Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What do you do when your child tells you no?

who's talking here?

EastCoast 2
Mrs.Primo 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 1
Maureen 5
Giraffe 1
Lily 1
Sair 1
✧cristina✧ 2
MOMx4 ¾ 1
εїзJelly_Bean 2
Wife, Mother amazing Women 3
Lexi-*Ind.*S*Director* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

My son is in this stage where he's constantly telling hubby and I 'no'. We tell him to go potty. We get 'no.' We tell him to get his shoes and get ready to go bye-bye and he tells us 'no.' Nothing is working for this. He is 3 years old. What do you do when your child tells you no?? 

MOMx4 ¾ --- 17 years ago -

Time out 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

Time out Tried this. He sits still but can scream his little heart out forever. We don't let him out of timeout until he's apologized. 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

he will learn 

Wife, Mother amazing Women --- 17 years ago -

We do it for her. If she says no I wont put my shoes on or no about getting in the car we sit her down and put her shoes on her and carry her to the car. We show her who is in charge. I dont care if she screams from now till next christmas we are the parents and she has to listen. Also if she wont hold our hand in public she has to go in the stroller or cart. Its too dangerous for her to not listen. Now we dont boss our kids arond and generally she does what she is told but when she doesnt we make her do what she has to do. 

Wife, Mother amazing Women --- 17 years ago -

We do it for her. If she says no I wont put my shoes on or no about getting in the car we sit her down and put her shoes on her and carry her to the car. We show her who is in charge. I dont care if she screams from now till next christmas we are the parents and she has to listen. Also if she wont hold our hand in public she has to go in the stroller or cart. Its too dangerous for her to not listen. Now we dont boss our kids arond and generally she does what she is told but when she doesnt we make her do what she has to do. 

Lexi-*Ind.*S*Director* --- 17 years ago -

since he screams, have you considered just doing time out in a room by himself and close the door, so he can scream all he wants but nobody pays any attention? 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

since he screams, have you considered just doing time out in a room by himself and close the door, so he can scream all he wants but nobody pays any attention?  I've done this also. There are days when I really can't handle the screaming and on those days, I put him in his room. Yesterday I actually took ALL of the toys out of his room and put them in the garage. I have a feeling it'll take a bit longer for him to stop doing this than I was hoping. Some days he's better than others but there are days that he is a little devil. 

✧cristina✧ --- 17 years ago -

We do it for her. If she says no I wont put my shoes on or no about getting in the car we sit her down and put her shoes on her and carry her to the car. We show her who is in charge. I dont care if she screams from now till next christmas we are the parents and she has to listen. Also if she wont hold our hand in public she has to go in the stroller or cart. Its too dangerous for her to not listen. Now we dont boss our kids arond and generally she does what she is told but when she doesnt we make her do what she has to do. This is totally what we do, too. And with regards to holding out hand, especially in parking lots or the street, if our daughter says no and tries to pull away, I just hold her hand or arm anyway, because you're right, it's way too dangerous. She can scream and cry and pull all she wants, but you have to keep your kids safe, and it's not like I'm hurting her. If worse came to worse, I would pick her up and/or put her in the stroller/cart. Also, I tell my daughter that she doesn't say no to me, at least if it's like you're talking about (if I ask her if she wants something and she says no, that's fine). I also try not to say no a lot to her, because I know I'm reinforcing the use of no if I'm always saying it, too. 

EastCoast --- 17 years ago -

My son just turned 3 and he will say 'no', but it's very seldom and when he does, he has a reason. I get "I'm fine" a lot when I tell him to go to the bathroom. He's been potty trained for long enough to know when it's an emergency and when it's not, so I just go with it. If it's about hand-holding or running off in a store, I grab his little hand or put him in the cart "like a little baby". He usually just goes with the flow though. 

Wife, Mother amazing Women --- 17 years ago -

Thank you "Emmali's Mommy" I was begining to think i was the only parent on here. I cant believe people are like "go to time out" Wow if i did that we would spend most our day in time out and get nothing done. time out in our house is for when you do bad things. So a kid tells you "no" your the parent and they have to listen to certain things, like go to th bathroom, wear shoes and hold my hand. Its not up for debate. I would think you were reinforcing the "No" by putting them in time out. So they go to time out do they ever actually have to do what was told? 

EastCoast --- 17 years ago -

Also, when he would get REALLY mouthy - around 2 1/2- he got a little baby spoon of vinegar. We started with lemon juice, then tobasco, but he loves both of those. 

✧cristina✧ --- 17 years ago -

Thank you "Emmali's Mommy" I was begining to think i was the only parent on here. I cant believe people are like "go to time out" Wow if i did that we would spend most our day in time out and get nothing done. time out in our house is for when you do bad things. So a kid tells you "no" your the parent and they have to listen to certain things, like go to th bathroom, wear shoes and hold my hand. Its not up for debate. I would think you were reinforcing the "No" by putting them in time out. So they go to time out do they ever actually have to do what was told? We use "time out" when our daughter is throwing a fit. But our time out is to have her go to her room and go to her bed. She hates this because there is nothing to really play with in her room, and she doesn't like to be by herself. She'll go up to her room, get her frustration out (usually by just screaming as loud as she possibly can for like a minute), and then come back downstairs. I still make her do what I had originally asked her to do (usually this start because she doesn't want to pick up her toys). By throwing a tantrum or saying no, she is NOT going to get out of what I told her, as the parent, to do. We don't have to do "time out" much, though, because she knows when she's told to do something that she has to do it, period. She's learned. It's just a process, and the "no" thing is something pretty much every child goes through because they are testing you to see if you really are the parent and mean what you say (IMO). Good luck Maureen. 

Giraffe --- 17 years ago -

Thank you "Emmali's Mommy" I was begining to think i was the only parent on here. lol... 

εїзJelly_Bean --- 17 years ago -

there are alot of times when time out doesnt do anything! my 5 year old gets worse when you give him time out. he broke the screen in his room and threw stuff out the window. poured juice all over the floor, mouths off and talks back. hits his brother or the pets. so i just learned to play his game. no more tome outs. instead i get him a sitter and take his brother out on a sat to go to the zoo or whatever and he doesnt get to go. or he doesnt get snacks during the day. or watch tv. he eventually learned that life is no fun when you want to be most of the time and started to stop with the mouthing off. now his younger brother does it.... 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

I told my husband that I'm going to sell all of his toys. A Thomas play table and 3 bins full of toys. I've stopped letting him watching his shows or movies. He gets nothing that he does not NEED. And about the potty thing, lately he's been wetting himself. I know accidents happen but this is happening a lot more than it should, which is why we tell him to go potty and don't take no for an answer. 

εїзJelly_Bean --- 17 years ago -

i would make pretend that i threw his toy in the garbage 

Mrs.Primo --- 17 years ago -

Well we are spanking parents so when my oldest would tell me "no" on things like that Id lightly pop his mouth..he learned real quick you dont 1. say no to us..and 2. NEVER use that tone with us. I never hurt him when I did it it was just like putting your hand over ur mouth and going ahhhhhh..and making an Indian sound. If he continued we would bust his a@@..but only had to do that once or twice. The baby doesnt say "no" yet..and Im dreading those years again LOL 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

i would make pretend that i threw his toy in the garbage  I told him they were going in the trash. He has his bed and a bookcase with books in his room and that's it. We've even tried the spanking thing. It's just like timeout though. It does nothing for him. He still says no and then we put him in his room. He'll scream for 30 minutes then apologize and think that he's off the hook. 

Sair --- 17 years ago -

we're spanking parents too. if we tell the kids to do something & they say no, we tell them "that wasn't a question, you do what we tell you to". if they still don't do it, they get a swat on the butt and a firm guide to where they should be headed. 

Lily --- 17 years ago -

Jamie tried that once in a store and I spanked him on the butt with my hand (not hard) for it, in front of everyone. He never did it again. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground