Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

1/5 lost their first (article from 4/27)

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
EastCoast 1
Mrs Patch 4
*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* 4
La Chickees 2
Samantha 1
Just Sayin 6
AINOKEA 1
Kim 1
Blondie1985 1
Jack Hass 1
Momzilla 1
whatevergirl2 3
Scrappy 2
Doo Schnugget 3
LullabiesButterflies 1
Sarah H aka Boot 1
ItchyWitch 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* --- 15 years ago -

I believe they replaced 3/5th...sorry if I am wrong in that. And I am posting this now because the article was written on the 27th and I would hope that families would have already been notified. My prayers go out to said family and more headed out for 1/5 and their safety!!! May they not suffer as much as 3/5! 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

They have lost more than one unfortunately, according to my husband. I wanted to post when I heard about the first (we're good friends with several of the guys in 1/5) but I know many 1/5 wives are PU users and didn't want to stir emotions. 

*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* --- 15 years ago -

Sorry forgot the link
Link 

Jack Hass --- 15 years ago -

I know many 1/5 wives are PU users and didn't want to stir emotions

X2. 

*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* --- 15 years ago -

Not meaning to stir emotions. Just wanted to make sure prayers get sent. 

Samantha --- 15 years ago -

I just want everybody to come home. Sorry I'm emotional and I want them all home. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Of course, I know you didn't intend that in any way. Its hard for me to be in touch with reality in this situation with an upcoming deployment we're anticipating, so I avoid reading articles and keeping up with it because it really is a lot to take in. 

Kim --- 15 years ago -

To date the 1/5 has only had one casualty, and he is the one mentioned in the article linked. We have had wounded. Other units in the same area have suffered casualties since 1/5 has been in place. And, yes please tred lightly. This young man's death may be common knowledge but his funeral has not even taken place. And, with the events of tonight, I know I am more worried then ever about the saftey of 1/5 and the other men and women that are currently deployed. 

*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* --- 15 years ago -

Of course, I know you didn't intend that in any way. Its hard for me to be in touch with reality in this situation with an upcoming deployment we're anticipating, so I avoid reading articles and keeping up with it because it really is a lot to take in. 

We too are in preparations for one this summer. So I know exactly how you feel with avoiding it! Prayers sent your way for keeping your family safe! 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Thanks! This will be the first since the baby was born, but third total. The first two did nothing to prepare me for deployment with a child. This time around will be trying for us. But it will be the last! 

EastCoast --- 15 years ago -

And, yes please tred lightly.
What the heck does that mean!? She's not saying anything bad about the guy nor did she state details. I'm assuming you have someone deployed with this guy and are emotionally invested in the situation. 

Blondie1985 --- 15 years ago -

My PM box is open for anyone that needs to vent/e-cry, etc. My heart is very heavy for those that are worried about loved ones. 

Just Sayin --- 15 years ago -

ALREADY REPORTED ON DEFENSE.ORG, family has been notified and have been interviewed, but we lost a second one, and it's really sad that the parents actually found out on FB before they were officially notified. 

Sarah H aka Boot --- 15 years ago -

Just sayin', that's why people need to not post shit like that on Facebook, until after the family is notified. 

La Chickees --- 15 years ago -

My husband is on his second deployment right now,And by far the hardest,My prayers and thaughts for everyone whos out there. 

Momzilla --- 15 years ago -

I'm keeping my friends in 1/5, their wives and children- and all of our troops in my thoughts. Hoping we can bring as many as possible home safe and sound. 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

Someone said this Marine hadn't been buried yet. Is that standard? It's been over a month since his passing. Sorry for my ignorance. I really do avoid everything to do with death and I don't listen or talk to my husband about it.

Also, these threads are so iffy on here. We've been asked not to allow them by many puers and commands. I don't know what the right answer is. I would hope no one would ever post a casuality before a family was notified and it hit the news. If your husband tells you something, it doesn't need to be reported to PU within 10 minutes or less. 

La Chickees --- 15 years ago -

I agree weg,we are not allowed to post tmi,for safety issues. 

ItchyWitch --- 15 years ago -

and commands

I think that if commands are asking PU Mods to not let the post go on then they shouldn't be. JMO 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

I haven't been contact by a command. I have been told by a couple other mods they have. I think the issue with it was reporting before the family was notified. Example on cp was the drowning that just happened in Del Mar. It was being discussed on her straight away.

With the puers, many felt it was too hard coming on pu only to read freak out threads about the unit their husband was deployed with. 3/5 was a perect example. They had a lot of hits/casualities and every time PU got and update. It made it hard on the families.

Like I said, I don't know the right answer. I get people have a need to pray and make prayer chains. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

My 2 cents on this:
I don't believe that any one of us would want to find out on PU, FB, or any media, about our spouses having an accident/dying and therefore we should respect others' loss and not race to be the first one to post about it. What benefit comes of it? None. I understand the want to ask for prayers, but in all honesty PU is not the correct forum for religion/prayer. There is just too much drama that can ensue from a well meaning post. My heart goes out to those of you whose husbands are deployed and have to see a post about a casualty on here. Also, prayers should go out for all units deployed and not just those suffering casualties. My church does this at every mass. It should not surprise anyone that commands/PMO DO see and comment on the stuff that is posted on here. Why anyone think that PU is a secret from the commands is beyond me. My last point is this: I just want people to realize that they could be hurting someone's feelings with their post who is already hurting unimagineably. Put yourself in their place. Maybe *you* wouldn't care if it was posted, but not everyone is the same. Think about that. 

AINOKEA --- 15 years ago -

Thank you.. and kindly deleted.. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

The FRO is not authorized to tell the family anything in regards to the injury/death of a Marine. That is what the purpose of the CACO team is. They're the ones who come to the family's home and deliver the information they need to know.

ETA* This should be explained to everyone at the deployment briefs. I know it is explained at the briefs I have attended. 

Just Sayin --- 15 years ago -

The title itself gives off ample warning of what is contained within. At the point which the OP posted "I would hope that families would have already been notified. " this thread should have been stopped, don't you think. Nobody has posted names, and any information was found out from FB, no one posted "my husband told me". One would hope imps would refrain from even posting if their husband got hurt because even THAT in itself you're not supposed to post because that will lead to people who know their husband/friend/whatever was with your husband to freak out that theirs was endangered as well. *I* posted what I did HOW I did posted to show what one careless individual did.

Furthermore then this post should stop being commented on and deleted, don't you think. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

JS - I would think that if there was any question about the family having been notified it would stop. Unfortunately, not everyone thinks alike. Also, if it's already in the news - and FB is not news people - then I would prefer for those articles to be linked. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

I guess you misunderstood me. I meant that for example, the OP referred to an article on 4/27, so then she could link the article and then her comment. I didn't mean for you to post your articles after the fact. Also I didn't miss the point of HOW you posted your comment, and I believe that more unfortunate examples like that should be shown to people so they realize that perhaps sometimes having information too soon can be harmful rather than helpful. 

LullabiesButterflies --- 15 years ago -

Yes, people should have the common sense not to post any info about casualties until all the info OS released on the did website. After that though, I don't think there's anything wrong with people asking for prayers for those lost and their families. I'm sure most families and friends would appreciate the thought. 

Just Sayin --- 15 years ago -

I guess you misunderstood me. I meant that for example, the OP referred to an article on 4/27, so then she could link the article and then her comment. I didn't mean for you to post your articles after the fact. Also I didn't miss the point of HOW you posted your comment, and I believe that more unfortunate examples like that should be shown to people so they realize that perhaps sometimes having information too soon can be harmful rather than helpful.

Oh, sorry for misunderstanding haha. Carry on lol. But yeah in my initial post I made sure to make it known that it had already been posted on the defense website so that a MOD wouldn't come down on me thinking that I was reporting something that wasn't already known or that I just picked it off FB without research or something my husband told me. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

If the info is already posted on the govt site why is it ever necessary to post stuff like that on here. Whoever should ne notified when a family member or spouse is hurt or killed will be. IMO no losses or accidents should ever be put on a chat forum. There just isn't any reason to do it.

The only purpose it serves is freaking out wives who husbands are in that unit which does no one any good. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground