If you were told by mulitiple Dr.'s that at 18 weeks gestation that your baby had holoprosencephaly and was missing part of his skull, and had spinal bifida at the base of the skull would you go against Dr.'s orders and not terminate the pregnancy? The baby is only expected to live 2 days after birth. I'm just curious on your input. Btw, the baby will keep growing but the skull will not. Please don't be too harsh, I don't know what I would do. This is all happening to my 16 year old brother and his 18 year old girlfriend. I really don't know how to feel. I think I'm just in shock.
Doctors can make mistake they told a friend of mine her baby was GUARANTEED gonna have down syndrome and other health issues. Her baby is happy and healthy to this day with no health issues or down syndrome! Are they ready to have a baby? How are they taking the news?
Have they thought of all their choices thuroughly (having the baby and it coming out perfectly healthy or having the problems the doctor says and loosing a baby or terminating it now and always wondering WHAT IF) making a decision like that is never easy I will pray the baby is fine and whatever they decide they do b/c they feels it's what's best for THEM not b/c a doctor told them to
i couldn't terminate the baby. you never know God is in the works. my god daughter was really sick and they had the same thing with the drs. yet today at almost 2 she is compl. healthy.
I don't know. My BIL/SIL terminated their 4th baby last year, when she was 6 months pregnant, something to do with lack of kidney function or something. I just know that I am so grateful to have never been in a position like that. I am thinking good thoughts for your brother.
i googled images too....but those are the extreme cases...look at this website:: link
It shows a wide variety of holoprosencephaly "looks" ....some of those kids look normal....
i will pray for your brother, i however would be completely devastated if I was ever told to abort... um, depending on if its going to affect my health to carry full term I would choose not too.. god works miracles, im sure its completely devastating to them..
i dont know if i would be able to terminate the pregnancy. theres too many what ifs and thats teh hard part. I think i would want that possible 1 or 2 days with the baby! then if god wants it then i'll have a guardian angel.
i agree with the dr's making mistakes it happens but they have had like 5 different second opinons. all the results have come back saying the same thing. i just don't know, i don't think i could terminate either because of the what if...but i just don't want that baby to suffer. spinal bifida at the base of the skull is pretty serious but part of his skull is gone and won't grow. plus his brain never split...part of the reason his skull is missing.
oh wow, what a terrible and difficult time it must be for them and your family. i'm sorry they are put in the position to make such a heartbreaking choice. me personally, i would not terminate. you never know, the doctors could be wrong....if they are right though, i would cherish those precious few days i had with my baby and have no regrets. god bless them!
oh and my brother's gf has epilepsy...so there is a pretty significant risk to her health. despite what my mother thinks and being selfish myself i hope she carries him to term. i want to be able to be there to at least see my nephew.
I personally wouldn't terminate it as San O said if it isn't going to affect HER health then maybe its better to keep the baby b/c of the what if's that may creep up later making her regret her decision. it is better have loved and lost than to have never loved at all and they would at least be able to see their beutiful baby even if they are only destined for heaven after a few days on earth.
oh and my brother's gf has epilepsy...so there is a pretty significant risk to her health
to be honest my birth mother had/has epilepsy and I am here and she is/was fine (ffrom when I knew her I am adopted so can't tell ya for sure)
alright from a person who has been through having a child in the nicu one for 5 months and the other 8 months and never being able to bring them home.. its extremely hard.. Me personally if i knew that they would only suffer when they are alive.. Its not worth putting a child through that.. if there was a chance for them to lead a normal life, I would say keep the baby. But if there is no way what so ever that child will live let alone have a good life. What i mean by have a good life is not being in pain your whole life, not being able to somewhat function at all.. then yes I personally would abort the baby.. I am pro choicce to a point.. I would not wish apon my worst enemy what I have gone through in my life.. When my twins were there in the nicu I had some of the most toughest decisions in my life to make.. And at the time i was only 19.. That was hard anough for me to do let alone a 16 year old and a 18.. I have to say that the twins taught me a lot while they were here.. And I know that they are in heaven and are guardian angels to my two beautiful girls now.. But to watch what they went through, and to know how much pain i know they felt.. It was truely heartbreaking for me.. If my son would have lived, he would have been in pain all of his life, never been off a ventilator, and would be bed ridden his whole life.. That is no way for anyone to live.. But the decision has to be up to them.. I would definately tell them to way the pros and cons, and fully understand everything from their doctor.. I wish them the best of luck.. and I am truely sorry for what is going on with them.. Its very very heartbreaking to here that this is happening.. I will keep them in my thoughts and prayers to do what is best for them and their unborn child
What is Holoprosencephaly?
Holoprosencephaly (HPE) is a birth defect that occurs during the first few weeks of intrauterine life. HPE is a disorder in which the fetal brain does not grow forward and divide as it is supposed to during early pregnancy (incomplete cleavage of the embryonic forebrain/failure of the prosencephalon to cleave into the cerebral and lateral hemispheres).
