Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

The battle of the binky......

who's talking here?

Kariane 1
DoctorDonna 1
YouReallyThinkSo 2
what 3
KillaK 1
chelleydi77 1
BadMomma2 3
Whitness Protection Team Betty 8
Vod Kaknockers 5
TheRoses 9
Scrappy 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

My son is 13 months old and I have been tring to break him from it forever. We only give it to him when it's nap time or bed time. Well, naptime is 11:30 and he has lost his last binky and I cant find it so here it is 1:00 and he will not take a nap. He is screaming and throwing a fit but I have tore this house upside down looking for it. Any advice? Should I just let him cry it out or should I run out and buy a new one? I'm going nuts. 

chelleydi77 --- 15 years ago -

Well IMO, if you're trying to break him of it, just let him cry it out. He'll eventually learn that he won't get his binky even if he is crying and will soothe himself instead of using the binky as a soother. 

KillaK --- 15 years ago -

I let my son cry when i was breaking him of his binky. After 3 days he forgot all about it. You just have to really stick with it, good luck! 

what --- 15 years ago -

Talk to your Dr. Mine explained that a child that young needs that security and may just turn to his thumb. I took my daughters away early and she sucked her thumb until she was 8 :( 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

get it over with now and let him cry it out. Your life may be a little more challenged for a few days but it will pass. 

what --- 15 years ago -

I agree with the others. If you really want it gone it should be cold turkey. If he sees it at all it will start all over again, he knows you have it! ;) 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

I took my daughters away early and she sucked her thumb until she was 8 :(

That's what I'm worried about, I can take the binky but I cant take a thumb. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Only one of my kids sucked their thumb and she never took a passy. The others I let them have it till they were two. None of them have bad teeth and they all talk fine. 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

The benefits outway the risk. Not all children turn to the thumb. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

My son is 13 months old and I have been tring to break him from it forever.

i have no problem with a 13mth old having a binky, especially as its only for sleeptime - i mean 13mth is still a baby so why force him to grow up so fast (a couple of mine use to just hold the dang thing while sleeping)

obviously hes upset so can he have something else to replace it, a fav toy or teddy to hold? kids usually give these things up when they are ready 

Vod Kaknockers --- 15 years ago -

We cut our daughters until she didn't want it any more. It took 5 days of cutting it, the last time we cut it we gave it to her she put it in her mouth and took it right back out and handed it to us. I think cold turkey is harder on both of you. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

obviously hes upset so can he have something else to replace it, a fav toy or teddy to hold? kids usually give these things up when they are ready

He has his doggy and blanket. He does just fine without it until he lays down. 

what --- 15 years ago -

I heard about the cutting technique. I would have tried it had I known at the time. My current youngest was a thumb sucker from go.

My children's teeth are fine too. I think pacifiers are great. They relax and soothe children. I would agree that 2 is a good age to try and "pull the plug". Like I said ask a Dr. My pediatrician said there is no reason to take it too soon. She said after 2 I want to start thinking about but it was on a per child basis. Some kids need that sense of security more than others. 

Vod Kaknockers --- 15 years ago -

I personally would go buy one and tonight or tomorrow start cutting it we did about 1/8 of an inch each night off and by the time she didn't want it there was pretty much nothing left. 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

The younger you get this done the better for you and him. He probably doesn't have much teeth yet which makes the timing good. When they are older and try to reason with you about keeping it, it gets much more difficult. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

I guess I'm just trying to knock out two things at once and it's making it harder, we have got him down to one bottle a day. 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

Good job :) some parents wait forever to try and then wonder why its so difficult. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

I personally would go buy one and tonight or tomorrow start cutting it we did about 1/8 of an inch each night off and by the time she didn't want it there was pretty much nothing left.

I think I'm going to try this. Do you start at the tip and just cut down? 

Vod Kaknockers --- 15 years ago -

I feel like we waited forever to take the binky away, because I felt bad because we took bottles away on her 1st birthday. She was cranky for 2 weeks after we took it away. I guess that is way we did the cutting on the binky, I wanted to make it easier on her. 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

you do realize it might just piss him off if you do this. This does not work with all kids. Some people dip it in vinegar. Either way, he is calling your bluff and giving him another one, cut or not, will show him that he wins and if he just cries long enough he will get it. 

Vod Kaknockers --- 15 years ago -

Yeah we cut the tip and just kept cutting it. 

Kariane --- 15 years ago -

I stopped using pacifiers at 2 months and they never turned to the thumb. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

Either way, he is calling your bluff and giving him another one, cut or not, will show him that he wins and if he just cries long enough he will get it.

Good point, it was not this hard with my oldest. Ayden took his out and threw it at six months and never wanted it back. I think another part of our problem is I will take it and hubby will give it back. 

Vod Kaknockers --- 15 years ago -

you do realize it might just piss him off if you do this. This does not work with all kids. Some people dip it in vinegar. Either way, he is calling your bluff and giving him another one, cut or not, will show him that he wins and if he just cries long enough he will get it. 

True, but what we had decided was once it was gone, if she still wanted it she was out of luck because we tossed the rest of them. 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

if there is none in the house then there won't be anything to give back to him ;) 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

if there is none in the house then there won't be anything to give back to him ;)

I think hubby has a stash of them hidden. 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

My son never started on a pacifier... I have lots of unused ones, they feel like a waste of money now, lol. Good luck to you though! 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

Well then you should have a long talk with him about the cons of continuing the binky. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

When we got rid of them but son kept finding them lol I think he knew it was coming and hid him a stash all over the house lol. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

What are the cons? 13 months old is not a bad age for a passy. Now over two I think is bad. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground