so i babysitt my sisters kids on the weekend she works double so i just keep them all weekend well madie is 3 years old and yesterday she wanted to color so i got everything ready so she could and when i went to pick her up she was wet she had wet herself so since she did that she didnt get to color. few hours later we are watching a movie and i ask her about ever half hour or so if she has to go potty well she wet herself again so i spanked her. is that wrong of me?? mt sister said she would have done the same thing
personally i wouldnt have spanked my neice for having an accident. I understand you kept asking but to me its not my place to spank my sis/bro's kids regardless if they say its ok. sounds like you got frustrated and thats why you did it.
I'm a fan of natural consequences. For an accident past the age of being pottytrained I would make them clean up the mess they made. For me personally spanking and withholding activities is not the consequence I would give, but for you as the babysitter the appropriate action would be what the parent (your sister) wants you to do, within reason of course.
eta I would personally never spank someone elses child even if they wanted me to, but understand that some people do believe in spanking.
I would make her clean up herself, sorry but spanking because a child had an accident , even know was the second one is uncalled for it.. is she to busy playing, is she sad.. a potty trained child don't wet herself because she wants.. some is behind her behavior , so the peeing is a consequence, by spanking you are treating the symptom not the reason.. correct the reason. Or she is not potty trained fully yet, and again spanking is not a way to potty training anyone.
As a sitter you should be handle some control, but spanking a child that is not my.. is never OK.. is only teaching that anyone can land a hand on her and that we fix frustration by hitting
I would never spank someone else's child, regardless of what they did. I know I would be p!ssed if someone else ever hit my child.
Spanking will not make a child want to use the potty, it can actually invoke a fear of going potty.
You don't spank a kid for peeing themself. Way to set them back. Some children don't have the bladder control well into school age. It will only make them feel bad about themselves. Its a body fuction. I am going to come over and thump you in the head everytime you fart. What is your address?
I don't really agree with spanking a whole lot in any case. I think it teaches kids that it's okay to hit someone when you're angry with them.
Parents wonder why their children start smacking them when they get mad.
I don't really agree with spanking a whole lot in any case. I think it teaches kids that it's okay to hit someone when you're angry with them.
Parents wonder why their children start smacking them when they get mad.
I spank my daughter. She doesn't try to hit me back, she's 6 and better behaved then that. Granted I only spank her when she is in serious trouble, I don't do it often.
I am not against spanking all together. Sometimes and some kids. Not all discipline works on all kids. Spanking is never cool for peeing. Potty training is a natural process. People who push kids too hard to do this only punish themselves. I have with all my kids let them do it in their own time. Never had to spank any of them over it. They learned differently but all got it.
Granted I only spank her when she is in serious trouble
I agree...there is a diff w/spanking and abuse....
Plenty of people have gotten spankings and grown up fine....
It kills me when I see some kids who are so out of control and the parents are like...please can you sit down...ill buy you a ice cream..
gag me....
I spank my daughter. She doesn't try to hit me back, she's 6 and better behaved then that. Granted I only spank her when she is in serious trouble, I don't do it often.
I meant more along the lines of hitting for every little infraction. Parents that smack their kids every single time the parent gets angry with their kids.
It kills me when I see some kids who are so out of control and the parents are like...please can you sit down...ill buy you a ice cream..
gag me....
Bribing always backfires!
The kids I see hitting their parents (one in particular) are the ones who aren't spanked and reprimanded.
Spanking is never cool for peeing.
My daughter still has an accident once in a while, but I don't spank her for it. I make her strip her bed and throw the sheets in the wash and she helps me make her bed. She wasn't potty trained until she was almost 3 1/2. She REFUSED to go, she would kick and scream and cry. I didn't push it.
Bribing always backfires!
they are idiots...butthen again some people want to be FRIENDS not PARENTS...
cracks me up...I still remember the 9 yr old getting thongs at VS....
girl I almost smacked her momma...she was yacking on the phone and then saying that she could pick out some stuff for her friends for her slumber party
It kills me when I see some kids who are so out of control and the parents are like...please can you sit down...ill buy you a ice cream..
We have a friend like that! We all went to Hollywood & ate at the Hooters up there & he would NOT sit still he was throwing stuff & acting a mess, do you know what they ordered him for "lunch" CHOCOLATE CAKE!!! Because it made him be quiet!!
I am not a huge fan of spanking(Not against it either) mainly because my daughter is 2 so usually when she is in "trouble" she is just doing normal 2 year old things like touching everything, PLUS you can pop her little booty all day & she really doesn't care lol time out=torture for her :D
I didn't push it.
Potty training isn't something that you CAN push, atleast I don't think so. It's one of those if they are ready they are ready kinds of things.
Like others have said, I wouldn't spank a kid that wasn't mine, curious why are you asking us for approval if you were wrong or not? Do you feel guilty?
Potty training isn't something that you CAN push, atleast I don't think so. It's one of those if they are ready they are ready kinds of things.
I see it a lot here and IRL. Moms think it should be done at like 18 months. HAHAHA. They get themselves so worked up. Like here on base, your kid has to be 3 and potty trained to do the Enrichment Program. They want them in so bad they try to force them into the process. Or its like a badge of honor. "*I* had my kids trained at 22 months...top THAT!" Hey congrats...really...quite an accomplishment. LOL
Yeah, let's give an out of control child something with more sugar!!!
Yeah & they used it as one of those "if you don't sit still you won't get your cake" kind of things.