This brain malformation can range from mild to severe and is classified into four types:
(1) Alobar (severe)--where the brain is not divided and there are severe abnormalities (there is an absence of the interhemispheric fissure, a single primitive ventricle, fused thalami, and absent third ventricle, olfactory bulbs and tracts and optic tracts).
(2) Semi-Lobar (moderate)--where the brain is partially divided and there are some moderate abnormalities; where there are two hemispheres in the rear but not the front of the brain (there are partially separated cerebral hemispheres and a single ventricular cavity).
(3) Lobar (mild)--where the brain is divided and there are some mild abnormalities (there is a well developed interhemispheric fissure however there is some fusion of structures).
(4) Middle Interhemispheric Variant (MIHV) -- where the middle of the brain (posterior frontal and parietal lobes) are not well separated.
Children diagnosed with HPE may have a small head (microcephaly), excessive fluid in the brain (hydrocephalus), variable degrees of mental retardation, epilepsy, endocrine abnormalities, or abnormalities of other organ systems such as cardiac, skeletal, genitourinary, and gastrointestinal. Mildly affected children may exhibit few symptoms and may live a normal life.
Facial deformities are often present in many children diagnosed with HPE. Mild forms of facial abnormalities may include a flat single-nostril nose (cebocephaly), close set eyes (hypotelorism), cleft lip and/or palate, or just one upper middle tooth (single maxillary central incisor). More severe facial deformities may include a single central eye (cyclopia), a nose located on the forehead (proboscis), or missing facial features.
What causes holoprosencephaly?
The cause of HPE is currently unknown. Often, no specific cause can be identified. Suggested risk factors include maternal diabetes, infections during pregnancy (syphilis, toxoplasmosis, rubella, herpes, cytomegalovirus), and various drugs taken during pregnancy (alcohol, aspirin, lithium, thorazine, anticonvulsants, hormones, retinoic acid). Women with previous pregnancy loss and first trimester bleeding are also more likely to have a child diagnosed with HPE.
Although many children with HPE have normal chromosomes, specific chromosomal abnormalities have been identified in some patients. There is evidence that in some families, HPE is inherited (autosomal dominant as well as autosomal or X-linked recessive inheritance).
Several genes have been identified that play a role in holoprosencephaly.
How common is this defect?
It is estimated that HPE affects between 1 in 5,000-10,000 live births. Since many pregnancies with a fetus diagnosed with HPE end in miscarriage, the frequency of HPE among all pregnancies may be as high as 1 in 200-250. Current studies indicate that only 3% of all fetuses with HPE survive to delivery and the vast majority of these infants do not survive past the first six months of life. The prognosis for a child diagnosed with HPE depends on the type of HPE and the presence of associated anomalies. The most severely affected children may live several months or years and the least affected may live a normal life span. Almost two-thirds of affected patients have alobar HPE and approximately one quarter are diagnosed with semilobar HPE.
Summary
HPE is characterized by a failure of transformation of the prosencephalon into cerebral hemispheres with separate lateral ventricles. HPE has many associated anomalies, both of the nervous system and face. HPE is also associated with malformations in other body systems, particularly when it has a chromosomal etiology. The true spectrum of HPE, its clinical manifestations, and underlying etiologies require further elucidation. Applying this knowledge to individuals and their families is of utmost importance.
link
good point about spending their short little life in pain....OP, do they know if the baby is born alive, will it be in pain the entire time? that would also be a deciding factor for me. it kinda makes me feel selfish, giving birth to a baby that will feel nothing but pain and suffering in its few days just so i can see him.
koz, i am so sorry for your loss. i can't even begin to imagine what you had to endure. i don't know you but you are truly a brave soul. thank you all for your kind words.
Doctors can make mistake they told a friend of mine her baby was GUARANTEED gonna have down syndrome and other health issues. Her baby is happy and healthy to this day with no health issues or down syndrome!
This happened with my Cousin. They told her that her 1st child has all kinds of problems and IF she carried her to term she would have all kinds of medical issues and not survive the first week. We her daughter is now 7 years old and there is NOTHING wrong with her! There is no down syndrome or ANYTHING...doc do eff up!
Personally I dont know what I would do..thats a tough call. Im pro life but if the babys life will be as difficult as it says it will be..I would be horrifed..especially carrying it and having it.
one last thing....this website is about a baby named Afton who was born with Down Syndrome and Holoprosencephaly Lobar (a less severe type) and he turned 4 on April 4th 2009.
would never terminate a pregnancy based on what a doctor says. They have been wrong-many times.
same here they said my oldest would have a genetic disorder that would kill her shirtly after birth (trisomy 18) they HIGHLY SUGGESTED that we Terminate...........we did not and shes now 11 years old and well
it kinda makes me feel selfish, giving birth to a baby that will feel nothing but pain and suffering in its few days just so i can see him.
I completely agree