Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Crib bumpers...unsafe??

who's talking here?

Totally Rockin 1
2Gems4Ever 1
Calimommy 2
Pink Taco 1
Hokey*Pokey 1
MommaNanny 1
Taminator 2
*~Always Faithful~* 1
DocsWife 3
gurlplz 1
SkullGirl 1
Poe 1
HavingaBOY 7
DramaLlamasMomma 2
shizzlemydizzle 1
bigmamaperry 2
accountnickname 5
reinacat 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

Ive been reading about crib bumpers and have read lots about them actually suffocating babies? And that the breathable ones are the ones you should get.

Any thoughts on this? 

bigmamaperry --- 14 years ago -

they are safe. both my sisters had them with there kids and they are fine. the bumper is to keep the baby from hitting their head on the sides of the bed. but they are safe 

*~Always Faithful~* --- 14 years ago -

They obviously could suffocate if you have them up against the bumper but no.. It also helps them not getting an arm or leg stuck in the cracks! 

Poe --- 14 years ago -

I heard its better to get the mesh ones so the baby can breathe if it rolls against one. 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

The American Academy of Pediatrics says that they aren't safe and some places even ban their sale. They are often considered to be for decorative purposes only and that is not worth the risks IMO. 

bigmamaperry --- 14 years ago -

The American Academy of Pediatrics says that they aren't safe and some places even ban their sale.


that is not true if they where not safe then they would not have them on the shelfs in store 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

that is not true if they where not safe then they would not have them on the shelfs in store 

There are many recommendations that the AAP makes that parents choose to completely ignore.

AAP crib bumper article 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

Notice that there are issues with the "bumpers" that are not the thick traditional kind as well. While suffocation is probably not a risk, entrapment and strangulation still is. 

DramaLlamasMomma --- 14 years ago -

There are many recommendations that the AAP makes that parents choose to completely ignore.

AAP crib bumper article


x2! The mesh bumpers are not even safe anymore. We took our mess ones off. I'm just glad I didn't buy the crib set I wanted. You can't use the comforter or the bumper! lol 

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

SO what is the point of the comforter? cuz im having trouble finding the bedding i want for my design ive chosen...do i even need a comforter? 

DramaLlamasMomma --- 14 years ago -

The baby should not sleep with the comforter and you can't put it at the end of the bed because they could pull it on themselves. Unless you want to hang it on the wall as a decoration a bed set would probably not be worth it to you. 

Pink Taco --- 14 years ago -

I had one with my son. I honestly think it depends on the person. If you're the type that doesn't check on the child that often when in the crib, then no don't get it. Some people leave their babies in the crib for a while thinking it will be ok.

Also, newborns don't really move much so for the first month it would probably be ok, I forgot what month they really start moving around. But you can see if your baby moves a lot or not with time, and if you don't feel safe with it, then you can always take it off.

And I used the comforter w/ my son too. 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

Some people buy the comforter and hang it on the wall. You can't use it for the baby. The best thing is to buy a nice cribskirt and then several matching sheets. 

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

Oh okay. We are doing a vintage race car theme. and i cant find crud for it lol. but im doing red and grey for the colors, and then accent colors. So im thinking now just getting red and grey sheets, and then just do the decor. 

DocsWife --- 14 years ago -

For those that say they're safe because so and so used them and they're fine: just because someone survives a dangerous situation doesn't lessen the danger of it. I can drive every day without a seatbelt and survive. However, someone can forget a single time and die. It only takes one drunk driver, or in the baby's case, a single time they rolled a little too far and ended up with their face pushed against the bumper too long. There's a reason they were just outlawed in Chicago. If you must use one, use breathable. No comforters, no pillows, no stuffed animals. Just a fitted sheet and breathable bumper. Sure it's not "cute," but it's much safer. There are something called sleepsacks if you're concerned about your baby being cold. You can use those once he is too big to be swaddled. 

Taminator --- 14 years ago -

Ask your OB for info packets on SID at your next apt. Also read up on it because its very serious! I used sleeping sacs with my daughter till she was 6 months old and didnt use bumpers, pillows, stuff animals (comfort), or blankets. 

Taminator --- 14 years ago -

For those that say they're safe because so and so used them and they're fine: just because someone survives a dangerous situation doesn't lessen the danger of it.

x a billion! 

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

Thanks ladies!! :) I'll def look more into SIDS! 

Totally Rockin --- 14 years ago -

I highly recommend blanket sleepers for babies, a breathable mattress and a sleep positioner . No blankets, no bumpers, no pillows and no stuffed animals. Our friends recently lost their baby to sids. He rolled over for the first time and suffocated. Babies can roll or push themselves into a bumper and suffocate, they can pull blankets over their face and suffocate and they can roll over and get stuck face down breathing in the same air they just breathed out or not be able to breath at all. Just because a friends kid made it, doesn't mean yours will. These were amazing parents and now they are without their precious first born son. It happens, but you can take certain steps to help prevent it from happening. 

DocsWife --- 14 years ago -

I had one with my son. I honestly think it depends on the person. If you're the type that doesn't check on the child that often when in the crib, then no don't get it. Some people leave their babies in the crib for a while thinking it will be ok.

Did you honestly check on your baby every few minutes? Because it only takes a few minutes for him/her to suffocate. And what about overnight? They're not safe no matter how often you pike your head in to look at your baby.

And OP, you should look into something called an AngelCare monitor for an extra layer of security. 

Hokey*Pokey --- 14 years ago -

When my eldest daughter was a baby, she had a crocheted/knitted blanket that she slept with. That way, if her blanket went over her face, she would still be able to easily breathe.

You could do that for your son, maybe in the same colors that you're using for his room or with a small race car decal on the corner of the blanket? 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

We all survived. Someone's child fell on the wrong side of those odds though. All of these precautions are in an effort to lower those odds so that fewer families are devastated at the loss of their child. As a parent we must decide if that is worth the effort to us or not. I can't say that I've always made the 100% most safe choice, but in general I have made an effort and that is my choice. It is better to be armed with knowledge and then be able to make an informed decision. If someone asks a question that I know the answer to, I'm happy to answer so they can also make an informed decision. 

2Gems4Ever --- 14 years ago -

Well I guess you ladies shouldn't send your children to the CDC where they have old 1960 drop down cribs. In daycare they also use a blanket on your 6 week old from its waist down. Also, maybe you shouldn't use a swing where your child isn't sitting up as straight and slightly breathes into their shoulder/chest which can ultimately cause SIDS.

I'm an advocate and I agree with the above. Of course as a parent you need to do what's right for your child. However, I bet there are a ton of situations that will arise once the child is here. 

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

Okay so fitted sheet and swaddled up in a blanket! lol saves me money...and appears to be the safest :) my momma was right...less is more when it comes to infants! 

SkullGirl --- 14 years ago -

I know it's kind of off topic, but has anyone looked into or used the Montessori approach which advocates floor beds as apposed to cribs? 

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

I know it's kind of off topic, but has anyone looked into or used the Montessori approach which advocates floor beds as apposed to cribs? 

ive never even heard of it...im gonna google it lol 

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

Okay, i wouldnt put my infant on the floor bed...but DEF when they get into the toddler stage it makes SO much sense!! and they are pretty neat looking. 

MommaNanny --- 14 years ago -

I used crib bumbers. He slept with his talking marine bear that his dad made before he left also. He didnt use a blanket. If anything touches his face while he is sleeping he instantly screams. So even at 11 months he still doesnt use a blanket. 

DocsWife --- 14 years ago -

Mommananny my daughter is 22 months and is still in her sleepsack lol. I tried giving her a blanket recently but she just throws it off.

And my daughter's toddler is basically on the floor but it still has a frame. It has no legs so it's pretty much like that Montessori approach. I didn't know I had a name. 

Calimommy --- 14 years ago -

My son got stuck in his bumpers. He is 3 now, but than without them, his leg got caught in the side of the crib. Not sure how I feel either way. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground