Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Twilight: Don't read if you haven't finished all the books! Spoiler alert

who's talking here?

Jennifer P 3
CoCo 15
Heather 8
luvmydevildawg 8
A Beautiful Mess 13
M.o.d.sfixyourself 10
ello 2
Donnye oregonbound bye camp p 2
JustAPrincess 14

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

I keep seeing people say "I'm Team Jacob." I've read all of the books (love them) and am wondering how, after finishing the series, you can still wish that Bella and Jacob got together. Don't get me wrong, I like Jacob too. I think he is a great character, but I never thought he should be or would be with Bella. Everything worked out perfectly in the end and everyone ended up completely happy and with who they were meant to be with. So it makes me wonder, would YOU want to steal your own daughter's soul mate? I'm sure you probably wouldn't, so why do you think Bella and Jacob should have ended up together? So anyways, this is just meant to be a fun post to discuss these issues, for people who have read all of the books. Whenever Twilight comes up on here, we can never really talk about it openly for fear that we will ruin it for others... 

JustAPrincess --- 17 years ago -

Well I can't answer your question because I am also team Edward. I like Jacob but I like Edward best for Bella. 

Donnye oregonbound bye camp p --- 17 years ago -

i know what you mean! the whole team jacob or team edward doesnt make sense to me lol. Specailly when he was made for Renesmee and her for him!! 

ello --- 17 years ago -

same here..I like jacob but I love edward and bella together 

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

i know what you mean! the whole team jacob or team edward doesnt make sense to me lol. Specailly when he was made for Renesmee and her for him!! Exactly, so that's why I'm curious about why someone would be "Team Jacob" 

ello --- 17 years ago -

I liked the ending to Breaking Dawn. I thought it was sooo cute how he could finally see her thoughts! 

Jennifer P --- 17 years ago -

i hate to see the shirts that say "i run with werewolves" dont you know thats not even what he is??? 

Jennifer P --- 17 years ago -

I liked the ending to Breaking Dawn. I thought it was sooo cute how he could finally see her thoughts! me too. thats where the baby gets her gift from....Bella 

Donnye oregonbound bye camp p --- 17 years ago -

haha i just finished the last book, like literally 30 minutes ago the ending was awesome, i wish they would have put somthing about the future about Jacob and Renesmee 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

ok ok. I am team Jacob for a few reasons 1) bells wouldn't have to die and become a vampire to be with him 2) she was and is an idiot. I like Edward, but he is too controlling, she acted like a moron over him. Sorry. Maybe I am too old now but she was such a sap Edward leaving him. All I could think was what a little girl she was. I know weird. 3) 

luvmydevildawg --- 17 years ago -

I am Team Jacob. It actually means that I would have preferred it if the story had not made Jacob and Renesmee soulmates. Now though, since they are, I understand that Bella and Jacob would not be together. I actually liked Bella and Edward in Breaking Dawn. My love for Jacob came from books 2 and 3. I loved Edward in the first book. I disliked him immensely in book 2. So, by book 3, I was wishing that Bella would pick Jacob. That's why I am Team Jacob. I prefer Jacob to Edward. 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

3) if she never went over to the dark side Jacob never would have imprinted and she could lead a normal life 4) the love scene with Jacob way better talking about how hot his body temp was. And that she could kiss him more than Edward. 5). I like dark haired men. I will take 6'4 tan dark haired man than a guy who wants to eat me. 

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

1) bells wouldn't have to die and become a vampire to be with him True, but he did not imprint on her, so we knew from the get-go that she wasn't his soul mate. He wasn't "meant" for her, you know? 

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

I like dark haired men. I will take 6'4 tan dark haired man than a guy who wants to eat me. lol 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

6). Jacob won in book 2 in my eyes. I wanted to kill Edward. 7) book 3 made me team Jacob. 

luvmydevildawg --- 17 years ago -

Oh my gosh VoodoosBoo, you can say #4 again! That was hotness! 

luvmydevildawg --- 17 years ago -

Hmm, VoodoosBoo, we might be the same age. LOL! 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

I know by far the best make out scene in all the books Coco. What I am saying is that if she ended up with Jacob than the baby would have never been there in the first place for him to Imprint and they would have been happy together. 

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

Okay, I think I can understand that. So, throughout the book you liked him better, but while you're reading the ending of Breaking Dawn, you didn't necessarily still think, pick him Bella! 

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

Coco. What I am saying is that if she ended up with Jacob than the baby would have never been there in the first place for him to Imprint and they would have been happy together. Didn't see this until after I typed what I just put 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

lol. Devil. All I could think was "stupid teenager" 

luvmydevildawg --- 17 years ago -

Yes, that's what I think Coco. If Bella would have picked Jacob, Renesmee would never have been born. But, I do understand that Bella and Jacob were not meant to be together. It's just that all of their interactions were hotness! I felt that way about Edward in book 1 but books 2 and 3 were all about Jacob. I can't wait for the 2nd movie! 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

after they made out and she realized that she was in love with Jacob. Jacob was the healthier choice. He was there her when Edward was stupid. She was obsessed with Edward. She wants to become a vampire but yet she was all weirdes out by marriage and didn't want to go to college. Stupid LOL. 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

yeah. I'm a total craddle robber borderline pedofile for tayler lautner. I think he was the perfect pick. 

luvmydevildawg --- 17 years ago -

Also, like someone else said, she wouldn't have had to die to be with Jacob. She could have lived in Forks and been with her father. 

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

I was always an Edward lover, so I read through the 2nd book as quickly as possible to get to the part when Edward came back lol. I didn't really start to like Jacob until the 4th book when she told it from his point of view. I liked that. Bella could be little tedious at times. After I finished the series the first time, when I was no longer under the stress of worrying that she might not end up with Edward (lol), I went back and reread it again and was able to appreciate Jacob more. I wish she would continue the series. She kind of left it open for the possibility when she mentioned that the Volturri would one day come back to settle the score. 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

forget the second movie. I want to skip to 3 

JustAPrincess --- 17 years ago -

I can see what you guys are saying. I spent most of the third book being annoyed with Bella. I like both of the guys and thought they were both good for her. Lol I think the only reason I like Edward better is beacuse I like him better for me. 

Jennifer P --- 17 years ago -

She could have lived in Forks and been with her father. she can still live there. 

CoCo --- 17 years ago -

Also, like someone else said, she wouldn't have had to die to be with Jacob. She could have lived in Forks and been with her father. But, just like with Edward, he would have stayed young while she got older (creepy) and she would have died way before him, unless he gave up shape-shifting... 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground