is in a store and my children are running wild all over the place... 

Jacy's Memorable Moments Photo --- 17 years ago -

Hmm, well when they start supporting her and taking care of her 24/7 then we will talk. Until then it is MY kid and MY choice on how I discipline. Exactly!! I agree with spanking your child. My mother never spanked us when we were young and we walked all over her, on the other hand my father did and he got respect from us. I dont believe in abusing your children. Spankning and abusing your children are 2 different things... Buts thats my opinion. 

MICHELLE**aka MISS 305** --- 17 years ago -

There isnt a halfway point here? I DONT BELIEVE in spanking your child for everything... it has to depend on what kind of situation. If its for a MAJOR REPEATED violation then yes, but even then an adult needs to control their temper. Some adults can let anger get to them and LEAVE BRUISES AND Such... THAT IS A NO-no!! I was raised with my mother leaving bruises on me (she wsnt beating me day to day or nothing) its just back then they werent as strict on "spanking" whereas now, anything can be reported to CPS. Anyhow, I dont believe in spanking constantly, but when a child is disrespectful... yes that deserves what I call a "pow-pow" lol 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

Isn't it CA law that you can't spank your child? I'm pretty sure it's not. I think they tried passing a bill a while back but it never went anywhere... BY THE WAY...the lady who was trying to get it to pass HAD NO CHILDREN. HMMM? 

Goldfish --- 17 years ago -

Spankning and abusing your children are 2 different things... Buts thats my opinion I totally agree with that. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

under California law, "... a parent has the right to reasonably discipline a child by physical punishment and may administer reasonable punishment without being liable for battery. In order to be considered disciplinary the punishment must:" bullet Be necessary (i.e. there it must be in response to a child's negative behavior). bullet Be reasonable, not excessive, in the judgment of a third party -- e.g. a Child Protective Services representative, or a law enforcement officer. Not sure how accurate is this 

Bella Vida --- 17 years ago -

I call a "pow-pow" lol LOL.. me too. I though I was the only one 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

There is a diff between spanking and abuse....I agree w/spanking 

Formerly known as Shannon --- 17 years ago -

I do believe in Spanking, but I don't. Very fortunate my children behave extremely well. Although broke down spanked my daughter at age 8 or 9 because she opened every single present for xmas even the ones that didn't belong to her. 

LittleMissPreggo&Mommy --- 17 years ago -

I believe in spanking. I was raised on it as was my husband and both of us turned out for the better. Personally, I think thats whats wrong with young ppl these days getting into trouble and all. Lack of disapline. Now I'm not going to go out a whale on my kid for soemthing. But I will pop them a couple times on the butt when they're young and move up to real spankings when they are older (bend over the knee with a couple lickins). If that doesnt work, my mom would always make me stand in the corner with my nose touching the wall and my hands behind my back. I wasn't allowed to lean. I only got one bathroom break and hour so I better make it a good one. The same way our parents raised us is how my husband and I plan on raising our kids. 

Pasha --- 17 years ago -

Personally, I don't do it because I know how it has no postitive effects on my kids at all. All is does is make them hostile and angry and hurt. But every kid is different.....what works for my kids might not work for someone else's kids. 

Oliver Clothesoff --- 17 years ago -

I don't know. I'm not excessive. I don't hand the spankings out like candy. For example My 18 month old repeatedly darts Into the street. After the 20th time saying no and him giggling about it thinking I was a game. He got his first butt spank. The look on his face was of sheer. Mommy how could you. Little lip stuck out and everything. He listens now. About the street at least. When it involved their safety like that. I won't bat an eye. 

εїзJelly_Bean --- 17 years ago -

i agree with spanking sometimes your kids like to walk all over you! and if you dont put your foot down at times they wont listen. i learned that from my 5 year old... 

Noah's Mommy --- 17 years ago -

I will spank when Noah is older but it has to be warranted. The punishment must fit the offense. For now smacking the hand lightly works when he grabs at things. He no longer plays with the blinds or grabs cords.undefined 

FreakinSweetie --- 17 years ago -

We do not spank. I will not spank, ever. Nor will my husband. We practice positive discipline. Its about the parent problem solving to find a different solution to the problem that is creating the negative behavior. 

Kristin --- 17 years ago -

Spanking my kids, no. Shipping them off to boarding school because somehow the royally screwed up and lost my trust in them, yes. 

hgredhd83 --- 17 years ago -

My mama spanked us and let me tell you we grew up respecting her and others. I spank my daughter, the time out method only works with daddy. If anyone has a problem with it they can spend a day with her! :) 

Mrs. C --- 17 years ago -

I don't have children and I have no problem with spanking and if need be when the day comes that my husband and I do have children it may become an option. My dad spanked me when I was acting up (which was often when I was very young) but it all stopped after one evening we were at a family dinner and I was being a brat, my dad threatened to take me outside for a spanking and I kept repeating my offenses, he followed through on his threat, took me outside the front doors of the restaurant, spanked me in public (humliating!), and from then on out all he had to do was ask if I wanted to go outside. That one time put an end to all my bratty behavior and it wasn't so much that I was afraid to be humiliated in public due to getting spanked, I really didn't want people to know that I acted up. The first and last public spanking was humiliating but I never felt that my dad was purposely threatening to humiliate me by a public spanking. I agree that not all punishments work with all children. You have to discipline accordingly. 

Braydens Mommy --- 17 years ago -

well my parents both spanked me. my dad did most of the time but every once in a while my mom would get mad enough to do it. let me tell you, i deserved it. i was a little brat growing up and you know what? i'm perfectly fine. it's not like they beat me..and i learned to respect my dad and my mom. when they said do something i did it. i think i love them more for it today. 

hawaiian50 --- 17 years ago -

i believe in it.period. 

Lissy --- 17 years ago -

spanking is the only way i can get my son to listen to me, but i don't like to because i feel like i am hurting his feelings 

curlyqgirl --- 17 years ago -

I do not spank my child. I don't think it is wrong for others to do it. 

Mommeee Drest --- 17 years ago -

My husband and I are firm believers in spanking... however, we are also firm believers that it's the last resort. If I give my child a verbal warning in a calm voice and she does not choose to listen to what I am saying/asking, then I repeat what I said/asked along with a reminder that this is the last time I will be asking and the next time I have to ask/tell then she will either get spanked or grounded. I think three chances are enough after that, it's not my fault if you get spanked in front of your friends. Or you get grounded and can't go to the movies. I always tell them "learn to listen"... the older they get the less we seem to spank. 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

I used to be against it. I was never spanked growing up my husband was though. As soon as we found out we were pregnant with our first we said we wouldn't spank him. Right now though he's 3 and tests us so much. We warn him but sometimes he just does not listen. We now occasionally spank him 

L4OT --- 17 years ago -

i dont have any kids but if i did i would spank them for doing something bad (depending on what the "bad" was). i was raised that way, and believe you me it is a very affective method. now dont get me wrong, i wouldn't beat my kid but some kids just need a good old fashioned spanking. sitting/standing in the corner just doesn't cut it sometimes. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground