I believe in equal rights for all, and if a homosexual wants to serve in the a military for a country that won't even allow them equal rights, more power to them.
IMO, the don't ask don't tell policy keeps gays and lesbians safe. Not everyone is open minded about homosexuality and unfortunately, there are some enlisted military who won't take too kindly to an out of the closet homosexual.
I believe in equal rights for all, and if a homosexual wants to serve in the a military for a country that won't even allow them equal rights, more power to them.
I agree!
IMO, the don't ask don't tell policy keeps gays and lesbians safe. Not everyone is open minded about homosexuality and unfortunately, there are some enlisted military who won't take too kindly to an out of the closet homosexual.
If there is a policy allowing gays to be open in the military, then it's up to that person whether they want to share that part of their life with their coworkers or not.
I think it does have positives, because like lacy said, there are people who are not supportive. My only problem with it is that its against UCMJ to even be in a same sex relationship. If you are gay, it shouldnt even be an issue, it should never have to be asked if you are, that info is not very pertinent to your job. I dont think if youre in a same sex rationship you should have to worry about getting caught, or be scared to bring your significant other to a family day.
My only problem with it is that its against UCMJ to even be in a same sex relationship.
It's also against Marine Corps rules to give your husband head.. sooo.. you might want to rethink that argument.
I am personally not a huge fan of this change. It's apparent that there are closet homos within the Military, but this may open up for possible harrassment issues. Just my opinion, though! :)
I am personally not a huge fan of this change. It's apparent that there are closet homos within the Military, but this may open up for possible harrassment issues. Just my opinion, though! :)
And again, it is up to each individual whether they want to share their sexual preference with their coworkers. If they don't want anyone to know, they won't tell anyone. The end.
And again, it is up to each individual whether they want to share their sexual preference with their coworkers. If they don't want anyone to know, they won't tell anyone. The end.
True...just glad my husband is reserves now. lol
I don't think that DADT accomplishes what it was intended to. In theory it sounded good, but it is a failed policy. Discharges due to being gay actually rose following it's implementation and 80% of those discharged were never have found to have committed any actual homosexual act. Also the way it is implemented any accusation of being gay can ruin you. If you fight a discharge you can receive a dishonorable discharge which will severely impact your entire future. There have been people who are not gay who have been discharged due to the false accusation of someone with a vendetta and they can't fight it.
I don't think that DADT accomplishes what it was intended to. In theory it sounded good, but it is a failed policy. Discharges due to being gay actually rose following it's implementation and 80% of those discharged were never have found to have committed any actual homosexual act. Also the way it is implemented any accusation of being gay can ruin you. If you fight a discharge you can receive a dishonorable discharge which will severely impact your entire future. There have been people who are not gay who have been discharged due to the false accusation of someone with a vendetta and they can't fight it.
The only way to fix this problem is to either completely ban it.. and well, still have the same issues.. or to allow it. I say allow it. :)
Also, I wanted to add that I don't think it's right that our military is the only employer that has still been allowed to discriminate. The arguments against allowing openly gay individuals to serve usually include unit cohesion and morale, and yet all the studies done on this, both of our own military and of our allies that do allow openly gay to serve, refute that cohesion or morale are impacted.
I fully understand the concern that this issue brings for many, and I don't know what the right answer is, but I don't know if there can truly be a perfect answer for everyone. There never is.
IMO, the don't ask don't tell policy keeps gays and lesbians safe. Not everyone is open minded about homosexuality and unfortunately, there are some enlisted military who won't take too kindly to an out of the closet homosexual.
Couldn't agree more!
I don't see how people can argue that it keeps someone safe... It will up to their own discretion to share their sexual preference and if they want to.. well, then it's their life and they are the ones dealing. Not you. It's not YOUR place to make the decision.
Manda, have you ever been prosecuted for giving your husband a bj? Or even heard of anybody? But people are being prosecuted for being gay. Thats why I dont like DADT.
Like Lavender said, its good in theory, but there are problems with it. Personally, I dont care if you are gay or straight. Just keep it behind closed doors.
Also like I said, that subject should never come up at work and effect your job anyways. I like dont ask dont tell because I dont care what you are, do your job and do it right. Like i said before, it sucks that people need to hide it. You should be able to bring your significant other to family day, or a homecoming without fearing its going to effect your career. I believe it was put in place with good intentions, but its not perfect
Manda, have you ever been prosecuted for giving your husband a bj? Or even heard of anybody? But people are being prosecuted for being gay. Thats why I dont like DADT.
So, allow it so that no one can be prosecuted. It's no one's business who is gay and who is not.. so, allow it so that no one can be prosecuted.
Manda, not everyone in the military is as open-minded as you are. It is no ones business whether someone is gay or straight but that doesn't mean there aren't the extreme cases of ignorance and violent occurances.
Yes, I understand that.. but it's up to the individual whether they want to share that or not.. and if they do decide to share that, then they are the adult who made the decision and has to deal with the reactions of those around them. The end.
It's very close minded to assume that that one gay dude in the shower is going to be attracted to all the guys in the shower. They are just as capable of minding their own business and taking a shower.
I watched last nights episode of Real World this morning since we are not late nighters. It made me sad for Tanner and Mike. Tanner came for a visit and then went home and outed himself to his parents. They were very harse on him. Asked if they needed to sell the farm and move.
It makes me sad people can't be who they are without torment and harassment.
I seriously hate the shower excuse. After boot camp and mct how often does your husband shower with other men?
Besides, even when I was in basic, I didnt have time to think if the girl next to me was staring. I had enough sh!t on my brain and the drill sergeant yelling 'you have 30 seconds to wash your hair!' '45 seconds to wash your body!' Kept my mind off that shiz.
If you are THAT worried about being stared at in the shower, you have issues anyway.
Besides, what makes you think that gay person finds every single male/female attractive?