Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Do you think this is too graphic?

who's talking here?

L4OT 1
Mrs.Primo 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 21
Charlie'sWife 1
Thread Killer 1
Sair 1
J.A.C.K. Here 1
Domestic Darling 1
Jessica H. 1
Mrs.B 1
LuciusLaVey 2
Toodles 7
B*Bright 25
JamieBear *PU Grammar Captain* 5
Kiki 1
San Antonio Bound 1
Texas9 11
Going - Going - GONE! 2
MOMx4 ¾ 13
εїзJelly_Bean 8
ashleyx3 20
the koz's 1
Lexi-*Ind.*S*Director* 9
★♫ guestspeaker 2
Vanbam 2
Flameless in a Handbasket 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think this is too graphic?

I was just curious as to what people thought about it? Do you think it is too graphic for a PSA or do you think it will be good for teens and adults to see? http://www.parentdish.com/2009/08/25/will-bloody-texting-psa-get-the-message-to-teens/?icid=main|hp-laptop|dl1|link3|http%3A%2F%2Fwww.parentdish.com%2F2009%2F08%2F25%2Fwill-bloody-texting-psa-get-the-message-to-teens%2F

Too Graphic Vote
 
 17.9% (7)
I think it is ok for a PSA Vote
 
 82.1% (32)
Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

I was just curious as to what people thought about it? Do you think it is too graphic for a PSA or do you think it will be good for teens and adults to see? 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

oops. i didnt link it right. let me try again. 

Toodles --- 17 years ago -

I saw it on the news, No I don't think its too graphic, I am sure teens have seen worse in movies, I just hope it will work. 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 17 years ago -

Oh my gosh that was graphic! But not to graphic to show to teens and parents. I think they need to learn the "truth". At my old high school they did something kinda like this but with drugs and alcohol not texting. 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

I am sure teens have seen worse in movies I think it is good and teens need to see it, but as a PSA younger children might see it too. this is from the article. "sometimes you have to push the envelope, but if you put this on TV, you'd have no control over who your audience was. Younger kids could see it" 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

At my old high school they did something kinda like this but with drugs and alcohol not texting they did at mine too. it was called Shattered Dreams! 

Toodles --- 17 years ago -

I think it would be good to show at all driver's Ed. classes 

JamieBear *PU Grammar Captain* --- 17 years ago -

they could have left the infant in the carseat out though... that wasn't really necessary if you ask me... first of all the child didn't have a mark on him and we all know that a crash like that would more than likely not result in the death of an infant. JMO though, please don't jump down my throat. 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 17 years ago -

What is a PCA? 

the koz's --- 17 years ago -

I about started crying when they were saying they were not getting a response from the infant and the little girl telling her parents to wake up.. I have seen worse than that for a drinking and driving video when i was in high school and that was 10 years ago 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

PSA - Public Service Announcement 

JamieBear *PU Grammar Captain* --- 17 years ago -

What is a PCA? PSA is a Public Service Announcement... 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

they could have left the infant in the carseat out though... that wasn't really necessary if you ask me they baby part made me so sad =( i think they were just trying to make the point that texting can effect anybody. 

Toodles --- 17 years ago -

The whole thing is 30 min long 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

The whole thing is 30 min long really??? lol i just saw the 4 minute clip...that would be a REALLY long PSA 

★♫ guestspeaker --- 17 years ago -

i think they could have done without the baby. it got the point across well enough without adding the infant to it. : ( 

Mrs.B --- 17 years ago -

I think they should show this in ALL DRIVERS ED CLASSES... 

Toodles --- 17 years ago -

really??? lol i just saw the 4 minute clip...that would be a REALLY long PSA Yes I was watching the news and the person who made the PSA was talking about it, and said its a total of 30 min, and the boy in the back seat crying for his parent to wake up is his son. 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

i think they could have done without the baby. it got the point across well enough without adding the infant to it. : ( girlllll.....we should do something later! lol 

JamieBear *PU Grammar Captain* --- 17 years ago -

they baby part made me so sad =( i think they were just trying to make the point that texting can effect anybody. Oh I understand WHY they put it... just didn't feel it was necessary... maybe that's just me though... my friend, her husband, and her baby, were involved in a car accident about 6 years ago... she was also 6 months pregnant at the time. Her husband was driving and their baby, he was 2, was in the backseat. A drunk driver that was texting on her phone hit them head on going 70... the car spun to a stop and then caught on fire... my friend was the only survivor... her husband was killed instantly and a passer-by tried to get the baby out but it was too late. 

★♫ guestspeaker --- 17 years ago -

Oh I understand WHY they put it... just didn't feel it was necessary... maybe that's just me though... i completely agree 

JamieBear *PU Grammar Captain* --- 17 years ago -

she did give birth to a healthy baby girl 2 months later... she hasn't really been the same since then though... :( 

Charlie'sWife --- 17 years ago -

we all know that a crash like that would more than likely not result in the death of an infant really? Think so? Head on then slammed in to again by another vehicle? Hmm... 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

ugh...the first 4 minutes made me cry....where is the other 26? 

L4OT --- 17 years ago -

i am not sure what i think about this. when i saw the unresponsive baby my stomach just rolled. on one hand i think it is a good idea to show this because in reality this is what could happen and people need to see what their texting or messing around in the car while driving can do to innocent people but on the other hand it is a bit gory. my tummy hurts now 

Texas9 --- 17 years ago -

her husband was killed instantly and a passer-by tried to get the baby out but it was too late omg that is horrible. i am so sorry =( 

Thread Killer --- 17 years ago -

I think it's a good psa, but for the U.S., it's too graphic for television. It should be ran in highschool classes whether it be drivers ed, pe, prevention lessons in homeroom etc. It may be too graphic for national television, but I have seen just as bad if not worse in highschool classes for alcohol prevention, drug prevention, etc. If teens are viewing such graphic things about drug abuse, then why not about something that they all do? It shows the impact on themselves, their friends, and other people, physically. 

Sair --- 17 years ago -

while i agree with the article that this should not be on TV (you never know who's watching), i do think it's wise to show it to teens at school. have a parent release signed & hold an assembly. too many teens (and adults) are careless and don't pay nearly enough attention to the road and the drivers on it. 

JamieBear *PU Grammar Captain* --- 17 years ago -

really? Think so? Head on then slammed in to again by another vehicle? Hmm... guess you didn't read the "disclaimer" at the end of my comment... 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground