Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

About the banning!

who's talking here?

~Caution-contents HOTT~ 1
Liz~*Celebrating Home *~ 2
EastCoast 1
Cayla 1
PeachyKeene 1
Avash1177 1
Charlie'sWife 2
moodyblues 1
Ruthie 2
*Target lady has a secret* 5
Thread Killer 1
Mrs.B 2
Jacy's Memorable Moments Photo 4
All Abouts 9
FixDaPix 3
Turkeys Mama 1
Princess B 1
Braydens Mommy 1
PPCTMistyLa Diabla 3
Oliver Clothesoff 2
FurMama 1
ATT☆Ind.31Consultant 1
Kariane 9
Lavender is Good 4
*Sarah H* 3
*~I love my sailor ~* 1
Flameless in a Handbasket 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Jacy's Memorable Moments Photo --- 17 years ago -

1,704 Marines banning breeds will lead to national pet crisis Reply Contact Rate it - 68 views - Add comment By ABBY BIRD I have recently learned that the Marine Corps has issued an order (MCO P11000.22 Ch. 6) that restricts certain breeds of dogs from base housing beginning in October. This order affects both national and international base housing. The breeds specifically named are: pit bulls and mixes, Rottweilers and mixes and wolf hybrids. Conspicuously absent are breeds such as German shepherds, Chows and Dobermans. The order is an attempt to remove “aggressive” breeds from these sites for safety reasons. The Marine Corps has an obligation to provide a safe environment to anyone living under their jurisdiction and deems these specific dogs to be risky in this enclosed environment. Prior to the deadline in October, any resident owning such a pet can be grandfathered into their current housing if and only if their pet passes certification of either Delta Society or Canine Good Citizen testing. This certification is being used as a form of temperament testing for these specific breeds. The repercussions of this order bring it to crisis status mentioned in the headline. I have received numerous phone calls from panicked owners of these specifically named breed dogs to test their dogs under the CGC format. The fallacy of the Canine Good Citizen test is that it not only tests for temperament but behavior and obedience commands as well. It is a difficult test and usually requires rigorous training for any dog regardless of breed to earn the status. Most of our own house pets could not pass without hours and weeks of work, if at all. Monday alone I performed four tests. What I found were happy, goofy dogs, well-tempered but not well behaved. They were good around children and other dogs but performed poorly on loose leash walking and focusing. The stereotypical aggressive breed was not to be seen here but unfortunately, except one, neither were they of Canine Good Citizen caliber and thus they failed the test. The test does not permit certain types of walking equipment such as pinch collars or harnesses which many owners use under normal circumstances to walk their powerful dogs. Upset owners, crying about their beloved pets and the potential consequences, left the exam devastated. The options and consequences to them and each local community are what bring this to crisis level. If their dogs do not pass the test, outright or after training, they either have to leave base housing and find off-base housing or give up their family pet. Finding affordable local housing that accepts dogs, let alone these breeds and others is difficult at best and severely limited. Many owners aren’t bothering to test and are just planning to move. If they can’t find housing, for the most part they will be turning their pets over to local rescue and shelters who in turn because of space and breed mandates of their own, will be forced into euthanasia rather than adoption. Shelters nationwide may indeed be overwhelmed as a result of this rule. Even if your dog does pass rigorous testing, the certification is for grandfathering purposes only for existing residents of on base housing. If you move to another base, your pet will no longer be welcome and you will have to live offbase. So, in about two years, there might well be another round of owners having to get rid of their dogs if they need to live on base, can’t find or afford outside housing. The inflow to shelters nationwide will just continue. While statistically these and other large breeds, if aggressive and not under owner control, could cause injury and death, an aggression test is not the same as a Canine Good Citizen test. A truly aggressive dog, regardless of breed, should certainly not be living on military bases with the close proximity of quarters. The thought of thousands of these non-aggressive dogs losing their homes or their lives when they are well tempered but not well behaved is appalling to me as a trainer and dog lover. What was equally appalling to me was that all four dogs, male and female, were not spayed or neutered. There is mention in the new orders of the advisement and recommendation to fix pets on base but no requirement. In some cases aggressivity in any breed can be directly related to whether the animal is fixed or not. It seems to me the requirement should be fixing first and training and appropriate testing second. Abby Bird is owner of Alpha Dog Training Academy and can be reached at ajbird@hargray.com The bended knee is not a tradition of our Corps." (General Alexander A. Vandergrift, USMC, to the Senate Naval Affairs Committee, 5 May 1946.)If we don’t believe in freedom of expression for people we despise, we don’t believe in it at all. "It is foolish and wrong to mourn the men who died. Rather we should thank God that such men lived." -- General George S. Patton  

Jacy's Memorable Moments Photo --- 17 years ago -

Monday alone I performed four tests. What I found were happy, goofy dogs, well-tempered but not well behaved. They were good around children and other dogs but performed poorly on loose leash walking and focusing. The stereotypical aggressive breed was not to be seen here but unfortunately, except one, neither were they of Canine Good Citizen caliber and thus they failed the test. The test does not permit certain types of walking equipment such as pinch collars or harnesses which many owners use under normal circumstances to walk their powerful dogs. Upset owners, crying about their beloved pets and the potential consequences, left the exam devastated.  

*Sarah H* --- 17 years ago -

oh shit 

Flameless in a Handbasket --- 17 years ago -

Conspicuously absent are breeds such as German shepherds, Chows and Dobermans. What does this mean; "Conspicuously absent" ? That those are NOT included in the ban? The wording seems a bit confusing. 

Princess B --- 17 years ago -

Conspicuously absent are breeds such as German shepherds, Chows and Dobermans. PHEW Thank God! I would hate to have to move because my Dobie isn't going ANYwhere without us! 

~Caution-contents HOTT~ --- 17 years ago -

Conspicuously absent are breeds such as German shepherds, Chows and Dobermans. Those breeds are known to be aggresive as well. We had a Chow when I was growing up and they are EXTREMELY aggresive towards other dogs/people. More so than any Rott I have ever known. 

*Sarah H* --- 17 years ago -

Maybe that's what housings is hoping, that all these people with dogs will move out and therefore have more housing available? Its a conspiracy :) 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

Training training training Some pet stores offer training for less then 150.. a happy dog is a well trained dog 

Oliver Clothesoff --- 17 years ago -

yeah chows are nasty. If you look up their profile. It says like they are 1 person dogs no kids yadda yadda 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

Conspicuously absent are breeds such as German shepherds, Chows and Dobermans. I have a GSD.. knowing that her breed may fall under the microscopy one day.. she is getting trained trained trained.. as for right now, she been with us for about 2 weeks.. she put her head down 75% of the time, when someone approaches her.. and she sits when a child approaches her.. also we have been about 75 % of the time successful on sitting and staying by me while in walks, even when others pass by her with dogs 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

I will be really happy when she stops barking in the back yard and digging :) 

ATT☆Ind.31Consultant --- 17 years ago -

Thank god I can keep my baby I would die if I had to live without my little girls. One german shepherd mix and the other mix with god knows LOL 

Jacy's Memorable Moments Photo --- 17 years ago -

Link 

Flameless in a Handbasket --- 17 years ago -

We had a Chow when I was growing up and they are EXTREMELY aggresive towards other dogs/people. More so than any Rott I have ever known.  What's funny is I have a Shepherd/ Chow mix, and he's a moron. I don't think he'd even figure out how to hurt anyone, and the only thing he knows how to do is "sit". lol. The worst thing he's done is eat a bee. 

Jacy's Memorable Moments Photo --- 17 years ago -

I have a blue pitbull, and he is a meat head lol! He is only 9 months old, so he isnt the smartest dog. I dont have time for proper training so I train him myself. He know his basic command but thats it. He is the most friendly dog i've ever owned! I refuse to get rid of him! If need to be we will move! 

Lavender is Good --- 17 years ago -

I will be really happy when she stops barking in the back yard and digging :) Those are usually signs of boredom. I don't know your dog or your situation, but make sure she isn't bored. :) 

Oliver Clothesoff --- 17 years ago -

get her a backpack all abouts. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

here is a good way to look at it.. If your child is in school and the teacher approaches you and say.. he is going to fail.. dont we go out and get all the help we can to make sure the child pass and succeeds .. same way.. 

Lavender is Good --- 17 years ago -

It seems to me that all dogs on base should just be required to pass a temperament test and a basic obedience test and be allowed without regard to breed. Not they test they are doing, but like the temperament test they do on MWDs they are testing to see if they are adoptable plus then basic obedience skills. This will test out both the dogs with bad temperaments and the neglectful owners which are for more dangerous than just a dog breed. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

Those are usually signs of boredom. I don't know your dog or your situation, but make sure she isn't bored. :) She is inside the house most the time.. do I think she is after those little creatures that makes holes in the yard.. and our house is located of a high traffic area.. so lots of sites for her to bark at it// VDB getting one next week.. and she will also start formal training next month( they want the family together for training ).. in the end she is a very good kid 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

It seems to me that all dogs on base should just be required to pass a temperament test and a basic obedience test and be allowed without regard to breed. I agree.. 

Cayla --- 17 years ago -

thankfully the one thing we focused so much on with our dog was walking without a leash, he listens MOST the time without his leash and will not lunge or charge at other animals or people.. thankfully though we do not fall under the category of aggressive dogs they are banning too. 

Braydens Mommy --- 17 years ago -

well my basset hound would fail for sure...she loves people and kids but she jumps and yelps in excitment when you walk in the door. she also can't walk beside you, she's always pulling and running after something. She is the best dog I have ever owned, I wouldn't change her for the world. We would move before ever giving up a pet. 

Liz~*Celebrating Home *~ --- 17 years ago -

I have a GSD.. knowing that her breed may fall under the microscopy one day.. she is getting trained trained trained.. as for right now, she been with us for about 2 weeks.. she put her head down 75% of the time, when someone approaches her.. and she sits when a child approaches her.. also we have been about 75 % of the time successful on sitting and staying by me while in walks, even when others pass by her with dogs I am glad she is doing well! She is a good dog. 

Turkeys Mama --- 17 years ago -

well my basset hound would fail for sure...she loves people and kids but she jumps and yelps in excitment when you walk in the door. she also can't walk beside you, she's always pulling and running after something. She is the best dog I have ever owned, I wouldn't change her for the world. We would move before ever giving up a pet. Haha so would my English Bulldog! He loves people, but when he knows hes going to the park watch out! He pulls us and sprints lol. Hes a nosey dog too, but the best dog I have ever owned! Most of the time he just lays around! He does get super excited when someone new comes around. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

I am glad she is doing well! She is a good dog. She sure is.. :) 

Thread Killer --- 17 years ago -

Bamcis would deffinately fail that test! He is the perfect example of a Jack Russell! Will work for treats, otherwise "eff off"! But, I love him, just wish I had him when he was a puppy, he'd be more polite. 

Liz~*Celebrating Home *~ --- 17 years ago -

My dad had a chow and he was the biggest baby! He loved kids and loved to be around people. After the dog died and a few yrs later, he got a cocker spaniel. Now that was a mean dog who didnt like kids or really anyone else. He loved my dad and me and that was it. He got rid of him bc he snapped at some of the grandkids. 

Kariane --- 17 years ago -

well my basset hound would fail for sure...she loves people and kids but she jumps and yelps in excitment when you walk in the door. my basset hound drives me NUTS. Hes sooo whiny..thats all he does is whine..alllll day long. It seems to me that all dogs on base should just be required to pass a temperament test and a basic obedience test and be allowed without regard to breed. I agree. Any breed can be bad..back home our neighbors had a border collie that kept jumping the fence and attacking whoever/whatever was in our backyard..they knew it did this but did nothing..they learned the hard way after it attacked my mom and they had to put it down, fines and a lawsuit. 

PeachyKeene --- 17 years ago -

What about chihuahuas?? Some of those can be vicious!! Why is the MC only picking on the big dogs??? This irritates me. Sorry to those who agree with it... 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground