So Im posting this for a friend because she obviously doesnt want strangers all up in her business, but I figured maybe i can get some answers out. Okay here's the deal, she cheated on her husband (please no rude comments, you dont know the situation) and now her husband and a mutual friend of the guy she cheated with are trying to get this guy charged. She got a phone call from the dudes command telling her they need to have a meeting with her so they can "read her her rights and set her up with legal counsel so they can investigate". She's wigging out because they way that made it sound is that she's also going to get into trouble for it, keep in mind she's a civillian, not a military member.
Does anyone have any insight on the situation?
No, she doesnt want a divorce. I wont get into the details of why what happened happened, but her and her husband are trying to work through it.
What she isnt understanding is that when she goes and talks to the command of this Marine, why she would need her rights read to her and legal counsel afforded to her. She's worried that she's going to get charged with something as well.
There's no point to charging someone for adultry if you're not getting a divorce...does her husband know they want to talk to her? Cause it doesn't make sense...
If they are working it out why does he want the marine charged. Doesnt mae sense seems he wants to rub it in her face. if u wanna work it out then u should the past be the past and move on
ok I just saw my post LOL . what its suppose to say is. It doesnt make sense he wants to work it out but yet wants the other guy charged. It seems he wants to rub it in and have it documented.He will use it against her whenever they have a little fight. If he truly wants to work it out he should move on and let the past be the past. I dont agree at all with what she did (its wrong and I hate cheaters) but if they want to make it work then start fresh and leave the mess she create behind. I dont understand why the other guys command want to have her come in and be charged. doesnt make sense she is civilian and they cant make her come in and admit to her adultry. Like I said it seems her hubby wants to have material to use against her in the future.
Who said she was being charged? Anytime you talk to an investigator, they have to read you your rights. If they don't, they get into big trouble. They cant use statements that you give if you speak to them and don't know your rights. It's like them busting in your front door and searching your house without a warrant. Also, just because she's a spouse does not mean the government cant charge her. I doubt they would, but don't think that because you have a brown ID card, you are safe and can only be charged by civilians.
*"you" is referring to anyone who thinks Uncle Sam can only charge the active duty members. Not anybody specific.
It sounds like they're just trying to scare her and get information so they can charge the other Marine. She has absolutely no obligation to go in and talk to them. I would strongly advise her not to do that unless she's also interested in getting the other guy charged for some reason.
I would not recommend her not cooperating. The less she cooperates with them, the worse it will be. They will just make her talk to them by getting a court order. This is the real world. She needs to take responsibility for what she did; no matter what the circumstances may have been. I hope the best for her.
I also think that people are forgetting that this Marine is going to a military court. You are not proven guilty in a military court; you must be proven innnocent. This Marine and the spouse are both assumed guilty until proven innocent. Trust me. It is not like it is on JAG. I have stood in on many, many NJPs and 2 court martials.
It is true that Military Court is very different from Civilian Courts. I have been a paralegal in both systems. "Adultery" is hard to prove in the Marine Corps. Her best bet would probably be to consult an attorney, a civilian who also practices military, as every Command handles a situation differently. Every person has the right to remain silent. That is the first thing I was trained to tell all potential clients and clients. Also, unfortunately, the "investigators" whether it is NCIS, or civilian detectives, are not your friends. They are just trying to get a confession.
I also think that people are forgetting that this Marine is going to a military court. You are not proven guilty in a military court; you must be proven innnocent. This Marine and the spouse are both assumed guilty until proven innocent.
Is NCIS even involved at this point? If it's not even a formal investigation, they can't bully her into confessing so that they can have something to charge the other Marine with. I'm not taking her side, but I agree that she should probably consult an attorney so that she understands her rights as a civilian in this situation.
Just know that the other Marine's command is probably on his side...he might've even told them that he didn't know she was married or that she told him he wasn't. So his command might be trying to get her to say stuff along those lines....
Honestly, I have dealt with the investigators on base soooo much and the best thing she can do if she doesn't want this dude to hang for it is just be as unhelpful as possible.
Did you sleep with cpl so and so
her answer should be either pleading the 5th, or I dont recall at this time.
Sure, they are gonna get pissed because she is not cooperating, and of course because she's not helping them out, they are going to know that it happened, but without her admitting it, they got nothing.
Second, shame on her husband for telling her she has to confess of he'll leave her. Your marraige should not be used as a form of blackmail.
Its a long, depressing road she's headed up, but I promise, things get alot better if you make it through the aftermath.
omg NCIS wouldn't even handle this case! I'm almost certain that CID wouldn't take the case either.
The 'other' marine's command cannot charge her... they'd have to get cid or ncis involved and like I said, I'm almost certain they'd laugh to think that they'd take an adultery case.
Tell her to grow a pair and to quit allowing herself to be bullied by her husband and the 'other' marine's command.
My husband has had this done to one of his marine. They can't do anything to her because she is not the marine. Only her reputation will be ruined. If she goes to the meeting her husband looks bad too bc he "is staying" with her. I don't judge but whatever the situatuion was all she can do is be honest. To the marine he is in for big trouble since he slept with a fellow marines wife. He may even be kicked out. Tell her good luck.
Unless the guy she cheated with is married, I don't think they can charge him with adultery. Adultery, as defined in the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, is: voluntary sexual intercourse by a MARRIED person with anyone other than his or her spouse.
The fact is this "girl" cheated on her husband. If you have the audacity to cheat, you must be woman enough to deal with the consequences. I highly doubt Miss Jana is talking about a friend... probably her pathetic excuse for a life... Why the hell do you get married if you are going to cheat? Seriously?