Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Child Sex Offenders (POLL)

who's talking here?

*MommyToTwo* 2
Sarah aka Tippy 21
G's Wifey 2
Christina 1
Thread Killer 2
Blessed Births 3
VivaLaDoll 29
nostalgia 1
Me+3 3
Ritaclrk 2
InkSpot 1
Kruid's Wife 1
All Abouts 2
B*Bright 34
*JuDgE*TJ* 20
Adorkable 1
San Antonio Bound 3
valerie - palomina.etsy.com 47
♪Mikayla 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Child Sex Offenders (POLL)

I just saw something interesting on the news, they were asking if Child Sex Offenders should be castrated (i believe they are referring to chemical castration, where they take something to make them impotent, not the actual cutting off). Right now, chemical castration is voluntary for sex offenders. So my question is: Should repeat child sex offenders be forced to do chemical castration?

Yes. Vote
 
 89.2% (74)
No. Vote
 
 4.8% (4)
Undecided. Vote
 
 6.0% (5)
valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 17 years ago -

I just saw something interesting on the news, they were asking if Child Sex Offenders should be castrated (i believe they are referring to chemical castration, where they take something to make them impotent, not the actual cutting off). Right now, chemical castration is voluntary for sex offenders. So my question is: Should repeat child sex offenders be forced to do chemical castration? 

valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 17 years ago -

I voted yes, because child molesters have a compulsion that does not just go away after time in jail. It's part of who they are, and I don't think it's something that can be fixed or changed. They are always going to be sexually attracted to children no matter what, the best thing society can do IMO is to do things that might prevent them from being able to act on it. However, I do think that they should have some certain criteria that sex offenders should meet before my child (or someone else's) becomes their next "slip up". 

Me+3 --- 17 years ago -

My immediate gut reaction is 'HELL YES' However, I think Repeat Sexual Offenders have so many issues and it isn't just the physical which is driving them- obviously- an while the CC is a great start it's not addressing the real issue which is the core of the compulsion. Even without a working ding dong they are still extremely dangerous and calculating so I think that while it's a great start, so is a lethal injection ;-) JMO. 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 17 years ago -

Well as a mother i think anyone who has the gusto to harm a child should be punished to the fulest extent.. not just to the laws extent , cause they dont always do much ... they should be locked up , or forced to live on a compound together , away from normal people and children .. not just castrated.. 

valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 17 years ago -

I agree, because they can still molest a child even without a working penis. 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 17 years ago -

I agree, because they can still molest a child even without a working penis. the sick Fu(ks! 

San Antonio Bound --- 17 years ago -

I personally think ALL sex offenders should be forced to undergo castration of some kind, be it physical (perfect revenge for the victim if you ask me) or chemical (they use the depo shot for those of you who were wondering). 

Me+3 --- 17 years ago -

I agree, because they can still molest a child even without a working penis. Absolutely Tthe grooming, reshaping of boundaries et al is extremely damaging to a young child who is forming their own take on the world and theirs/others place in it. So, so, so damaging. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

There are diffrent levels of "sex offender" I think that castration of any sort would have to be used in the more serious cases. TECHNICALLY if an 18 year old has sex with a 17 year old that SAYS she's 18 then daddy presses charges the 18 year old is a sex offender- even if she's found with a fake ID. 

valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 17 years ago -

TECHNICALLY if an 18 year old has sex with a 17 year old that SAYS she's 18 then daddy presses charges the 18 year old is a sex offender- even if she's found with a fake ID yeah, i don't think those people should be forced to register as sex offenders, because in that case my hubby would be one LOL I'm only referring to the for real child molesters. And believe it or not, there are plenty that say THEY WILL offend again if given the chance. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

The reason it may not work are the lesser offenders don't deserve it, and the most awful of offenders that DO deserve it - will just use an item instead. Sexual offences are rarely about sex. Meanwhile it should be considered an option by the court. But I also think women that lose their kids because of serious abuses should be "fixed" as well. But that's just my thought on it. 

San Antonio Bound --- 17 years ago -

I'm sure there are extenuating circumstances for some people labeled as "sex offenders", but because of childhood experiences, I tend to be rather unforgiving of anyone who is given that label. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

I tend to be rather unforgiving of anyone who is given that label. Which is why I think they need to re-work the system at least a little in naming. There are diffrent degrees- but when it comes to that label that's all anyone hears. I just happen to know someone that has that label due to MAKING OUT with a girl that HAD a fake ID. She was a few months out from 18 and he was 19.. BUT she was a cops daughter. He will forever have the label. They even used his profile in the news when they did a story about SEXUAL preditors on Myspace. I'm not saying you're wrong to read the label and be weary- that's what the label is for. I think they just need to come up with a better way of using it. Besides, a label doesn't work if you can't see it. At a public park or something you can't tell the labeled from unlabeled. That's scary to me. 

Blessed Births --- 17 years ago -

How will cutting off the gonads solve anything? It's what has corrupted their minds that need to be addressed, not chopping the wanker off. Kind of like cutting the fingers of an anorexic, will stop them from making themselves vomit after eating? 

*MommyToTwo* --- 17 years ago -

If it is proven that they molested a child - they deserve death. They will do it again. They do not deserve to be a part of our society. 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 17 years ago -

cutting the fingers of an anorexic, will stop them from making themselves vomit after eating? thats bulemia .. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

will stop them from making themselves vomit after eating? The idea being that if they do it again it has to be premediatated rather than just acting out on an impulse. But if that's the case the offender also needs his hands removed. 

valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 17 years ago -

How will cutting off the gonads solve anything? It's what has corrupted their minds that need to be addressed, not chopping the wanker off. Kind of like cutting the fingers of an anorexic, will stop them from making themselves vomit after eating? well this is chemical castration...it's not cutting the penis off. its just a chemical that prevents them from being able to get an erection. but i dont believe that they can be fixed with therapy or any of that BS. just like you will always be attracted to men, child molesters will always want children. i think its a permanent state. 

valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 17 years ago -

cutting the fingers of an anorexic, will stop them from making themselves vomit after eating? thats bulemia .. lol i was going to say that too 

valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 17 years ago -

If it is proven that they molested a child - they deserve death. They will do it again. They do not deserve to be a part of our society. yep, thats what my hubby says too. i would have to agree- i dont care how harsh it sounds, because i would personally murder anyone that did that to my baby. 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 17 years ago -

sexual child molesters tend to be sociopathic and show no remorse for what they have done and have a 85% probability of repeating the offense if given the chance , these are the ones who should be severly punished. once they commit that crime seldom do they ever ignore that urge. And a psycologist is not going to help that 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

you will always be attracted to men, child molesters will always want children. i think its a permanent state. They have found some of the chemicals and places in the brain that MAKE someone attracted to men or women now! It's early in it's research, and it's being used to study what makes someone gay. I think it would be better put to use on child molesters. Maybe one day IF the research goes well they could SOLVE the wiring problem in their brain and let them live normal lives. Maybe even predict it? 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 17 years ago -

use on child molesters. Maybe one day IF the research goes well they could SOLVE the wiring problem in their brain and let them live normal lives. Maybe even predict it? but who wants to waste money on these people?? i dont , you know? 

Me+3 --- 17 years ago -

Sarah, very true. They've come out with studies that they claim show genetic mutations as well. It's a thought provoking field, that's for sure. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

but who wants to waste money on these people?? i dont , you know? Before they molest... I do. Even if it is just to protect the children that COULD have been their victims. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

i said no....i don't see what it will solve....i mean....if we do that, shouldn't we cut off their hands, toes, tongues, etc...anything else that can go inside a child/person..... (toes i know not very likely but we are talking about crazy people here) What if another child is the sexual predator?? Should we castrate him/her too?? If an older boy (say 14 or 15) is raping an 8 year old girl??? or a 14 or 15 year old girl rapes/molests a 8 year old boy??? should those sex offenders be "fixed"??? IMO, castrating them won't do anything....it's all in the head.....lets just suck out their brains like babies getting aborted... unfortunately, all we can do is throw them in jail... **note:: wasn't trying to start anything with the abortion comment...so please don't start** 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 17 years ago -

Before they molest... I do. Even if it is just to protect the children that COULD have been their victims. but that in and of itself is hard to do .. would this scan be done at birth? because you said its the same for gays .. when gays are gay from birth. and who would fund it ya know? it would be a hard thing to work all the kinks out of , but if it works then cool ..but as a taxpayer , who most of all this funding comes from , it just seems like alot of money for them to be "well" 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

i would personally murder anyone that did that to my baby. what if you had 2 children...a 13 year old and a 4 year old....and the 13 year old molested/raped the 4 year old....would you think your older child deserved death?? would you murder him/her? or would you want to try and get them help.... basically you all are saying that sex offenders are all lost causes.....well, what would you do if your OWN child grew up to be one??? would your thoughts change then??? 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 17 years ago -

IMO, castrating them won't do anything....it's all in the head.....lets just suck out their brains like babies getting aborted... okay one.. i got sickened by the abortion thing.. just putting my opinion out there... you probably shouldnt have said it if you didnt want a reaction. and Two . Molestation is not about sex , true , its about dominance and proving that they can be more powerful than another being , but chemically castrating then , it takes a small part of that ability to be dominant away .. it doesnt completely solve it true , but its a good first step in alot of ways 

nostalgia --- 17 years ago -

Besides, a label doesn't work if you can't see it. At a public park or something you can't tell the labeled from unlabeled. That's scary to me. They (i'm not placing the lessor offendors in this) should Tattoo SO or somthing on their forehead. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground