Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Argument with my husband am I wrong?

who's talking here?

O G docswife 3
JMudsy 1
meandhim+3 3
Mommeee Drest 7
Princess B 1
Regina George 1
listencarefully 1
Canineagility 3
El Doosho 2
Dots 5
MandaBabyy 4
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

meandhim+3 --- 16 years ago -

Ok so this year these wonderful people gave us a chritsmas tree. It was a fake white tree decorated in red white and blue ornaments. It was a beatiful tree ( at least I think so)and they spent a lot of time to make us this tree. Now my husband wanted to put up another tree in a diffrent room because he wanted a real tree in the house. But I told him that we should just admire and appreciate this other tree that people cared enough to give us. Now that christmas is over and he took the tree down yesterday. then he yells at me and is pissed because "I am pushing his traditions to the side and ignoring how he feels" and he informed me that when he is deployed next year I have to have a real christmas tree and it has to be at least as tall as me. (like I didnt have enough to worry about but now I have to make sure christmas is up to his standards when hes not even here)Am I wrong here should I have let him put up another tree instead of enjoying and being thankful for the one that was given to us? 

JMudsy --- 16 years ago -

Am I wrong here should I have let him put up another tree instead of enjoying and being thankful for the one that was given to us? You did the right thing. Tell him to quit being greedy and you'll do Christmas however you please when he's not there. My husband wanted a real tree this year too. However, I know damn well I would be the one watering it and picking up pine needles off the floor. Thanks, but I'll pass. 

Dots --- 16 years ago -

I think it is very important to give and take in a marriage. If your husband feels so strongly about continuing traditions for his children then why not? I understand appreciating something someone gave to you and the time and effort put into it, so why not have both? I grew up with a real tree and it wouldn't feel like Christmas any other way, the smell of a real tree in our home feels like Christmas to me. My husband's tradition is the story of the birth of Chirst should be read every Christmas Eve, I did it when he wasn't here because it is his tradition. I don't see what the big deal in accomadating both parties is. 

O G docswife --- 16 years ago -

daddy i want a goose who lays golden eggs and i want it now!!!!!! sorry this quote came to me as i was reading your post. it sounds like he is a little kid throwing a fit i am sorry, i know that it is not very nice to say. but i think not having a real tree when he is gone is not the end of the world. i would tell my husband he was crazy. i can see if he really wants a real one while he is here ok. but to dictate what HAS to be done when he is gone , no. 

listencarefully --- 16 years ago -

umm my darlin would never make me do a darn thing. we would talk about it first then come to a compromise. your husband sounds like he needs a time out 

Canineagility --- 16 years ago -

I think it is very important to give and take in a marriage. If your husband feels so strongly about continuing traditions for his children then why not? I agree with you. My husband loves real trees, the only reason he is ok with not ever having one, is i am allergic to them. I think it made him said to not have one this year and even sadder because we didn't decorate at all because we had just moved and were unpacking still. if we had a big enough place i would tell him to get a small real tree because that's part of his christmas tradition. Mine is walking about Naples (in Long beach) looking at the lights every Christmas so he did that with me this year. 

O G docswife --- 16 years ago -

oh god and you are allergic to them and he till insists on you getting one while he is gone?!? no he needs to stop sorry. fine how about you get a real one that is potted and put it outside for decoration. then he would have his tree, and you would not have to suffer. was this your first christmas together, or does he do this to you every year? 

Princess B --- 16 years ago -

You should have had two trees, we had a real one and a fake one too. But that was me compromising haha. 

Canineagility --- 16 years ago -

oh god and you are allergic to them and he till insists on you getting one while he is gone?!? no he needs to stop sorry. fine how about you get a real one that is potted and put it outside for decoration. then he would have his tree, and you would not have to suffer. was this your first christmas together, or does he do this to you every year? i think your reading the wrong post. my husband isn't making me do anything well he is gone and i'm the one allergic to real Christmas trees. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

meand...ask him to think about how the other people would feel. Ask how HE would feel in the same situation. He goes out of his way to help a family, spending all that time and money to help them have a great Christmas, and he comes to find out that this family has his tree up, but they went ahead and put up another tree also. Wouldn't he feel a little bit slighted? Also ask him, deos the true meaning of Christmas for him entail a Christmas tree only? Is that the only symbol that he equates with Christmas? Maybe this stems from something happening in childhood? Maybe his father didn't allow real trees? Or any number of things. My husband and I try so hard not to get mad during this time or throw unnecessary fits. It is such a joyous time that fighting over a Christmas tree seems wrong. I should add, that I am on your side with this problem. I don't understand where your husband is coming from. And if he's gonna be gone well........ 

O G docswife --- 16 years ago -

oh sorry amanda i did read it wrong!! but i agree with toni, is the tree really that big of a deal? 

Canineagility --- 16 years ago -

i know to my husband it is. he isn't really a religious guy. his family also went out together and cut the tree themselves. his dad and him didn't do really anything together when he was younger besides decorator for Christmas. So the tree remains him of the few times spent with his dad well growing up. 

MandaBabyy --- 16 years ago -

He goes out of his way to help a family, spending all that time and money to help them have a great Christmas, and he comes to find out that this family has his tree up, but they went ahead and put up another tree also. Why would they care? It's not their house.. A lot of people do two trees, in two different rooms! 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

I would care Manda.... I would feel as if the family did not like the tree I gave them. Thats just me. 

MandaBabyy --- 16 years ago -

I would care Manda.... I would feel as if the family did not like the tree I gave them. Thats just me. I think it would depend on what room the tree I made was in. That might bother me, you're right. 

Dots --- 16 years ago -

I dunno, maybe he is throwing a fit maybe he's not....MAYBE he's trying to be a "part" of Christmas in the house when he wont be there. MAYBE he's trying to start traditions for his children. IMO If my husband felt so strongly about something I would do the best I could to make it happen. If it's not hurting me or anyone else and it makes him happy what's the harm in having two trees? I mean really? If something as small as a real tree is starting a huge fight I think other aspects need to be examend. When beginning a marriage and blending traditions there needs to be some give and take. It sounds to me like neither of you are willing to do that. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

think it would depend on what room the tree I made was in ya thats a good point....if the tree I decorated was relegated to the back bedroom and they put up a real tree all decorated nicely in the front living room it would hurt. But if it was vice-versa, then maybe I wouldn't care so much, cause mine is in front lmao. 

Dots --- 16 years ago -

would care Manda.... I would feel as if the family did not like the tree I gave them. Thats just me. Then you'd be taking things to personally and not realizing that every family has their own set of traditions and how they celebrate Christmas. It's not for you to dictate what kind of tree they have and where. If they are displaying your tree and not dumping it obviously the like and appreciate it. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

Then you'd be taking things to personally and not realizing that every family has their own set of traditions and how they celebrate Christmas. It's not for you to dictate what kind of tree they have and where. If they are displaying your tree and not dumping it obviously the like and appreciate it. Think what you like Dots... thats how I would feel if I gave something to a family that I spend time and money on. Would I go all crazy and say something? NO...but I would be hurt. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

oops.... my comment looks like I quoted... but thats me talking lol. 

Dots --- 16 years ago -

Think what you like Dots... thats how I would feel if I gave something to a family that I spend time and money on. Would I go all crazy and say something? NO...but I would be hurt. Hmmmm, you've never gotten a gift you didn't like that you didn't use or what not....wouldn't the other people be hurt? Put yourself in their shoes. LOL didn't you say something to that effect earlier? You would have to say you absolutely loved enjoyed and showed off every gift you every got. I think appreciation for something and what your families traditions are are completely seperate things. Because my family uses a real tree doesn't mean I wouldn't appreciate the gift of a fake tree any less, I would just use it in a different spot. It's not that big of a deal. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

A decked out Christmas tree and a gift of say a scarf are two different things IMO. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Maybe he needs to get over it and quit being selfish. If you have kids, it should be about the kids. End of story. He's an adult and needs to act like one. If he throws a tantrum, so be it. 

MandaBabyy --- 16 years ago -

Maybe he needs to get over it and quit being selfish. If you have kids, it should be about the kids. End of story. He's an adult and needs to act like one. If he throws a tantrum, so be it. I disagree.. If he wants a tree, he wants a tree. They can have both to satisfy both parties. For some people Christmas traditions are VERY important. 

Regina George --- 16 years ago -

Agree..should have just had both. I think its dumb to argue over a tree personally. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

I disagree.. If he wants a tree, he wants a tree. They can have both to satisfy both parties. For some people Christmas traditions are VERY important. Unless the traditions involve church or jesus christ, they are for our own pleasure. Hence, being selfish. If his argument was based on his religious beliefs, I would agree entirely and say that it was for the true meaning of chritsmas. Other than that, it's for our own selfish reasons. 

MandaBabyy --- 16 years ago -

Unless the traditions involve church or jesus christ, they are for our own pleasure. Hence, being selfish. If his argument was based on his religious beliefs, I would agree entirely and say that it was for the true meaning of chritsmas. Other than that, it's for our own selfish reasons. In that case, why have a tree at all?? 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 16 years ago -

OK, your husbands wishes and your wishes are NOT mutually exclusive. It sounds to me like he wants his traditions to matter to, even while he is gone. I hate the Huskers ornaments that his parents sent us for Christmas but they went on the tree even though he wasnt here. If he wants you to have a real tree next year get a very small one, and send him a picture of it, that will probubly boost his spirits a little bit. I know my husband wanted pictures of "our" first Christmas deocartions. It just seems silly on both sides to fight over something like this. But thats just my opinion. 

Dots --- 16 years ago -

A decked out Christmas tree and a gift of say a scarf are two different things IMO. why? someone else's thoughts, money etc went into the scarf too. 

meandhim+3 --- 16 years ago -

I didnt do a second tree because I was trying to think of it from the other peoples point of view if i did all that I too would feel like it was a slap in the face if they put up another tree. And every other tradition in our house is my husbands. we open up pjs on christmas eve we have snack food on christmas eve we give the kids black rocks, we use special wrapping paper from santa, i make devil eggs on thanks giving, we will do snacks on new years and give the kids cider, even me staying home until the kida are in school is his tradition so i felt like just one tradition for a year was ok 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
pendleton
pu
rant

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground