Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

A debate...

who's talking here?

Terica 4
☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co 2
Alotta VaJana 1
gidget 1
Dimples 5
Lorien 3
gator girl 2
Monster* Mouse 1
♥ Su ♥ 1
NOT THAT Tanya 2
Drama Llama 2
Romeosgirlie 1
Mrs Patch 8
♪♫♏ikayla 1
Sarah aka Tippy 3
imahohoho 2
Lissa970 4
¥ØÜnique™ 1
natalia 1
mamaold 1
Ruthie 6
Thread Killer 1
jennifer 3
*Navy*Wife* 1
The 1 The only 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 18 years ago -

With all the political ads and the upcoming elections I have been thinking a lot about something: Gay marriage. Specifically Prop 8 to overturn legally recognizing gay marriage. Keeping religion out of it, because we clearly have the separation of church and state...why should gay marriage be illegal? Remember, no religious based arguments... Go. 

♥ Su ♥ --- 18 years ago -

why should gay marriage be illegal? It shouldn't. But yes, I would love to hear WHY..Also :) 

gator girl --- 18 years ago -

i think it should be legal, you should be able to marry who you want , but then again i have alway been a supporter of gay rights 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

i couldnt tell u.it be interessting to see what ppl say to this. i'm not good with politics i get bend out of shape and then i might say something and get death threads again LOL 

♪♫♏ikayla --- 18 years ago -

I just saw a commercial tonight(I never watch tv so I don't know how long it has been playing) with a little girl in it running to her mommy all excited saying "look mommy I can marry a princess!" or something like that. Hmm. I have no problem with gay people whatesoever but I don't know where I stand on the marriage. Well no, i'm actually for it I suppose. But that commercial, when they said they would teach a 2nd grader it's ok to marry say, their best girl friend, i'd be thinking they'd go and try mackin' on eachother or something. Eek I don't know. 

Mrs Patch --- 18 years ago -

So tonight I was listening to how after Massachusetts legalized gay marriage, they started teaching it in schools. And you know, it kind of bothered me. I don't have children now, but I will one day soon and I don't want them to think that same sex marriage is the norm. Although I want them to be accepting of other people's lifestyles (or their own if that's the road they are choosing) I want them to believe in the Nuclear Family. I want to be the one to explain to them that everybody has a right to love, but I also want them to realize that if they do choose to live a gay lifestyle, it will be hard road to take. I want them to have the best chance at having a normal lifestyle, which a homosexual lifestyle is not. Don't bash me for saying it's not normal, because we as a society since the beginning of time have deemed it to be abnormal, hence why we refer to it in terms such as "queer." I don't want them to be gay bashers or anything like that either, because that would uspet me more than them being homosexual themselves. I wouldn't love my child any less if he/she were a homosexual, but I would fear for them. Acceptance of homosexuality and homosexuals as pertinent members of society has increased dramatically I would say in the past 5 years, but the stigmata that it comes with is still enough for me to believe that we are not as accepting as we say we are. I believe are moralistic issues which should be taught at home, by the parents. I don't believe legalizing gay marriaged should be a law that is revoked. It pulls at my heart strings to think that all those people are finally achieving something which about 10 years ago, I could not because I, too, was in the same situation since mixed ethnicity marriages were prohibited and I being Mexican could not have married an Anglo man. 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 18 years ago -

I blogged about this tonight and it's interesting that you posted your views because in my opinion, the ability to marry the same sex will not make you gay any more than the existance of a liquor store will make you an alcoholic. As far as societies view of homosexuality, views change over time. What was societies view of race minorities 50 years ago? Great strides. We still have race discrimination but it is far lower. And, before that women's rights? I can wear pants now. Woo hoo pants. You are born gay, IMO. Teaching your child that its wrong is teaching them THEY are wrong. And saying you can be gay...just not get married is like saying "fine do it if you must but go do it in a dark corner where no one can see you or be disgusted by your choices." More detrimental than accepting. Marriage is the union of two consensual adults committed to each other for life. I would be happy for my children to be influenced by a healthy relationship...even if they were both anatomically identical. By the time our children are adults perhaps the stigma will be erased. It won't be if we perpetuate the stereotype. We make the rules. We ARE society. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 18 years ago -

For the most part the reasons to ban gay marriage are religious... but from that stand point as well, it tells us not to judge. Backing off the religious prespective, the saying "a rose, by any other name, would smell as sweet" or "you could put lipstick on a pig, but it will still be a pig" both mean the same thing and related as far as I'm concerned. You can call it a union, a marriage, a life partnership or what ever you want. They are what they are and I personally don't know why I have the right to tell them society shouldn't acknowlage that they're togeather. If you don't want it taught in schools than maybe it should be looked into to change THAT rather than banning gay marriage. But that's just my fuzzy thought process at 6:30 am. 

*Navy*Wife* --- 18 years ago -

I guess I am old school, but I think this prop 8 brings many things to the table that will change a definition that has been in place so so many years.. dating back to B.C. IMO I think that if your sexuality is that where you are with the same sex, that is your choice however... I do not think that they should be able to marry and call it a "marriage". Its not a marriage, its actually anything but that. A "MARRIAGE" is between one man and one woman. There is nothing saying that a marriage is between 2 persons of the same sex. So my vote on this prop 8 is "YES"! 

mamaold --- 18 years ago -

I think that it should stay legal but I am not sure how I feel about it being taught to second graders. I am taking a human sexuality class in college right now and I have been reading about other cultures and how normal it is for men and women to havesame sex relationships. In one culture in Africa in order to become a "man" he boys must recieve seman from the elders. Women learn how to schieve and orgasim from other women. This is a very hard subject to decide on I don't want my second grader being taught anything about sex and who they should or shouldn't marry at that age. I feel that this is not a subject for elementary school but that is my job as a parent to tell them about different types of people. My niece right now is living with a gay couple and they can give her all the love and support that her parents couldn't I think it is good for her to be in that situation. However I know it is probably very confuaing for her. I think that it is our society (U.S.) that debates this. I would like to be an anthropologist and go do a study on gay relationships in other societies. for the record I have a very good friend from High school that is openly gay now and just legalized his relationship with his partner and I wouldn't want to deny him the right to marry the person he loves.I am just concerned about what this will teach in schools. 

Mrs Patch --- 18 years ago -

I like that although everyone's opinion varies, the post has maintained it's decorum. 

NOT THAT Tanya --- 18 years ago -

I personally do not mind if to gay people choose to marry.. However, we do not teach our morals or values in school (meaning religon, race to date ect..) I do not think that it should be taught in schools.. I think things of that nature should be up to the parent to educate their child. 

jennifer --- 18 years ago -

Can anyone really confirm or deny that they are really teaching 2nd graders all of this is schools. I have been into politics for years(actually working for both sides of the political forum) and whatever side of the table you sit on, or even none at all for that fact, we all know that things are perpetuated to make us fear change. I have to wonder, outloud, if this practice is really happening or is it just a scare tactic for the many people out there who are open to gay marriage but just don't want it "close" to home so to speak. The idea of it being taught to our children changes our opinion dramatically, but I think before we entertain that idea, we should ask for some hard corp proof that that really is the case, other then ads perpetuated by the other side. It seems to me that a lot of people are on the fence when it comes to this proposal only because of the idea of how it may effect our children. If that were to have never been brought up, you would have never had those problems/questions. There will always be those that are completely for gay marriage and those completely against it and I don't think that those will ever change there ways. It does upset me though that the many who have been "open" to the idea have been scared by tactics like this to pull at their heart strings. Just my opinion on the matter!! 

jennifer --- 18 years ago -

By the way it is nice to see a well thought out conversation on here for a change, while drama can be entertaining at times, it is questions like these that make us grow as human beings. When I sit on here and read some of the crap slung back and forth it really makes me think that some show there "age" and maturity levels" way to quick by flying off the handle at someone that you don't even know, or maybe you know them in real life, but just not on here, maybe the person that you are mudd slinging on here is a friend of yours yet it is a lot easier to act a certain way when it is autonomous. Just food for thought. I do agree with youMrsVA it is nice to see an accepting conversation happening to start the week off on a good foot!! 

jennifer --- 18 years ago -

By the way I have to just laugh at the ad on the right just in case anyone missed it, it really is funny how we can be hit from all sides, when a lot of money is being thrown at something!!! OK now I will shut up its to early for me =-) 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 18 years ago -

I think the point we're getting stuck on mostly is not "is gay okay", it's more like what is "marriage". Is it a marriage if they are swingers? Thats not one man and one woman... but it's still allowed. What about the marriages out of convience? Is that a marriage? I think since the state is involved, most of it is a public acknowladgement of a commitment to eachother. I don't see why the state has to be involved in it at all, but that's just me. 

Ruthie --- 18 years ago -

I personally do not mind if to gay people choose to marry.. However, we do not teach our morals or values in school (meaning religon, race to date ect..) I do not think that it should be taught in schools.. I think things of that nature should be up to the parent to educate their child. I have to agree,I also understand why there is sex-ed, but I think it's a failed program, I think we need condoms, and oral contraceptives, readily available to those who seek it right away, and yes even in high schools. Also if Church and State were truly separated this wouldn't be an issue. I'll be the first to admit, when I vote, I vote with my beliefs. 

Lorien --- 18 years ago -

Heterosexuals: ruining the sanctity of marriage since the invention of the concept. There is no good argument to deny anyone the right to marry whomever they choose. Religiously based or not. I don't give a crap if you want to marry someone of the same sex, someone you're related to, or multiple people at the same time. As long as all participants are of legal age and consenting, it's none of my business. 

Drama Llama --- 18 years ago -

because in my opinion, the ability to marry the same sex will not make you gay any more than the existance of a liquor store will make you an alcoholic. That was well said 

Dimples --- 18 years ago -

Didn't read it all but hubs and I were just talking about this the other day. I honestly could care less who marry's who but I think it's wrong that they are going to start teaching it in the schools. I definitely do not want my kids learning that it is ok for boys to marry boys and girls to marry girls. I will pull my kid out of school before that ever happens. Of course this is just my opinion 

Lorien --- 18 years ago -

Last year my kindergartener had sex ed class. When the paper came home, I immediately freaked but then her teacher explained what they'd be teaching. It was basically, Girls will grow up to be women, Boys will grow up to be men. Grandmas and Mommy's are women, Daddy's and grandpas are men. And....the whole, we don't let people touch our privates and if anyone does you tell an adult talk. 

Lorien --- 18 years ago -

Are you afraid someone might talk your straight kid into becoming gay, Dimples? I don't mean that in a snotty way, I'm really curious. 

Alotta VaJana --- 18 years ago -

I don't give a crap if you want to marry someone of the same sex, someone you're related to, or multiple people at the same time. As long as all participants are of legal age and consenting, it's none of my business. I completely agree with Lorien on this one. Marry who you want, do what you want with your body, it's a personal choice, not the government's to make for you. 

Terica --- 18 years ago -

My sister is a lesbian, so I speak from experience, I think Prop 8 is more than just marriage what about their rights: for medical insurance, life insurance etc… those are they real issues that need to be addressed. My sister says if Prop 8 allows her to “legally” marry then that’s nice. But if it gives her the ability to insure her family that’s all she cares about. 

Lissa970 --- 18 years ago -

I personally do not mind if to gay people choose to marry.. However, we do not teach our morals or values in school (meaning religon, race to date ect..) I do not think that it should be taught in schools.. I think things of that nature should be up to the parent to educate their child. This is exactly my thoughts on it. I dont anyone has a right to judge someones preference even if I dont agree with it, but the choice to teach it should be left to the parent, same as religon. 

Lissa970 --- 18 years ago -

I could be wrong, but I heard that in california (prior to legalized marriage) that you could insure you partner and have get your life insurance. Is that true? 

Drama Llama --- 18 years ago -

I definitely do not want my kids learning that it is ok for boys to marry boys and girls to marry girls. Thats what white men in the 60's said about their children going to school with black students... I think the more it's talked about the more tolerance there will be. Everyone has a right to be equal on all levels. I just think to myself how would I feel if I were in their shoes. Empathy is a great emotion that I don't think people use enough. 

Mrs Patch --- 18 years ago -

I could be wrong, but I heard that in california (prior to legalized marriage) that you could insure you partner and have get your life insurance. Is that true? Yes it's true. It covered any domestic partnership. I know because I had my boyfriend at the time covered on my insurance as my domestic partner. 

natalia --- 18 years ago -

I think that people should be able to marry whomever they want to marry. Who am I to say that no you can't marry so and so because you are the same sex. But if they are teaching it in the school I don't think they should be able to. I think that as parents we should be the ones that sit down with our chilren and talk to them about all of this...not a teacher who is going to have their own take and beliefs on it. 

Terica --- 18 years ago -

Yes but it doesn't apply to federal jobs i.e. the military. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground