my daughter has been soooo naughty lately and i don't know what to do. i thought tantrums and such weren't supposed to start until around 2 or so. she is only one so time outs and things of that nature are pointless as she won't understand why she's being punished. i'd prefer not to hit her but i have tried to slap her hand or pop her in the mouth but she is unphased. she is teething but it just can't be that. i took her to the dr. when she started acting like this (screaming relentlessly when she wants something or screaming if i take something away from her that she shouldn't have for whatever reason, screaming if i don't share EVERYTHING i have with her, ect...)to see if maybe she had an ear infection or something. she is teething and has several teeth breaking through but this is not i'm-in-pain-naughtiness. i can't take this girl anywhere!! errands are a complete disaster no matter how small. i get zero breaks from her and i am overwhelmed. any suggestions?? thanks.
i popped her because she was being naughty. she doesn't listen when i say no screaming please or stop or whatever and she will not stop if i just ignore her. she will only stop when she decides she's done. i didn't hit her hard, just a pop. i did that at the suggestion of my mother...
i don't really know anyone here so no she does not get to be around children often. i recently started pt and there is a daycare there with lots of kiddos. she does well after the initial where are you going mommy freak out. she plays nice and shares.
My son just started acting like that at almost 16 mo. Its been horrible if he doesn't get his way its a screaming tantrum. I'm not one for spanking my child but it has come down to me popping him on the hand and telling him no. It takes 2-15 times for him to get the hint but I was told by the doctor that we need to be consistant. If we say no we need to mean it not say it once or twice then give in.
For example last night we went out to dinner and he decided to start throwing a fit because he didn't want to sit in a high chair and wanted to run around everywhere. After a few min of him throwing a tantrum, I picked him up and we went outside. I told him until he stopped we weren't going back inside and I wasn't letting him down to run around. ( I know he might not understand it but its a start to him learning when we say no that we mean it. ) After about five minutes he calmed down and I took him back inside and he sat for about 35 min while eating and he started again and we did the process all over.
It was so funny because there were a couple behind us that told us he was so well behaved and they don't see that very often. I was kind of shocked because its not how he is ever. He never has thrown tantrums like this while we had been out.
How old is she? My 18 month old does this at times too, and I do put her in time out, she does understand what she is doing and she understands why she is being punished.
yea, i'm consistent for the most part ut i'll admit i do give in on one thing. when she wants boob she yanks on my shirt or screams until i give in (even if i just fed her!!). often i do give in if we are out because i just get so overwhelmed with her screaming and pulling on me. with everything else, i am firm. so just keep poppin her hand then?? she will be one on sunday. i know she knows that i am upset with her when she's naughty and i'm pretty sure she understands i want her to stop it but i don't think she will understand a time out...
I started time out at 12 months. No she didn't understand at the time but she does now. I also don't stay in the room where her time out is, if she is throwing a tantrum it is because she wants attention. I don't give it to her when she is acting that way. I have even taken her to her room and let her scream it out, and when she is done go in to her.
i only popped her once but i get it. i just didn't know what else to do. again though, she is only one. if i put her up in her room she will scream probably until she falls asleep... is that really learning not to be naughty? i'm doubting that this will be effective...but i could be wrong.
My son throws some small tantrums. I continue talking to him in a quiet tone and tell him to calm down, that the world is not ending. His tantrum usually ends in a couple seconds.
If I tell him no in an extra firm voice, he starts crying. and comes up to me for a hug.
To me it sounds like she is teething. You know when you have a toothache that just won't go away and you start to get moody, that is what it sounds like is happening.
if i put her up in her room she will scream probably until she falls asleep... is that really learning not to be naughty?
my older kids have cried themselves to sleep after being punished, it didn't damage them.
You don't have to let her fall asleep, let her scream it out, once you've given her some time, go in and talk to her. You don't have to be all formal and Mother about it, use simple words she can/will understand: You can't scream, it's a no-no See screming only gets you in trouble...w.e. works.
Yes it will teach her, because she wants attention and if you let her scream it out until she falls asleep, she will get the point that YOU won't put up with her acting that way.
lol, yes,if i yell at her she wants a hug. i try to keep my voice calm because yelling at her to not yell is just silly. i don't know. i'm having a hard time believing that she is acting sooo badly because of her teeth. i think i can tell the difference when she's in pain (not saying that snotty) but maybe i really am wrong. idunno. i have been giving her motrin regularly since i took her to the dr. a few weeks ago. usually when she is hurting i can calm her down with nursing and distractions and stuff like that... lately she is a maniac!!
All that's teaching her is to hit people when she's angry or frustrated.
noted.
my older kids have cried themselves to sleep after being punished, it didn't damage them.
i'm nt saying it would be damaging. i just didn't think she would understand.
Yes it will teach her, because she wants attention and if you let her scream it out until she falls asleep, she will get the point that YOU won't put up with her acting that way.
ok, i guess i'll have to give this a try then... thanks guys.
Children go off the vibes of their caregivers. If a stranger puts her in a room...well she would freak.
If her MOTHER has put her in her room after throwing a tantrum she will begin to realize soon enough that 1+1=2. It may not work the first, second, or third time but you have to be consistent with whatever punishment she gets otherwise you will confuse her.
i don't think so. we play a lot and i do take her to the playground pretty often. she likes to be outside and she's usually very happy exploring and all that. but the minute i tell her no don't eat the wood chips (lol) or don't try and touch the chewed up gum on theound, she gets pissed!
If her MOTHER has put her in her room after throwing a tantrum she will begin to realize soon enough that 1+1=2. It may not work the first, second, or third time but you have to be consistent with whatever punishment she gets otherwise you will confuse her.
the minute i tell her no don't eat the wood chips (lol) or don't try and touch the chewed up gum on theound, she gets pissed
lol, mine did this too. She is testing her boundaries. You are in it for the long haul. My daughter's terrible 2's came almost as soon as she turned one and is still there :P
my son use to do the same thing. hes 23months now but started around 18months. he has been screaming, temper tantrums, hitting, biting...you name it. i started putting him in his room. he didnt like it the first 5 or 6 times but hes gotten to the point to where if he does any of the above, he goes to his room without being told. he will stay in there until he calms down, then let himself out. it just takes patience. be firm and never stop trying. the more you repeat the punishment, the more she will start to understand the consequences. i got lucky and it only took my son a few times but even if it takes 100x she will eventually get it. also, i get to his level when im scolding him. he seems to pay attention longer when we are at eye level to each other.
he goes to his room without being told. he will stay in there until he calms down, then let himself out
wow that's crazy. lol, i was just the opposite when i was little. my mom said i was such a little sh*t. i used to get popped on the hand and sent to my room and on the way up the stairs i'd ask "mamma, do you just want to gimme another pop? cuz i just know i'm gonna do somethin' bad" ugh...my poor mother lol. she says my daughter's personality and wild side are just like how i used to be so i can assume the next several years will be a challenge lol. i love that little monkey though, even if she is giving me grays...
...and it wouldn't post and said clean up ur language buddy... and it did it again... o, oops. can't say sh*t.