Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: What is worse...a 15-Month old on time out or a 3yr old still on a bottle?

who's talking here?

ALEM 3
☆Blessed Mommy☆ 1
IrishTwinsx2plus1 1
CaliJuicy 7
Bo§§ Lady 4
All Abouts 1
*Mommy2-2Princesses* 2
Flameless in a Handbasket 1
Cupcakes♥Champagne 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: What is worse...a 15-Month old on time out or a 3yr old still on a bottle?

My mom & I just went at it. She tells me I'm a bad parent because I put my son on time out. Only when he throws a fit, or when he decides it's ok to hit his head against the wall. I don't think I'm a bad parent for that...Correct me if i'm wrong though..HAHA The most I put him on time out is 10-15 secs. So I got mad and told her I don't tell her she is a bad mom for still giving my 3yr old sister a bottle. Although I think it's totally wrong she knows my views on that! My son has been on his sippy cup since he was 6-months old! Anyways I told her everyone has different parenting skills, I just started the whole time out thing about a week ago. It works for us, he's been throwing less tantrums & hitting his head less. It's a miracle in our house! He was getting bad, it was going on for several weeks now, so now that we have time out he know he shouldn't hit his head when he's upset or he will get time out. So am I wrong for my discipline? Am I a bad parent? Seriously she is hella pist, she hung up on me! HAHA I can't believe it!

You're Wrong!(please do explain lol) Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
You're in everyright to put him on time out if you please! Vote
 
 96.6% (28)
You're both wrong!(please do explain) Vote
 
 3.4% (1)
CaliJuicy --- 17 years ago -

My mom & I just went at it. She tells me I'm a bad parent because I put my son on time out. Only when he throws a fit, or when he decides it's ok to hit his head against the wall. I don't think I'm a bad parent for that...Correct me if i'm wrong though..HAHA The most I put him on time out is 10-15 secs. So I got mad and told her I don't tell her she is a bad mom for still giving my 3yr old sister a bottle. Although I think it's totally wrong she knows my views on that! My son has been on his sippy cup since he was 6-months old! Anyways I told her everyone has different parenting skills, I just started the whole time out thing about a week ago. It works for us, he's been throwing less tantrums & hitting his head less. It's a miracle in our house! He was getting bad, it was going on for several weeks now, so now that we have time out he know he shouldn't hit his head when he's upset or he will get time out. So am I wrong for my discipline? Am I a bad parent? Seriously she is hella pist, she hung up on me! HAHA I can't believe it! 

CaliJuicy --- 17 years ago -

Oh & may I add she got more upset when I told her I found this cute plush toy with a time out "timer". LOL I seen it at the thrift store on base today & had to have it! It's the cutest thing ever! LOL 

Cupcakes♥Champagne --- 17 years ago -

Cali, get his vision checked. The head butting the wall or the floor is usually a sign of a vision problem 

ALEM --- 17 years ago -

Ash goes in timeout for hitting, and turning on and off the cdplayer/surround sound. Shes there for a minute. I wouldn't put her in ther for banging her head against the wal though(shes learning) 

*Mommy2-2Princesses* --- 17 years ago -

My mom told me for younger kids a minute per year they are old.. Like my daughter is almost 2 so she sits in time out on the bottom of the stairs for almost 2 minutes.. Its in a parenting book i read also 

CaliJuicy --- 17 years ago -

Cali, get his vision checked. The head butting the wall or the floor is usually a sign of a vision problem Oh he sees good! He just does it when he is upset. He will go to the wall and hit his forehead!Or smack his head with his hands. I don't know were he got that from. I don't hit him, and I just started time out. Time out works wonder. He's only been on time out 3 or 4 times....He's been good ever since! 

Flameless in a Handbasket --- 17 years ago -

ok, call me stupid but if he's acting up isn't a time out the best way? I mean what's she want you to do beat him instead? 

Bo§§ Lady --- 17 years ago -

If my son understood the concept of timeout I'd put him in it. He's 15 and a half months and is now starting to throw tantrums. I don't think my son gets what timeout is yet, but you bet when he does start to figure that out he'll be getting sent there. For now I don't pay attention to the Boo Hooing and usually it stops until the next time he throws a fit. 

Bo§§ Lady --- 17 years ago -

My mom told me for younger kids a minute per year they are old That's what I've heard too. 

ALEM --- 17 years ago -

He's 15 and a half months and is now starting to throw tantrums. I started ash earlier than that i think. It just takes consistancy and will power lol 

CaliJuicy --- 17 years ago -

I wouldn't put her in ther for banging her head against the wal though(shes learning) He is a boy :) My mom told me for younger kids a minute per year they are old.. Like my daughter is almost 2 so she sits in time out on the bottom of the stairs for almost 2 minutes.. Its in a parenting book i read also I've read that somewere. A min per year, but 10-15 secs does the trick, plus I feel bad lol 

ALEM --- 17 years ago -

My mom told me for younger kids a minute per year they are old That's what I've heard too. thats what i do. 

IrishTwinsx2plus1 --- 17 years ago -

I start time-outs with mine around 15-18 months or so, depending on the child. Before that, it's just constant (and exhausting LOL) re-direction. 

Bo§§ Lady --- 17 years ago -

it's just constant (and exhausting LOL) re-direction. Yep. 

CaliJuicy --- 17 years ago -

ok, call me stupid but if he's acting up isn't a time out the best way? I mean what's she want you to do beat him instead? No she just wants me to love him! I do love him!DUH! He is my son!LOL If my son understood the concept of timeout I'd put him in it. He's 15 and a half months and is now starting to throw tantrums. T don't think my son gets what timeout is yet, but you bet when he does start to figure that out he'll be getting sent there. For now I don't pay attention to the Boo Hooing and usually it stops until the next time he throws a fit. My son is 15-months and half as well. He knows the concept of time out now. When he throws a fit I just tell him time out and he stops!WAAALA 

*Mommy2-2Princesses* --- 17 years ago -

I've read that somewere. A min per year, but 10-15 secs does the trick, plus I feel bad lol Yah usually after about 30 seconds my daughter is saying sorry sorry sorry mommy sorry 

☆Blessed Mommy☆ --- 17 years ago -

Yep 1 minute per year. My daughter sits in between my legs. And she did the head hitting thing too, still does occasionally, but I just ignore it. She does it to get my attention while in time out. Since I won't give her attention while she is in time out. If I do she screams the whole minute. 

CaliJuicy --- 17 years ago -

Yah usually after about 30 seconds my daughter is saying sorry sorry sorry mommy sorry After those dreadfull 10 secs he will do his fake cry, then I take him off lol. 

CaliJuicy --- 17 years ago -

Yep 1 minute per year. My daughter sits in between my legs. And she did the head hitting thing too, still does occasionally, but I just ignore it. She does it to get my attention while in time out. Since I won't give her attention while she is in time out. If I do she screams the whole minute. Very true! When he knows he is going to time out he stiffs his whole body straight lol. So I'm not able to sit him down. He does hit his head back against the wall and says OUCH, but I ignore him and he stops. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

re-direction. My approach. As for the bottle.. I believe every parent needs to do what works for them.. 3 yrs old drinking out the bottle for me is a bit much, however some parents think I am wrong because I dont take the bottle way before 2. That is why I say you have to do what works for your family. I could not imagine any of my kids not being potty trained by 2, but my youngest soon is turning 2 in December and I highly doubt he will be potty trained ( it wont pass 2 1/2 do). In the end of the day we all wish the same.. happy kids, well round adults 

Bo§§ Lady --- 17 years ago -

When he throws a fit I just tell him time out and he stops!WAAALA Nope, not my little guy or at least he doesn't seem like he knows just yet. When I fuss I at him for doing something he wasn't supposed to do he cries and then walks over to me to hug... almost seems like he's apologizing. Who knows at this point? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground