My 3 year old is startig to back talk and it's driving me crazy. I don't want to do time-outs because I don't think that back-talking is time-out worthy. I try to reserve time-outs for melt-downs, being repeatedly unkind, and disobeying deliberately.
He will say things like, "What did I tell you about saying 'no' to me?" When I ask what he wants for lunch/dinner he always says he's not hungry yet, so I wait a bit and ask again. "What did I tell you about food?? I'M NOT HUNGRY"
It's seriously wearing me down. He got it from me. I will tell him not to do/say something. Then, when he does whatever, I say "What did I tell you about that?" to make sure that he 1) understands what I said to him and 2) knows that I saw/heard what he just did. I started doing that because he's been SUPER sensitive about misbehaving and I don't want to be constantly correct him. I want him to start correcting himself by doing what I say without having to be reminded everyday on little teeny stuff....which is what I use he "what did I tell you" line for.
My three year old just started that. I tried the "You don't talk to me like that" approach but now he's started saying that too. I wonder how much boarding school is...lol
Its the age. My daughter started giving me back the stern "really?? " Look that I give her when she's being defiant. 2 or three trips to her room. For an hour at a time and she's knocked it off. She yells at her brother " I told you, stop it now!! " But only when he's doing something she knows is bad. She mimicks me . But for the most part, the time out discipline has helped and she's knocked it off lol
I dont have any kids so I dont know if this will work or not but if they are mimiking you, maybe tell them how they should talk to you. LIke with the food if he says that again give him a stern look and say "Thats not how you talk to mommy. You can just tell me no thank you" Maybe the way they are talking is the only thing they have learned about how to react to situations.
Im in the same boat as well. My son is 3 and a half and he will repeat things I have said to him. I have said, "I told you not to do...." and he will say that to me. I switch up different phrases now and also let him know that he isnt suppose to say that, only mommy and daddy.
I'm right there with ya! My lil girl is driving me nutz with all the back talking. I send her to her room and remove both baskets of toys. It helps sometimes, but she started spitting on us too now.
Instead of getting mad at them try this. When they talk back to you and start repeating things to you that you dont want them saying, sit them down and look in their eyes and just talk to them calmly but sternly. Tell them I know you hear mommy saying so and so but that is for grown ups to say and not for children. You need to listen or you will ....and give them a consequence like go to your room or get a toy taken away. It works for my daughter. Its the age and it takes time and patience. There is always a new "stage" at another age. lol does it ever end?
This may sound mean, but it worked VERY quickly and effectively. When my boys started yelling at me, talking back and/or biting, spitting...I had them stick out their tongue and I pinched it. After a few times of them pressing me to see if I would stick to it, they stopped...really. If they started throwing a fit in the store over not getting something they wanted, I'd just ask them very quietly if they didn't stop, I could always pinch their tongue for them...instant stopping of the fit. Now at age 7 and 8, I can honestly say my kids do NOT at all talk back to me. They know it is also the consequence of saying a bad word, calling each other names, lying...so very little of that happens at our home.
Haha the vinegar thing doesnt work out my daughter. we did it to try to keep her from putting things in her mouth. everything started going into her mouth again and wouldnt listen when we told her no..so we tried vinegar and my sicko liked it! buuut then smack on the mouth should do the trick for spitting. kloe went through a screaming at you phase when she was mad and that a few times knocked it out.
When my first boys were doing that, i would put them in their room for an hour, then they could only sit and read or go to bed for the rest of the day. If they were in public, me and my hubby would pinch their ears, their nose, or their tongue. I was never spit on, just talking back and maybe some kicking...
But these younger monsters are spitting. And like Fix I pinch their tongue. Not hard, but hard enough to make them stop.
Hubby would also do vinegar(sp), or soap, nasty smelling soap.
But these younger monsters are spitting. And like Fix I pinch their tongue. Not hard, but hard enough to make them stop.
The reason I take spitting so seriously is because Parents can SUE you for your child spitting on their child for "assault"...that is CRAZY!!!It leaves no marks but the mark on their memory that getting their tongue pinched SUCKS! Just hard enough to wear they start to do a little whiney scream and what my dad called "2 step"...I don't smack my kids on the mouth because that can go wrong in so many ways...an accidental fat lip, cut lip, cut my hand on their teeth, miss the mouth and get the side of their face...and with people being CPS crazy, not gonna chance it.
Putting them in their rooms for an hour? When they are 3? They won't remember why they are in there. I ignore the sassing and back-talking. No reaction, no reward. They eventually get the idea. They can be suck little jerks when they're 3. LOL
They won't remember why they are in there. I ignore the sassing and back-talking.
I think he'd lose the point after an hour, honestly. I try ignoring him, but sometimes it REALLY gets under my skin.
Hot sauce will work for any child. The trick is to rub it on the inside of their lips, not put it on their tongue.
The hot sauce thing seems a little harsh for my personal situation. Yes, he is talking back, but he's repeating exactly what I say to him. I have told him only grown-ups speak that way and explained that children who do are disrespectful. He's grasping that it's wrong, but I think he just really doesnt care. :-( What a little punk! I might try the tongue thing to see if he gets it.
ok, this is going to sound dumb... but how exactly do you pinch someone's tongue??
you wipe if off, hold it between your thumb and pointy finger and pinch...if it's wet, it will just slip out.
I don't do the hot sauce only because my mom did it with me to make me quit chewing my nails and 1) it didn't work and 2) it always made my tummy hurt...I don't use soap because that can cause diarrhea and then it backfires on me, lol
i didn't read all the posts, but ECB, maybe you could try ignoring what he said or since he likes to mimic you, maybe you should try changing the way you talk to him? I'm definitely no expert and have no idea if that will work, but it's worth a try if nothing else is working. Good luck!!
maybe you should try changing the way you talk to him?
I try. Honest. I try to really be careful how I say things to him because he's super sensitive about disappointing me or making me mad. But what I use as a reminder for him to realize things and correct himself to avoid punishment has become a snotty come back to nearly anything I ask him. So, I meant well in the beginning, but... gah! If only there was an instruction manual.
Today, I tried to ignore it when he talked back. The only time it really affected him was at lunch when he had to eat peas instead of choosing a veggie. I told him he wouldn't help me choose so I chose for him and if he didnt eat it, nothing but water until dinner. He ate it, but he pouted the whole time with his little lip out. :(
So, I meant well in the beginning, but... gah! If only there was an instruction manual.
LOL...We only wish!!
Today, I tried to ignore it when he talked back. The only time it really affected him was at lunch when he had to eat peas instead of choosing a veggie. I told him he wouldn't help me choose so I chose for him and if he didnt eat it, nothing but water until dinner. He ate it, but he pouted the whole time with his little lip out. :(
AWWW....did he at least not back talk at any other questions you had to ask him? Like did you ask him what he wanted for dinner or anything and did he answer with a smart comment or he actually answered?