Interesting-but it may be flawed- how old were the kids studied- and could ut be they just are more comfortable expressing their sexuality?
Or could it be that children mimic their parents; all they know is the homosexual lifestyle so they're more prone to following in their parents footsteps?
according to the article, the study restricted the results so that they included only children in their 20s -- presumably after they'd been able to work out any adolescent confusion or experimentation
i see it as not so much a gay people have gay children but gay people have children that may be more open to experimentation and acceptance about mixed sexuality
i wonder if bi-sexual is considered as gay for this study
I think everyone that has kids run a "risk" of having their child become gay. In my opinion, who cares. They're just gay. It's not a skin eating disease and I do not believe it's any bit contagious.
Or could it be that children mimic their parents; all they know is the homosexual lifestyle so they're more prone to following in their parents footsteps?
Society looks down on homosexuality so much that people will do everything in their power to promote heterosexual relationships only. So unless the children of gay parents were locked inside all day that cannot be the only life they know. I very much disagree with your statement.
Keep in mind the publisher of this article was released from his duties as a journalist because of ethical violations. I have a strong opinion on homosexuality but that is not going to keep me from being completely unbiased and non-prejudicial.
ETA: I confused myself with the names. Cameron was the unethical journalist, whom Schumm, the actual publisher of this article, was trying to disprove but ended up proving the point, in his opinion, of the "gay parents, gay children" study.
Society looks down on homosexuality so much that people will do everything in their power to promote heterosexual relationships only. So unless the children of gay parents were locked inside all day that cannot be the only life they know. I very much disagree with your statement.
"Gangbanging" and "drug pushing" is looked down upon in society. Yet children born into such families are more likely to become such themselves. I highly disagree with your statement as well. Children look to their parents as role-models more so than society.
Or could it be that children mimic their parents; all they know is the homosexual lifestyle so they're more prone to following in their parents footsteps?
I disagree with this. I think children of gay parents would be more likely to experiment, but in the end you are what you are.
Schumm concluded that children of lesbian parents identified themselves as gay 31 percent of the time; children of gay men had gay children 19 percent of the time, and children of a lesbian mother and gay father had at least one gay child 25 percent of the time. ...the study restricted the results so that they included only children in their 20s...58 percent of the children of lesbians called themselves gay, and 33 percent of the children of gay men called themselves gay.
31%, 19% and 25% is not "more likely", more likely is over 50% across the board. And the second set of results is skewed. Only choosing one age group, in an effort to get people "presumably after they'd been able to work out any adolescent confusion or experimentation" is lopsided. I know plenty of people who were still confused and experimenting well into their mid-20s. Hell, my gay step brother didn't fully know who he was until he was almost 25!
Schumm looked at the existing academic studies, the ones used to pillory Cameron's work. In all there are 26 such studies. Schumm ran the numbers from them and concluded that, surprisingly, 20 percent of the kids of gay parents were gay themselves. When children only 17 or older were included in the analysis, 28 percent were gay.
That still doesn't speak as "more likely" to be gay if your parents are...
In Schumm's study, he quotes from the extant literature the stories of young women, describing how being gay was never frowned upon in their household, and so that "option" was available to them. That said, Schumm also finds evidence of gay mothers pushing their daughters, upset over a relationship with a man, to "try out women."
I absolutely disagree about this... I was raised in a "gay" household. My mother and her wife or whatever you want to call it... And I know plenty of other children of gay parents who are not gay themselves, nore did we experiment or do anything out of the usual for other kids, I am obviously married to a man, and my younger brother and sister are straight as well, our mother did not influence us in sexual orientation at all.
children of lesbian parents identified themselves as gay 31 percent of the time; children of gay men had gay children 19 percent of the time, and children of a lesbian mother and gay father had at least one gay child 25 percent of the time.
i would be interested in the male/female breakup of the children
my thinking is its more acceptable to be lesbian/experimenting than gay/experimenting so for lesbian parents to have a higher percentage of gay children do they also have a higher number of daughters than sons?
"Gangbanging" and "drug pushing" is looked down upon in society. Yet children born into such families are more likely to become such themselves. I highly disagree with your statement as well. Children look to their parents as role-models more so than society.
That lifestyle of drugs and gangs are normally taught to children. They're taught how to "throw up" gang signs. They're taught to stay true to a certain color. That straying from the "rules" can mean potentially deadly consequences. Do you really think gay parents are teaching their children that gay is the right way? The only way?
That lifestyle of drugs and gangs are normally taught to children. They're taught how to "throw up" gang signs. They're taught to stay true to a certain color. That straying from the "rules" can mean potentially deadly consequences. Do you really think gay parents are teaching their children that gay is the right way? The only way?
According to his sources, "lesbian" parents do actually push a homosexual lifestyle on their children.
"lesbian" parents do actually push a homosexual lifestyle on their children.
I know when I had problems with boyfriends my mother never pushed the idea of being a lesbian on me, they were there for me like any other parents would be... I can only speak from my personal child hood, but I know plenty of other girls who I grew up with that would disagree with all of this as well.
I think this study chose extremists. I certainly don't believe it represent the majority of homosexual couples.
You could be right. We all have our own personal beliefs and in mine, I believe that everyone is born a blank slate and nurture, not nature, molds us into the person we are. Inlcuding our parents sexuality's role in raising children. Children learn from their parents.
DISCLAIMER: I am NOT in anyway attempting to poke the bear by posting this thread. I read the article and thought it an interesting discussion piece for getting all sides and opinions on the issue.
I believe that everyone is born a blank slate and nurture, not nature, molds us into the person we are.
Were that the case, I would be a homophobic, bible thumping, ignorant piece of white trash instead of the bisexual, agnostic, intelligent person that I am. I grew up with straight parents, my father was the biggest homophobe out there, yet I was ready to marry another woman before I met my husband. There are some things your parents can influence, but you are who you are, from birth, and if that runs counter to what they've tried to teach you, there really isn't anything that can change it.
Holy crap chill out with all of the BOLD. Seriously I think this thread is a bad idea it was posted just to stir the pot and get everyone all riled up and defensive towards their own opinions on the matter. Personally I don't care if people are gay, straight or friggin' window lickers.
I believe that everyone is born a blank slate and nurture, not nature, molds us into the person we are.
Were that the case, I would be a homophobic, bible thumping, ignorant piece of white trash instead of the bisexual, agnostic, intelligent person that I am
You were not born anything. What you experience, what you interperet and the opinions and thoughts you hold make you the person you are. Which, I believe, parents do attribute to. But I also believe you CHOOSE what to do with your life on your own terms. It's complicated and I'm completely aware of this. If we all agreed on everything and individualism was non-existant in this world, it would be a hell of a boring place.
Holy crap chill out with the all of the BOLD. Seriously I think this thread is a bad idea it was posted just to stir the pot and get everyone all riled up and defensive towards their own opinions on the matter. Personally I don't care if people are gay, straight or friggin' window lickers.
Not stirring the pot in anyway. I was under the assumption this was a calm, collected discussion learning every side of different opinions.
We all have our own personal beliefs and in mine, I believe that everyone is born a blank slate and nurture, not nature, molds us into the person we are.
If this were true I'd be an alcoholic racist who believed hitting kids was the best way to get your point across.
Holy crap chill out with the all of the BOLD. Seriously I think this thread is a bad idea it was posted just to stir the pot and get everyone all riled up and defensive towards their own opinions on the matter. Personally I don't care if people are gay, straight or friggin' window lickers.
What bold? I was disagreeing with Lacy and expressing my opinion of the nature vs nurture debate.