Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

IUD POLL....

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
EastCoast 1
Mrs Patch 3
B*Bright 9
Lavender is Good 2
VA♥girl 1
LakerGirl 1
SusseTraume 1
Jay Elle 3
Colonel LizZoo 2
Mary Swanson 1
~Lauren~ 1
BadMomma 3
Melissa 1
LilyB 2
Cellulite City 1
No L 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

IUD POLL....

So, I know birth control reacts to everyone differently and blah blah blah....I know this. I am just curious as to what YOU would pick...no reason to say why or anything...you don't even have to comment if you don't want to. I'm not going to put an "other" because that would just make this thread go a whole other way most likely with all the "he's getting snipped" or "we do this method or take that pill" etc... I just want to know, if these were your ONLY two options of birth control, which would you get? Remember, the most common side effect of these is that Mirena takes away your period (but most likely you will gain weight or it will be hard to lose) and Paragard will most likely make your period and cramps worse but the upside is that there are no hormones so it probably won't affect weight, acne, etc... Anywho, I was just wondering...LOL.

Mirena (5yr, hormonal) Vote
 
 66.7% (24)
Paragard (10yr, nonhormonal) Vote
 
 33.3% (12)
B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

So, I know birth control reacts to everyone differently and blah blah blah....I know this. I am just curious as to what YOU would pick...no reason to say why or anything...you don't even have to comment if you don't want to.

I'm not going to put an "other" because that would just make this thread go a whole other way most likely with all the "he's getting snipped" or "we do this method or take that pill" etc...

I just want to know, if these were your ONLY two options of birth control, which would you get?

Remember, the most common side effect of these is that Mirena takes away your period (but most likely you will gain weight or it will be hard to lose) and Paragard will most likely make your period and cramps worse but the upside is that there are no hormones so it probably won't affect weight, acne, etc... Anywho, I was just wondering...LOL. 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

WHY?!

*runs out of thread screaming* 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

I use implanon, because I have issues with my cervix and I can't have an IUD, but I wanted something more permanent. If given the choice, I would go with the non-hormonal paragard. Because I hate messing with hormones of any kind. I actually think we're going to try the "temping" method or whatever it's called soon. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

what?? what is wrong with me asking?? I'm not on here saying "I have a doctors appointment to go get this and want you to tell me which one I should get."

I am just curious as to which one you would choose. It will have no bearing on what I would do. Just, ASSUMING that everyone would get those side effects listed above...would you rather have no period but gain/not lose weight....or would you rather have worse periods and make it easier to lose weight??? LOL.. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

neither - im sorry but for me there is always other & better options that dont require me to put chemicals/iuds into my body

goodluck!!! 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

I'd rather not get either. Is no bc an option? (I'm serious...I don't want either set of side effects) 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

jLo - you should google "natural family planning" or NFP for short...that is going along with the temp method but waaaay more to it...and it is very effective I hear if you do it the right way... oh and www.fertilityfriend.com would be a good website to get free charts...i have a lot of online friends who use it both to get pregnant AND to keep from getting pregnant! 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

you should google "natural family planning" or NFP for short

this is what i did before hubby had his vasectomy. ive never been on the pill/iud and my children were all planned - but i have a very regular cycle 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

LOL..lizzoo - i wouldn't want either set myself, but i have to have a birth control....i'm done with kids and I couldn't get a tubal or anything bc i brought it up too late with the doctor so now i'm stuck trying to decide which to get. I think I want Paragard because I like the no hormones part, but my doctor was really pushing Mirena on me. And then I got on babycenter community and read all these stories about chicks getting on paragard and then finding out they were pregnant...some of them were only 4-5 weeks in...some had had it for 4 or 5 years and were getting preggo...I am really not interested in that. I want to get hubby snipped but it's his body so I'll let him make the decision...but right now he can't because apparently our kids have to be at least 6 months old...and mine are only 10 weeks...and by the time they are 6 months, we will be EAS'ing...so it won't be able to be done...BOOO!!!!

Anywho...I gotta run for about 20-30 minutes...gotta feed the bubbies! I will be back to check on my thread though!! 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

jLo - you should google "natural family planning"

will do :P) 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

My youngest was only 4 weeks when my husband got the snip snip, but we started pushing for it before we even had the baby and got the STUPID question: What if something happens to this child? Like they are books that can be replaced. When we told the doctors they were idiots for asking if we would ever try to "replace" a child, they referred us.

Squeaky wheel gets the grease. He'll just have to keep asking and asking for a vasectomy. If you guys really want it done, it can be done early. You just have to nag the doctors. :) (We were also younger than they wanted us to be...it used to be 3 kids and/or kids and 28. We had 2 kids and were 26) 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

this is what i did before hubby had his vasectomy. ive never been on the pill/iud and my children were all planned - but i have a very regular cycle

Is it.... easy? You can pm me. I honestly always thought it would be too hard to keep track of. But after trying a couple versions of the pill, and now implanon, Im starting to think a little work would be worth it. LOL I have had terrible experiences. 

LilyB --- 16 years ago -

If you're absolutely 100% you're done having kids, it couldn't hurt to look at this. My friend is getting it done soon, just so she doesn't have any "uh ohs" (her words) later in life. I just had my Mirena moved- was not happy with the side effects from the hormones, but am willing to try the paraguard. Not quite sure yet. 

No L --- 16 years ago -

Mirena really messed my body up! 

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

I had Mirena and it was a big mistake. I have had horrible headaches for almost three years. I also had The worse cysts and bad acne. My neurologist said it was time for me to get it taken out. My doctor says it will take up to 4 months for my body to go back to normal. Never again. 

Mary Swanson --- 16 years ago -

I had Mirena for a year.. definitely a mistake.. I will never get it again!

The worst BC I've ever used. 

ALEM --- 16 years ago -

I just went for a consult today for a tubal. But I got to thinking what if we really want another. Were both happy with 2 lol. I can't do pills, nuva ring gave me bad anxiety attacks, depo totally effed up my system, I've had patches fall off so the iud is what's left really. I already get bad cramps so I'm opting for mirena. 

~Lauren~ --- 16 years ago -

I already went in for my BC consult since I am HORRID at taking the pill (Errin) around the EXACT same time everyday (most pills you can vary a little bit with the time - apparently not with the Errin)...so I talked to my doctor about the Paraguard. He warned me about the possibility of heavier and longer periods - but I have heard SO many horror stories about Mirena... 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

I have had Mirena before. It wasn't so bad, but no matter what I tried, I couldn't lose any weight. I didn't gain any either but I really need to lose some. I was going to zumba every day they had it and still...nada. Yes, I changed my diet too. I mean, I didn't go all out and turn super healthy or anything, but I did cut back a lot on junk and other things and started moving my butt but nothing would go away. I didn't lose inches or anything else either. So I don't know if I want that again. Other than that, I was pretty good on Mirena. No periods after the first 3 or 4 months on it and all that good stuff.

Nohea - I was thinking about getting that done. I've seen it before and thought about getting it, but haven't talked to the doctor about it yet. I didn't think they would have an Essure certified doctor there at NHCP, but I just checked and they do. A Dr. Katherine Austin? Anywho, I may have to check this out! I am for sure done. My last pregnancy had a very frightful ending with a c-section (I know, call me a wimp...lol) but I really NEVER EVER EVER want to even chance that again. Plus, it only makes sense to stop at where we are. We could not afford another kid. We barely afford these 3. One was a surprise...a twin..LOL.

J Lo- I think NFP is pretty easy, although I've only read about it. Never practiced it. It's easy but sort of a lot of work. You have to chart your temps every morning and check your cervical mucus and a few other things....it's all easy, just a bit more work than popping a pill in your mouth..LOL.

lizzoo - i may have to have dh start being squeaky! LOL. He says he doesn't know if he wants more kids or not, but I hate to break it to him, he's not getting any more from me. (He already has 5 anyways!!!). I also don't think I would ever be able to say 100% sure that I don't want another kid, because I can always vision myself holding a tiny newborn, but I am done. I know that doesn't really make sense, but I guess what I'm saying is...

Rationally speaking, I am done. If I'm thinking clearly I don't want more kids. We can't afford them and I don't want to be pregnant again. But when my babies are bigger and I see a newborn, I will fall prey to that "baby fever" VERY EASILY and will not be thinking with a clear head. Then that leads to the discussion with hubby "Maybe I should take the IUD out and we should try for another baby." (which is what got us twins btw...) So, I think I would always love to have another baby, it's just not going to happen for us. So while an IUD is a good choice for me since I can't just stop taking it and it would require a doctor to remove it, I could just as easily go to the doc and say "take it out" but if i have a permanent option, there is no going back and none of that "forgetting" the pill and "accidentally" getting pregnant (yeah, i'd sink that low in a baby fever haze!)....I NEED permanent!! LOL. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

Lauren - About horror stories...I heard so many of them about Paragard (read: getting pregnant while on it) but someone summed it up for me this way. You know how you go to a restaurant and if you get crappy service then you go around and tell everyone that asks, don't go there because it's crappy. But if you got great or expected service, you don't really say anything because it's..well, expected. Horror stories are sort of like that. Nobody ever tells you that it worked for them as for what they expected from it, because it's (The birth control) is doing what its supposed to do. But when it fails (either by horrible side effects or not preventing pregnancy) most people shout it from the rooftops how horrible it was and how they will never get it again because of how it reacted....So for every horror story you hear, there are probably tons of happy stories you don't hear. Thats how someone made me look at it. Oh..and I have been taking the pill (on and off) since I was 14 and I could take one in the morning..then the next day take it at night and fluctuate all different times and skip days and all kinds of crap and still never even had a scare...that was ortho tri cyclin....but I hate taking pills...bleh... 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

I won't ever get another bc that contains hormones. Once we are done, my husband is getting a vasectomy. If Tricare won't pay for it then we will more than happily pay for it out of pocket. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

patch - just curious...what are you going to do between kids?? if you plan on having more than one? like, are you going to use NFP to space out the kids or some other type of method? 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

The rhythm method works really well for us. Yes, I know it is not perfect - but getting pregnant again is not a downfall for us. We don't want tons of time between kids as I am getting older and older. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

Hey if that works for you then work it girl! LOL. (how funny does that sentence sound!) But I was just curious. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

:) If I was 10 years younger I would probably go w/ the hormonal bc. I don't need any extra help getting moody nowadays lol 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 16 years ago -

I don't do birth control. The extra hormones makes me so sick. I'll never use it again. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

fyi, a good book is Taking Charge of Your Fertility, and their site has a forum to discuss more in depth: http://www.tcoyf.com/ 

VA♥girl --- 16 years ago -

Paraguard, even though it doesn't have hormones, still releases copper into your body. So it still has chemicals that can cause side effects. I was too excited to get Paraguard because my body does not do well with hormones and it did not have any. I had it removed last week. After 5 months hoping it would get better like the doctor was telling me... It just kept getting worse. I technically did not gain weight with it, but I retained a TON of water. DH kept asking me if I was sure I wasn't pregnant. After my cycle, I would go back down to my normal weight, but that only lasted a week, because I would start PMS'ing all over again. I had 5 week cycles... (this might be a little TMI)1 week was perfect, 2nd and 3rd week consisted of heavy spotting (enough that I had to wear a tampon), then I would have my period for another 2 weeks. But not a normal period... It was MUCH heavier (like 3 boxes of tampons). I also have not had issues with acne since I was like 13ish... But with Paraguard (and I can only assume because my PMS period was so long), I would have like MOUNTAINS on my face. So even though it doesn't have hormones, it does still have a ton of side effects. Do a lot of research before you get it. There are women out there that it was perfect for them. But there are more that it wasn't so good. It really just depends on how "accepting" you body is of foreign things. 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

I've had the paraguard for over 2 years and have had zero issues with it once my body adjusted. I agree that it's mostly people who've had problems, NOT the majority who love it, that take the time to write about it on the internet. 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

ut right now he can't because apparently our kids have to be at least 6 months old...and mine are only 10 weeks.


My husband just got a vasectomy and we have no kids! I'd tell him to keep pushing for it. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground