I have a neighbor who constantly YELLS at her little boy. He doesn't look any older than 3 years old. I don't talk to her or know her. I will smile if we make eye contact. And even if I did know her, I don't think I would feel comfortable critizing her parenting skills. The yelling isn't normal frustrated mom yelling. In my opinion it's over the top, not necessary yelling for a 3 year old. She's not even my next door neighbor but the neighbor in front of me, up the hill. So that gives you an idea how far she is from me & how loud she is for me to hear it clearly. In your opinion, is yelling at your child so intensely that the neighbors can hear "OK" or verbal abuse?
I will admit that I sometimes feel like screaming at Hunter....like right now. However, I wouldn't do it. That is way too far for you to be able to hear it and it still be considered "okay".
Remind her that what you put into a child is what you get out. If she yells at him all the time, then he's gonna learn that yelling is the way he has to communicate in order to be heard. I don't know how you'd go about that tactfully. Maybe write an anonymous letter and mail it to her. I'm sure she'll be pissed at first and then realize that maybe she needs to tone it down.
Just curious, but what does it matter what other people's opinions are? Do you intend on telling her something and you're just looking on here for reassurance?
Oh no, this child is not hard of hearing. It's the tone she is yelling with that lets me know that she is frustrated & taking it out on the child. He likes to play outside & from our front windows we can hear when his dad plays with him & he never yells at the boy. I know it's wrong to judge when you don't know the whole situation but it's really bad when she yells at him. She yells for little things. Like, "MOVE OUT OF THE WAY!" "SHUT UP!" the list goes on & on. It's her tone that lets me know that neither of them is hard of hearing.
I know it's wrong to judge when you don't know the whole situation but it's really bad when she yells at him. She yells for little things. Like, "MOVE OUT OF THE WAY!" "SHUT UP!" the list goes on & on. It's her tone that lets me know that neither of them is hard of hearing.
Again, I'm failing to see the point in talking about it if you don't intend to confront her about it. I don't think you need to/ should either way becuase as you said, you don't know the entire situation. Just leave it alone.
i would mind my own business.. unless you think there is a reason to step in..
That's what I'm trying to figure out. That is why I asked. I don't know if it's my place as a neighbor/a concerned citizen of this childs welfare to step in.
Maybe offer to watch her little boy... to give her a break? Express your concern & offering to help at the same time.
that is a good idea but wouldn't it be weird if one of you neighbors randomly approached you about watching your kid? How would you go about that?
I don't know if it's my place as a neighbor/a concerned citizen of this childs welfare to step in.
If you're concerned about it, call CPS. They won't tell the parents who contacted them, that information is confidential, and it'll either get the mother some assistance, or let her know that someone has concerns over her child's welfare.
That's what I'm trying to figure out. That is why I asked. I don't know if it's my place as a neighbor/a concerned citizen of this childs welfare to step in
I don't think you'll get a good idea of what to do from consulting PU. We know less than what you know. Just get to know her.
If you're concerned about it, call CPS. They won't tell the parents who contacted them, that information is confidential, and it'll either get the mother some assistance, or let her know that someone has concerns over her child's welfare.
I've thought about that for a while now. I wanted to hear some of your opinions as mothers/neighbors before I made that decision. That's why I asked, what would you do?
That's why I asked, what would you do?
I wouldn't call if I don't know anything else besides her yelling. If you saw her stike him in a way that could be deemed abuse or their house was unfit for a child of his age to be living in then I'd MAYBE call. I'd need a lot more than, "I hear her yelling at him form down the street"
No, that is why I felt it would be important to get a mothers opinion or thoughts. I have been a caregiver for children with down syndrome so I know what it is like to deal with difficult children. But even in that situation, I could never imagine yelling at a toddler to "shut up". I can understand frustration as a parent because I have friends with kids & I have seen them "yell" when frustrated if they aren't staying in time out or what not. But the things she yells about could easily be spoken not yelled. I appreciate all of the feedback. You all have given me good ideas & before I do or say anything I think I am going with the opinion of getting to know her. Maybe then I could get a better grasp of why she is the way she is with her son.
Yea you dont completely understand a parents frustrations YET anyways. Personally I would never tell my kids to 'shut up' and yell at them as bad as Ive seen. I have heard some awful things come out of a parents mouth to their 3 yr old child..that I would NEVER tell anyone. BUT..I dont feel as though its my place..we are 'friends' but not close enough to where I could say something like that..I just avoid her at all costs.
What housing do you live in? I know that in my housing area or house aren't even connected by walls, but I can hear my neighbors yell at their children. But I also know if I walk down the street and my son is yelling for me or his dad we can still hear him. Sometimes neighborhoods echo, and sound louder than they really are. Before you call CPS why don't you get to know them first before jumping to conclusion. Sometimes if you should just tell your neighbor your concerns first maybe they don't realize what is going on, (hard to believe but sometimes it happens). But if after you talk to them then and things don't get fixed, then take another step. Other wise you are wasting CPS time, and that is not right.
again talk to them first and then if nothing comes of it then try another step.
I have a two year old. I feel bad for my neighbors. My daughter has a temper and when things do not go her way she will throw a fit and scream at the top of her lungs. But what can I do but let her stay in her room and throw her fit once she is done I talk to her about it
Ok, let's be honest here, you can't know how you would be as a parent until you are one. So your experience with the children with down syndrome is experience, it is not being a parent. Now personally I would never tell my child or anyone elses for that matter to shut up, but honestly, lets look at the slang and language now-a-days, that is how some people have been brought up and it is their "norm" so she may not think anything of it. Also, you hear her yelling, but did you hear her quitely say "please move for mommy, please be quiet, please do this elsewhere" the 5 to 10 times before she yelled? So of course you're going to hear frustration in her voice. As SAHM we are the caretakers, the cleaners, the tutors, the taxi drivers, grocery getters and everything else that life decides to throw at us that day so until you know what is going on quietly or behind closed doors stay out of it. If it warrants physical, emotional or sexual abuse by all means call CPS but if she is not calling her child degrading names and just yelling she's probably told them more than one time that you didn't hear. Also, I have seen many parents substitute yelling for spankings and a slew of other punishments, so maybe thats a way to look at it. And one last thought...you said you've seen the Dad do fine without yelling...AM I the ONLY one here whose children act like angels when Daddy is around and turn a complete 180 when he leaves. If you observed my family you'd see my husband never raises his voice, he doesn't have to. But when hes gone sometimes I have to to even get a head to turn my direction. But then again, you wouldn't see this part of it. So honestly unless you see some true cruelty to this child mind your own business.
But then again, you wouldn't see this part of it. So honestly unless you see some true cruelty to this child mind your own business.
I completely agree with you!
i yell at my 3 yr old when i keep having to tell her time and time again to not do something or to do something. staying at home all day does get frustrating... but i don't think any of my neighbors hear me yell at her...she never gets that bad i guess...
maybe she is substituting yelling for spankin and maybe her kid just won't listen...i mean unless you heard excessive yelling, a few slaps, then a child crying like someone's beatin him...i don't think it's something you need to call cps about..
tho my kid sometimes cries like someone's beating her just when i put her in time out...lol....kids...
tho my kid sometimes cries like someone's beating her just when i put her in time out...lol....kids...
mine too. but what can ya do. I don't want to change my parenting skills over something like that