Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Military Medical Malpractice - Research

who's talking here?

Joe Momma 2
O G docswife 1
Spare Change Rainbows 2
CoCo 11
Mommy Cruz 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 1
Ruthie 1
Thread Killer 1
Barbara 2
Mason's Mom 3
MOMx4 ¾ 1
ღHollyDeeღ 1
3lilmunchkins 1
Lebowski 1
VA♥girl 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

I am writing an article about military medical malpractice. As some of you may know, active duty service members may not sue the government for medical malpractice because receiving medical care in a government facility is considered activity incident to service, and service members may not sue for injuries incurred during activity that is incident to their service. This bar to suit is the result of a Supreme Court ruling which has come to be known as the Feres doctrine. The Supreme Court believed that service members should not be able to sue the government because it would interfere with military discipline and because there is already adequate compensation in place. Right now there is legislation before Congress, the Carmelo Rodriguez Military Medical Accountability Act of 2009, which would overturn this ruling and allow service members to bring suit for injuries arising from poor medical care, excepting injuries which arise out of combat activities. I am interested in your thoughts about the Feres doctrine. Do you think this doctrine affects the quality of healthcare service members receive? What do you think about the quality of care you and your spouse receive at government medical facilities? Do you believe you or your spouse have been the victim of medical malpractice? What do you think about the Carmelo Rodriguez Military Medical Accountability Act? Should Congress change the current law? If you do not feel comfortable expressing your thoughts openly, feel free to send me a PM. Also, let me know if you have any questions I can answer. 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

I am posting this to open up a discussion about the Feres doctrine and to hear feedback from military families who receive care in government facilities. Thanks in advance for your help. 

Lebowski --- 16 years ago -

What is your personal connection to the Feres Doctrine or the bill that is before Congress? 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

I am a law student and I am writing an article for school about this topic. In addition to that, I am a military wife and so this affects me personally, as it does all military families. 

Thread Killer --- 16 years ago -

As a military spouse, you cannot sue the military health care system/facilities/doctors as well. 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

As a military spouse, you cannot sue the military health care system/facilities/doctors as well. Actually, dependents can sue if the injury is to them and not the service member. For example, if a surgeon left a sponge in you (the wife) during surgery, you could bring suit for negligence. However, if this same thing happened to the active duty service member, he could not bring suit. In addition, if your spouse died, you could not bring suit for wrongful death or loss of consortium because the claim arises out of HIS injury. 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

As a military spouse, you cannot sue the military health care system/facilities/doctors as well. And just to clarify, when someone brings suit against the government for medical malpractice, the defendant is the United States (as the employer), not the individual doctor actually responsible for the injury. 

Ruthie --- 16 years ago -

Carmelo Rodriguez My heart goes out to his family, I wish his story was more known! 

ღHollyDeeღ --- 16 years ago -

Some people are not familiar with the Carmelo act. You may want to post background info on him and how it originated. 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

My heart goes out to his family, I wish his story was more known! That's a good point Ruthie. For those who do not know: Sgt. Carmelo Rodriguez was a Marine who died from cancer. When he enlisted in the Marine Corps in 1997, at his physical, doctors noted that he had melanoma on his buttock. Unfortunately, Carmelo was never informed of his condition and there was no recommendation for further treatment. Seven years later while serving in Iraq, Carmelo sought treatment for a growth on his buttock that was worrying him. Over the next two years, doctors repeatedly misdiagnosed the growth as a wart or birthmark although it began bleeding and leaking pus. Out of frustration, Carmelo made an appointment with a dermatologist without a referral and was told that he had stage 3 melanoma. Carmelo died in November 2007 at age 29. 

Joe Momma --- 16 years ago -

I think that everyone should be held accountable for your actions or services. As a doctor, you know that things can and will go wrong which is why there is malpractice insurance for medical personnel. How is it right for service members to not be able to hold someone accountable for their actions when it is dertmental to their health? I mean, military people depend on their health to be in top notch form and if that gets f'ed up then it is their career that is over too. 

Barbara --- 16 years ago -

Being a spouse and seeing stuff like this happen and hearing the stories that come out of Marines who refuse to go to medical, though they need to I feel that this is an issue that needs to be taken a good lok at. I think that the Carmelo Act does need to go through because I feel that it would help service members get the medical attention that they need and not just given the magic pill of motrin for everything because if these "medical professionals" are not being held accountable then maybe they would pay a little more attention to what they are doing and out military members would not be afraid to seek the medical attention that they need. I'm sure someon will have something to say but this is the reality. Iam not active duty but I am a spouse who has persoanlly been misdiagnoised and fromj what they said was "stress" was actualy a brain tumor that was cancer with a grade of 3. They gave me the run around for 4 months! Had I not been treated when I finally was I would have died. 

Barbara --- 16 years ago -

Sorry for the misspelling, my fingers could not keep up with my brain... Also, I do have to say that there are AWESOME doctors in the military but they are very few and hard to come by. 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

Thanks for everyone's input so far. I read a LOT of "rants" about the care received at the Naval Hospital on Camp Pendleton. I wanted to open this discussion to really get a feel for what military families think about the current quality of healthcare. 

Joe Momma --- 16 years ago -

My husband broke his wrist at PT. He went to medical and was told that it was sprained. He continued to PT on a wrist that was swollen and very painful b/c medical did not give light duty. He went back to medical and was given XRays again. Again, he was told it was sprained. He went back to medical. Xrays for the 3rd time. Was told that his wrist was broken and what yahoo missed it in the first 2 sets of Xrays. My husband's response "Sir, I have been seen by you the other 2 times that I was here and you said twice that my wrist was only sprained." Dead silence. After being seen by Ortho at Balboa (the bones did not heal properly because of the continued used and not being set) he had a cyst removed for the bones for bone chips getting infected and cortizone shots to ease pain. He is also now in need of surgery and for the bones to be rebroken to correct something that could have all been prevented if someone would have actually read the Xrays the first time. By the way this was a break in several places not just a hairline fracture. Was there anything that he could have done to make sure that this does not happen to anyone else? Nope! Not a dang thing. In the "real" world this would not be acceptable from any medical pro and malpratice suits would follow. 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

Xrays for the 3rd time. Was told that his wrist was broken and what yahoo missed it in the first 2 sets of Xrays. My husband's response "Sir, I have been seen by you the other 2 times that I was here and you said twice that my wrist was only sprained." Dead silence. Wow, that is amazing. 

Spare Change Rainbows --- 16 years ago -

Coco, Im glad your writing about this. I personally feel that military members should be able to sue over legitiment things. Its rediculas that military members at times recieve sub-standard care that can be damnaging to them. For people to think that military members already are compensated enough is just nuts. people make mistakes, and they should be held accountable for them. Not this Oh well your in the military so you dont deserve to get the care everyone in the " free world " gets. 

Mommy Cruz --- 16 years ago -

As a military spouse, you cannot sue the military health care system/facilities/doctors as well. Not totally true. There are ways around it. I am a military spouse and I just sued the Navy for the wrongfull death and medical neglect of my son. 

Spare Change Rainbows --- 16 years ago -

this is true, only the MILITARY member can't sue... dependants arn't held to that standard, and most certainly can sue 

MOMx4 ¾ --- 16 years ago -

Coco, just out of curiosity, are you doing any comparison with civilian malpractice at all? 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

bump for those who did not see this yesterday and have a comment on this issue 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

Coco, just out of curiosity, are you doing any comparison with civilian malpractice at all? Yes, I do a breakdown of the actual compensation received and explain why it is inadequate. Or I guess I should clarify: I am in the process of doing that! My article is not finished yet. 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 16 years ago -

Coco, just out of curiosity, are you doing any comparison with civilian malpractice at all? great question...Ive seen some reall horror shows on this My heart goes out to his family so sad 

Mason's Mom --- 16 years ago -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=65Cqxio4_ow Watch this. So incredibly sad. 

Mason's Mom --- 16 years ago -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=65Cqxio4_ow Watch this. So incredibly sad. 

Mason's Mom --- 16 years ago -

carmelo rodriguez hope i linked that right! 

3lilmunchkins --- 16 years ago -

Coco, one of my closest girlfriends just got surgery on her breasts because they noticed possible cancerous cells. After her surgery she has lost alot of feeling in left arm (?) and is not able to reach above her head. The doctors have acknowledged they did something wrong during surgery and the Army was trying to make her get out medically (she is active duty). I can call her if you want her story, just let me know! 

VA♥girl --- 16 years ago -

My husband was building something with one of his guys, and a piece of wood they were all carrying slipped, and out of habit he threw his leg up to help catch it. In the process, it slapped his thigh. He came home and could not even walk up the stairs. I yell at him all the time when he hurts himself to go to medical, but he has seen the docs do just crazy things. He is also gung ho MC, that he didn't want to take the chance of going light-duty and taken off the TO. We went to go get massages one day, and the masseuse told us, that he had a torn muscle, and that he had to be looked at. My hubby goes to the doc, where he asked my husband before even examining him if he was sure he wanted to be seen, if he found something he'd have to be put on light duty, if he was a torn muscle the doc could give him ibeoprofen (not sure of spelling), and that should help it heal. So of course he left. IMO that should have never been asked, and they should have seen him and cared for him. I now pay for insurance through my company for both my husband and I, so that he can be seen out in town. Hopefully the next time he hurts himself, he'll go to the urgent care. 

CoCo --- 16 years ago -

Thank you so much to everyone who has shared their stories with me! I really appreciate all of the input. This article by no means is meant to lambast military doctors in particular but to draw attention to an injustice against military families. From my research and from reading this board over the years and from talking with some of you specifically through this thread, I think a common theme is the lack of confidence in the military healthcare system. I think this is a direct result of the Feres bar, because by keeping "mistakes" relatively inexpensive to make, it fosters an atmosphere where people are not accountable for egregious errors, and all members of the military community are aware of that fact. 

O G docswife --- 16 years ago -

vagurl if your husband hurts himself and is seen out in town, he will still be put on LD though if he is hurt. and if he did not go in and be seen right away, how can he be mad at the doctors? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground