it didnt work for me. Is this the article about the picture of the Marine that was injured and then died? If so.. they shouldve respected the family's wishes and not published it.
thats the article in question about the marine.. im so sad it made me cry.. i think its wrong for them to be displaying that pic. with out the parents consent
I was just reading this to my hubby, father and aunt. They ALL are vets of gulf wars (1st and 2nd) and they ALL feel, while they should have waited a bit longer to release it, if he signed the release for the embeded reporter then he knew this could happen and HIS wishes are what matters most.
My husband said he would want them to tell his story, no matter how harsh, becuase thats how people get just how real and emotional this stuff gets.
I know if it were my husband/child/family member I would like them to tell the story, pictures and all. This shows the country just how harsh our Marines have it and its keeps them from being just another name on a page, theres an image and a real face to go with it.
if he signed the release for the embeded reporter
Do they actually sign releases? I was never around reporters when I was over there. Out of curiosity?!
"To ignore a moment like that simply ... would have been wrong. I was recording his impending death, just as I had recorded his life moments before walking the point in the bazaar," she said. "Death is a part of life and most certainly a part of war. Isn't that why we're here? To document for now and for history the events of this war?"
Later, she showed members of his squad all the images taken that day and the Marines flipped through them on her computer one by one.
"They did stop when they came to that moment," she said. "But none of them complained or grew angry about it. They understood that it was what it was. They understand, despite that he was their friend, it was the reality of things."
I think it should be showed, because alot of people don't know what's really going on. They don't know until they see. The closet they might get is a picture.
This is reality.
if you go to the ap site they have the pic in question.
its not that its graphic because i dont think it is, i saw worse from my grandfathers wwi pics. i guess people dont like to realize that people are dying over there. and its scary to some to think about it.
I couldn't even finish watching the pics, Im to scared of what I might see. All you fellow marine wives know how hard it is to hear something like this, but now to actually see it is an outrage!!
All you fellow marine wives know how hard it is to hear something like this, but now to actually see it is an outrage!!
See I dont think it is, i think it honored him.
Do they actually sign releases? I was never around reporters when I was over there. Out of curiosity?!
When both my brothers had embeded reporters they signed releases so im assuming its the norm.
My husband had a reporter inbeded with his unit and he did not sign a release to my knowledge. He was in time magazine and in countless newspapers. They did not even realize most of the time that their picture was being taken.
"To ignore a moment like that simply ... would have been wrong. I was recording his impending death, just as I had recorded his life moments before walking the point in the bazaar," she said. "Death is a part of life and most certainly a part of war. Isn't that why we're here? To document for now and for history the events of this war?"
My sociology prf told us that journalists are lazy people. How true that statement is! She didn't take that picture to honor him or what he died for. She took it to gain attention. She expolited him while he was dying for us. For that, I hope she burns.
My husband had a reporter inbeded with his unit and he did not sign a release to my knowledge
I just asked my hubby and he said he never signed a release form and they had an embedded reporter. But he also said he would want the pictures out there. So if no release was signed they should have listened to the family! It would upset me to have to wake up to my hubby's picture everywhere after something like this happened. Now that he has told me the way he feels I would allow it to be printed but it would still upset me.
i posted this earlier but it's prolly on like page 5 now LOL
i think they shouldn't have published it just out of respect for the family. they didn't want it published, yet they disregarded it.
the picture of my husband was of him and a doctor carrying a wounded marine on a stretcher, he had no idea that picture was even taken, and that it would be seen around the world. i think i would not want a picture of my husband dying to be released, but it is an unfortunate reality. i guess i am torn on it, i feel for his family and what they must be going through.
This was just horrible-----my husband put that young man into the MC when he was on RD....he is just sick about this. He was a great kid & honestly died doing what he loved
I feel very sorry for his family, but I think that Americans need to see the truth. People push war into the back of their head and hang their little f*cking gay yellow ribbons and think that they are somehow fulfilling their patriotic duties and go about with their humble, protected little daily lives, while members of the military are dying. They need to see the truth. It's not the press's fault that the government has not yet convinced people of the valid reasons for being over there. If we're big enough to fight a war then we should be big enough to look at it.
I see no reason in sanitizing all the images of war being published. That defeats the point of journalism. You just have to know where to draw the line and I don't think that photo was all that graphic or disrespectful in any way.
I'm just ecstatic that it's ok for so many young (and old) men and women to die fighting a war for this country, but we're all too f*cking pussy to look at it.
clarification.. i dont think its wrong to publish it if no one objects but if the family said not to print it.. i think their decision should be respected.
my hubby had a reporter with them but never signed anything.
This doesn't honor him. The family gets to look at that picture day after day looking at their son dying. They will spend the rest of their lives looking at it thinking "what if". I think it was irresponsible. Why not ask a family of someone who wouldn't mind having their dying Marine in a picture? That would be a helluva lot more honorable than this trashy journalist.
I'm not trying to sound rude or challenge you but how does it honor him?
It makes him REAL, not just another name on the casuality list, theres a picture, a full story and full emotion that more often then not we DONT get. THis picture, this story shows people who dont live with it every day, what these brave men do every day. I honors his sacrifice to trully show it in all its entirety and not make him just another name on the list.
I dare you ALL to ask your husbands if they would want thier full story, pics and all, told. I am pretty sure they would all agree with my hubby. Its different coming from the spouse or family point of view as apposed to the active duty point of view.