Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: How do you feel about this?

who's talking here?

L4OT 1
Mrs Patch 1
CourtesyFlush 1
PeachyKeene 2
Sarah aka Tippy 2
*t3Rr@* 1
San Antonio Bound 1
Braydens Mommy 1
*Sarah H* 1
Mañanita 1
Grosie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: How do you feel about this?

It's a Fork, It's a Spoon, It's a.... Weapon? Do you agree that he should have been suspended? Discuss! :)

Yes, I'm a firm believer in zero tolerance Vote
 
 12.5% (4)
No, maybe in school suspension Vote
 
 37.5% (12)
No, not at all, he did nothing wrong Vote
 
 40.6% (13)
Other, please let us know how you feel! Vote
 
 9.4% (3)
PeachyKeene --- 17 years ago -

It's a Fork, It's a Spoon, It's a.... Weapon? Do you agree that he should have been suspended? Discuss! :) 

PeachyKeene --- 17 years ago -

bump to the top 

*t3Rr@* --- 17 years ago -

I could see the punishment fitting had he been older and knew better or had he tried hurting someone. I think if anything a few days ISS or suspended would have been enough, 

Braydens Mommy --- 17 years ago -

I said maybe in school suspension because I understand they can't make exceptions for some kids and not others...but I mean, COME ON! 

L4OT --- 17 years ago -

i dont think he thought of it as a weapon at all. the poor kid was just so excited about it. i doubt he was like "well i wanna bring my new fork/spoon to school but i am sure it is against the zero tolerancy policy". seriously he is a kid who wanted to use his new toy. if anything it would be the parents fault for letting him bring it to school but i dont think child or parent was wrong...serioulsy it is retarded someone would get in trouble for that. 

San Antonio Bound --- 17 years ago -

I can see why the school saw it as a weapon since it has a sharp edge that allows it to serve as a knife also, but the whole zero tolerance thing is a little over done imo. 

*Sarah H* --- 17 years ago -

other : Thats effing stupid, hes 6. 

Grosie --- 17 years ago -

Poor kid, he's only 6 and he was proud of what he learned. I definitely think they took it too far. In school suspension should be enough to satisfy their zero tolerance policy. 

Mañanita --- 17 years ago -

Clicked other, I think he should have had his utensil taken away. That's it. But Zero Tolerance was created by politicians to appease scared parents. When people who have no idea how schools work make the rules you get A LOT of stupid rules. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

Zero Tolerance is for kids is the devil. It's dumb. We have a judicial system for adults that commit CRIMES... but there's no individual judgment and punishment levels for CHILDREN? Take it away. Send home a note to his parents. Maybe even make a point of putting out a news letter to let everyone know to be more careful of what their kids bring to school. But 45 days for a 6 year old? What? 

Mrs Patch --- 17 years ago -

Clicked other, I think he should have had his utensil taken away. That's it. I agree with this because it can be used as a knife. His parents could have easily been called in to pick it up at the end of the day. Yes, it's an inconvenience, but it is outside the barriers of their guidelines. I bet they didn't even think of it as a knife either so that's why they let him take it to school. Poor kid. 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 17 years ago -

More proof that Zero tolerance is a bad idea: "The "zero tolerance" policy at some school and in some states, reaches levels of complete incompetence when a 6 years gets written up as a sexual offender for copying what another kid did and playfully smacking little Katherine DeLeon on the bottom twice. That is right, a six year old is being labeled a sex offender for smacking a girl on the bottom in a playful manner after seeing another child do the same. For doing this, this child, Randy Castro, had the police called on him by Potomac View Elementary School, then they wrote him up for "Sexual Touching Against Student, Offensive", in their report. The school website says it is located in Virginia but the news reports call it a Maryland school and their zero tolerance policy has managed to substitute the words of a policy from the actual thought processes of those in charge. (Video news report on this incident at that link) An assistant director of the National Association of School Psychologists, Ted Feinberg, says he is "stunned" by the school's reaction to a child of six that has no concept of what those behaviors mean and he states, "I believe they do not have the capacity for awareness of sexual motivation … it seems like a gross mislabeling of the behavior and an overreaction." Instead of telling the child that those actions and behavior is unacceptable, the school, instead, labels this six year old a sexual harasser and sexual offender. Randy's mother, Claudia Castro, says, "When I hear 'mommy they called police because I am a bad boy,' that is the message that you're giving to a 6-year-old?" Where is the common sense here? Sure, it is appropriate to march the child into the principal's office and tell him in no uncertain terms that he cannot touch another child in that manner, so that later in life he doesn't continue thinking it is just a playful thing. Calling the police and putting a report in his permanent school record with an"Incident Code(s) for this perpetrator" of "SX2" or "Sexual Touching Against Student, Offensive, is beyond the realm of comprehension in my mind. Where is the line drawn between zero tolerance and common sense? When are school officials going to start using judgment instead of some generic general rule to decide a case on an individual basis? Mark Steyn writes an opinion for the Orange County Register where he spotlights the fact that this isn't the first time that an overreaction has been perpetrated in the name of zero tolerance. Randy Castro was not apprehended until he was 6, so who knows how long his reign of sexual terror lasted? Sixteen months ago, a school official in Texas accused a 4-year-old of sexual harassment after the boy was observed pressing his face into the breasts of a teacher's aide when he hugged her before boarding the school bus. Fortunately, the school took decisive action and suspended the sick freak. By the way, is that the first recorded use in the history of the English language of the phrase "accused a 4-year-old of sexual harassment"? Well, it won't be the last: In the state of Maryland last year, 16 kindergartners were suspended for sexual harassment, as were three preschoolers. Where does the line get drawn? When do school officials start being required to use their brains? In what alternate reality do we live in where a six year old or a four year old are accused of being a sexual offender, simply because they are too young to understand their natural inclination to play and touch are wrong? The zero tolerance policy was designed to protect children from drugs, weapons and sexual violence, not to label a six year old, or a four year old, as a sexual offender. " 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

He shouldnt have been suspended. He's freakin 6 for crying out loud. I guess it also depends on the kid though too. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground