Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Essure vs. Vasectomy?

who's talking here?

Maureen 1
YazminsCreations 1
IrishTwinsx2plus1 1
KayCee 7
Mommeee Drest 1
B*Bright 4
Lavender is Good 1
Brandie 2
Crimson Nape Duchess 2
❤ me 1
MRMBR 1
~Sara~ 1
LakerGirl 5
SusseTraume 2
Mrs. Taken 1
BadMomma 1
??? 1
LilyB 11
♠VivaLaDoll♠ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

Ok so.. I've been married before and have 2 wonderful boys as a result of that marriage. I recently married again-this time for good!-to someone who does not have any kids, but considers mine his own. I'm really lucky to have him, he is amazing! We do not want anymore children, but I've heard alot of horror stories about getting tubal litigation (tubes tied), so I've been thinking about either Essure or a Vasectomy. My questions are: has anyone had essure and had any side effects? And personal opinions on my new hubby getting clipped? He doesn't mind doing it but I feel guilty even thinking about it, we're only 23. 

KayCee --- 16 years ago -

the military most likely wont let either of you doit. you have to pretty much beg if your under a certain age..have no childrn together and if you havent been married for very long.
good luck!
i had my tubes tied back in 08.. i havent had any thing bad happen with it..lol 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

:( wonderful. I'll beg though if needed- have had Mirena almost year and a half, and really not happy with it. I was really thinking about getting my tubes tied, but I started researching and reading alot of really bad stuff, I didn't research Mirena before I got it and now wished I would have. Idk what to do. 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

the military most likely wont let either of you doit. you have to pretty much beg if your under a certain age..have no childrn together and if you havent been married for very long.

Not necessarily true. My husband is getting a vasectomy in August & we have no kids.

To be honest I've never heard of Essure. The procedure doesn't sound pleasant though. (Not that a vasectomy does, either.) 

YazminsCreations --- 16 years ago -

I was told for tubes tide you had to be 25 or have 3 kids. Hubby was told he had to be I think 25 or something not to sure so don't quote me or have 3 kids. Not sure how they do it now this was a few years back.

I guess for now you can stick with birth control 

KayCee --- 16 years ago -

Not necessarily true. My husband is getting a vasectomy in August & we have no kids.
he must of got lucky then. ive known lots of people that have 3+ kids and married for ever and get denied... 

KayCee --- 16 years ago -

I was told for tubes tide you had to be 25 or have 3 kids. Hubby was told he had to be I think 25 or something not to sure so don't quote me or have 3 kids. Not sure how they do it now this was a few years back.
its still like that.. i have no idea how was able to get it done. i was 24 with 2 kids. might have something to with being seen by the same ob for over 5 years..
who knows.
i have had friend older with more children get told no.
also if you are approved you have to sign the consent form and wait 30 days to get it done 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

he must of got lucky then. ive known lots of people that have 3+ kids and married for ever and get denied... 


I'm not gonna go into it again but if you search 'vasectomy' you'll see my previous post & why we were probably approved.

I'm sure it's a case by case basis, Nohea. You guys are going to have to decide what works best for you two. It doesn't matter what our opinion is of your husband getting "clipped" (LOL, btw) its your opinion that matters. 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

To be honest I've never heard of Essure. The procedure doesn't sound pleasant though. (Not that a vasectomy does, either.)

Essure takes like 10 minutes and is relatively painless. they insert these things that block your tubes and they form scars to completely block any sperm from entering. completely permanent though, no reversals. I watched the video someone posted the other day about a vasectomy- I can usually handle medical stuff more than most, but for some reason I only made it half way through that one! 

MRMBR --- 16 years ago -

Essure doesn't necessarily take 10 minutes- at the NH they give you your choice of anything from just an ibuprofen for the procedure, all of the way up to conscious sedation. I chose conscious sedation, so I was there for a total of a few hours, but not too long overall (and I was really happy with the same day surgery staff). One thing about Essure, though- you wouldn't know in advance, but if they can't see the openings to your tubes, then they can't place the coils. I have 3 kids and had no idea the inside of my uterus is covered in scar tissue. She said on one side, it was totally covered, and on the other, I had 3 little "puckerings" one of which might have been an opening, but it's possible none of them were (it would be pointless to do one side anyway). My husband ended up getting a vasectomy (though our original intention was for both of us to get it done). He had a very easy time with the procedure and the recovery- it was textbook.
When I went to the class, I don't remember them actually saying anything about a specific age or number of kids, though they did tell me to think long and hard because I was only 29, and there's a much higher regret rate under 30. It made me laugh, though, because my son was born in June '07, and I turned 30, 2 months later, in August. 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

Ty MRMBR, I didn't know that about seeing the tubes but I guess it does make sense. My husband and I have been discussing it for a little while and which ever way we go, we will wait a little while longer just to go over all options and make the right choice. Like I said he has no prob with the vasectomy, but I really don't want him to regret it later on. I have no problem with only 2 kids, these boys are a handful! 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

Also, I don't know if this has already been covered Nohea, but with a Vasectomy, if 10 years from now your husband changes his mind and desides he does want a child, at least there is a good chance a vasectomy can be reversed. It is not 100% but you odds are better than if sterilization is done on the woman. 

??? --- 16 years ago -

I got the Essure and ended having to turn around and get my fallopian tubes removed. I would say to have him do a vasectomy. If it is for medical reasons Tricare will cover the Essure. My husband got a vasectomy also after having to do a bunch of stuff for Tricare to approve it because we are both 23. They usually require you to be 25. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

if 10 years from now your husband changes his mind

yes! as you are both 23 and this is your 2nd marriage statistics isnt on your side im afraid (but i hope im wrong)

i would def consider putting some of your hubbys swimmers on ice if you go ahead with the vasectomy, afterall you/he might change your minds in 5yrs time and decide to have a little one 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

I will definatley keep this all in mind. I know that we are young and sadly I know that statistics aren't on my side as you said Lorraine and we are keeping this all in consideration. Thank you for the advice ladies! 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

if you are not 100% sure yet but don't like the idea of hormonal birth control, you can also get the paragard IUD....it's basically the same as mirena, but no hormones are in the paragard one... website

It's also good for 10 years...by then you would be 33 and know for sure if you are done with kids or not...i'm only 23 as well and i'm done with kids too...but i have 3. but hubs is 27 so as soon as the boys are 6 months old (my ob told me our youngest kids have to be 6 months old before hubs can get snipped) then he is going under the knife....but i too want to get something permanently done....i DO NOT want to get pregnant again!!! 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

Wow, I've never heard of paragard, but it sounds awesome. I LOVE the fact that it's hormone free! Might have to check this out with the doc, ty B*Bright!!
I'm right there with you on getting something permanent done, I def. don't want to get pregnant again, but if this works well, I might trade my mirena for this. That's awesome that it lasts 10 years! 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

I really would not recommend doing anything permanent at your age. I'm 29 and I think I'm still too young to do something permanent. That's a lot of time to potentially change one's mind, and it's really expensive if you change your mind. 

Mrs. Taken --- 16 years ago -

I had a Tubes tied 6 mo ago and never had any issues. Good Luck! 

~Sara~ --- 16 years ago -

Depends on you....... I couldnt stand the thought of having something permanently inside me after my horrible experience with the mirena. I had a tube and it went very smoothly (I was 24 w/ 3 kids) They will give you a hard time but if you are adamant they will make you sign a waiver and then do it. Good luck 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

TY again ladies, after hearing about the paraguard I'm scheduling an appt. with a doc to talk about it. My only issues with the Mirena is the insertion (-freaking hurts and I fainted the last time I had one put in& I've never done that!), and the hormones really messed me up. Mood swings, cramps (never had previously) after a year and a half of irregular periods my system is just now starting to straighten out, and serious weight gain (30lbs!!) that no matter what I do, I can't seem to get rid of. If the doc recommends the paraguard then I might get that and just worry about the permanent stuff later, but I'm def. done having babies! :) Tysm! 

Brandie --- 16 years ago -

My OB up at the NH told me that it is up to the dr whether they do the procedure. She knows my history with preterm labor and having my babies early so she told me she would tie my tubes for me no questions asked. Its completely up to the dr. 

Brandie --- 16 years ago -

btw i am only 23 with 2 kids 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

My pregnancies and labor were pretty regular with the exception on the last I actually had a serious panic attack during delivery. I'm sure I'd be able to get one, although I'm willing to deal with a hassle if need be. That's awesome that your doc would do that for you w/no questions asked though! 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

Nohea - I'm just wondering...did you ever decide on which way to go? Did you get the Essure or the Paragard?

Has anyone else had Essure done?


I talked to my doctor at NH and we have scheduled me an appointment to get it done, but now I'm getting scared. Not scared of being permanently fixed, scared of the actual procedure. I've heard all the horror stories and it sucks. I wish I could erase them from my head.

Anywho, just wondering how this ended up and if anybody else has had it done.

BTW, I'm 23 and 3 kids. My youngest will be 5 months old when I get it done. So I'm pretty sure if you keep at it, they will give you what you want. I have brought up getting "fixed" since a week before I had my twins and they are letting me do it. They recommended that I wait and really stressed that it is super permanent, but I am very pleased with not being able to have more babies.

Anywho, anybody that has had it done, did the NH just give you some pain pills, put you under, etc?? How exactly did they do the procedure? 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

B Bright, my doctor talked to me about Essure too, and it's just not something I feel comfortable with after doing some research.
Why not just have hubby get a vasectomy? Mine's getting one next month. YAY! 

IrishTwinsx2plus1 --- 16 years ago -

Why not just have hubby get a vasectomy? Mine's getting one next month. YAY! 

Mine is, too. Despite being almost 36-years-old, being married for 16 years and having 5 young children, my husband's doctor needed me to email him my written approval. LOL My husband was all indignant about the reverse sexism. lol 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

LOL My husband is younger than that, & we only have one kid. I haven't had to sign anything for approval yet, but I think I do when I take him to the NH. 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

I keep telling him he wont be able to get it and he keeps says "they always make exceptions,

If he's persistent enough and has a good case, they might eventually. They kept telling my husband no because we only had one kid, but he's finally getting one. We've been married 5 1/2 years though.

You guys are pretty young though to make such a permanent decision! 

♠VivaLaDoll♠ --- 16 years ago -

Right now I'm trying to make up my mind on getting a tubal or essure done. I'm worried my Husband will chicken out and I don't want to go back later to get something done since I'll already be open when I have Gavin (c-section).

I'm really not sure what is best.. tubal or essure?? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
health
marriage

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground