Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Cry-it-Out Method

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
PeachyKeene 2
Avash1177 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 1
alfulkerson 1
Charlie'sWife 1
StephyTX 2
VivaLaDoll 2
Toodles 1
Mommeee Drest 1
Meranda 1
ChestyMcBreasty 3
ALS MommaKitty 1
ღHollyDeeღ 1
Kariane 1
3lilmunchkins 1
Pamper your inner Chef 3
Spork Fight 3
Pink Taco 1
LakerGirl 2
Empirestate 1
Mommy of 1 Angel 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Cry-it-Out Method

My daughter is 4mo, and she sleeps with my husband and usually takes naps on me while nursing or sometimes she will sleep in her swing. We have a crib for her - but she refuses to sleep in it. Did any mothers here do the cry-it-out method? Did it work? Or did you try something else??

Cry-it-out Vote
 
 81.5% (44)
Other Vote
 
 18.5% (10)
Mommy of 1 Angel --- 16 years ago -

My daughter is 4mo, and she sleeps with my husband and usually takes naps on me while nursing or sometimes she will sleep in her swing. We have a crib for her - but she refuses to sleep in it. Did any mothers here do the cry-it-out method? Did it work? Or did you try something else?? 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

I'm not opposed to the cry-it-out method, but 4 months seems maybe just a little bit young for it. I'm not really sure though because my son has always been a good sleeper. (I know I'm lucky!) I'm sure someone here will have some advice for you. 

alfulkerson --- 16 years ago -

With her being 4 months let her cry it out for a little while. But check in on her every once in a while. 

Mommy of 1 Angel --- 16 years ago -

I was just wondering - I would like her in her crib by 6mo - sorry, I forgot to put that! 

ChestyMcBreasty --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure someone here will have some advice for you. just dont take "the spanking advice PLEASE!!!" YES I went there!!=) 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

just dont take "the spanking advice PLEASE!!!" YES I went there!!=) I've been purposely avoiding opening that thread because I have a feeling it will pi$$ me off. lol 

Mommy of 1 Angel --- 16 years ago -

just dont take "the spanking advice PLEASE!!!" YES I went there!!=) I will never hit my child in any way, shape or form. My three younger brothers and I were never spanked for any reason - and we all turned out okay, I would like to think. 

Pink Taco --- 16 years ago -

just dont take "the spanking advice PLEASE!!!" YES I went there!!=) Lol.. yeah that's for YOU to decide when its time... Anyway, they just showed that on Dr. Phil not too long ago, and said that you can't spoil a baby 6 months or younger... so not letting her cry it out is fine... but after 6 months she needs to get use to being in her crib... 

StephyTX --- 16 years ago -

Call me the mean mommy but I always let my kiddos cry it out although I check in on them every few minutes they got the point that they were not getting picked up. And I know im going to probably get sh!t for this but its my opinion, to me the only reason a baby gets that way is if you spoil them too much. Again only my opinion but if you hold a baby constantly and let them slept on you or always with you they will get spoiled and not want anything else. This has worked for some but not all. So im not saying its a bad thing but it didnt work for us to have a baby in the room for us because then we would have no adult time. lol 

Empirestate --- 16 years ago -

I've been purposely avoiding opening that thread because I have a feeling it will pi$$ me off. I haven't opened it either 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

Double post 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

Try putting a shirt you wore that day with her in the crib... Also if she cries more than 10 min pick her up and calm her down and try it again.... Consistansy is the key. Don't slip up after you do the crib because then you'll have to go through the whole process again... 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 16 years ago -

Consisity is the key quite true... 

VivaLaDoll --- 16 years ago -

I never let any of my kids cry it out or anything like that. I always put my babies to sleep first and then just put them in bed. All of my boys slept through the night before they were 3mths old so I was lucky. I co-slept with each of them till they were about 6-8wks old then they slept in their cribs. Landon is the only one who still ends up with us, but that is my Husband's issue more then mine at this point. My Husband spoils him rotten.. 

ChestyMcBreasty --- 16 years ago -

I've been purposely avoiding opening that thread because I have a feeling it will pi$$ me off. lol Its your choice!=) 

VivaLaDoll --- 16 years ago -

Try putting a shirt you wore that day with her in the crib... Also if she cries more than 10 min pick her up and calm her down and try it again.... Consistansy is the key. Don't slip up after you do the crib because then you'll have to go through the whole process again... Good idea.. 

ChestyMcBreasty --- 16 years ago -

Try putting a shirt you wore that day with her in the crib... Also if she cries more than 10 min pick her up and calm her down and try it again.... Consistansy is the key. Don't slip up after you do the crib because then you'll have to go through the whole process again... Good idea.. ditto! 

Mommy of 1 Angel --- 16 years ago -

Thank you to everyone who has replied so far - I am pretty neurotic about googling things, but I figured I would ask mothers instead of reading doctors/specialists opinions. 

ღHollyDeeღ --- 16 years ago -

Do what you as a mother feel is best. Try a few things and see which works the best for your baby. 

Toodles --- 16 years ago -

My son does the Cry it out method, well did now he understands that he is in there to nap or go to sleep, so he does not cry any more he will babble for a bit sometimes or just goes to sleep right away, he is 18 months now we started when he was 5-6 months old. 

Avash1177 --- 16 years ago -

I did and still do cry it out. I check every 10-15 minutes to make sure they are ok but ultimately they need to learn that crying will not make me come to them ALL the time. And as a mommy you can tell the difference between a hurt cry and a fussy tired cry. Just do what your gut tells you to do. She should be in her own crib by now though IMO. Both of mine were in their own cribs as soon as they could hold their heads up and were too big for the bassinet:) I also KNOW that they ahve to learn to self sooth. The earlier the better. It is my personal Opinion that the more you hold your baby and coddle them the clingier theyw ill be. My second baby I held her ALOT because she was colicky and holding her was the only way to make her stop crying and keep my sanity. My first was not. She was content with playing by herslef or sitting in her swing or bumbo. Now at 2.5 and 13 months my 2 year old is still VERY independant and my 13 month old is VERY clingy. She SCREAMS if I even leave the room and she cant see me! 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

luckily i started letting them sleep in their bassinet at 3 months and only had a few issues with #2. I went by the rule of 5 mins, I gave her crying of 5 minutes if she didn't stop I would get her but after about 3 weeks she was perfectly fine. 

3lilmunchkins --- 16 years ago -

If your nursing, I let my sleep with me (I got more sleep that way) plus its good for the baby! 4 months old is a little young personally to me, If you want to try the cry out I would wait til 6 months or longer depending how long you will be nursing exclusively! 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

I waited til 8 months my self because I was nursing, but toeach their own... The first night (or 2) you will have a hard time sleeping but it will get better :) 

Mommy of 1 Angel --- 16 years ago -

I am nursing, which is why my husband and I decided to let her sleep with us. I do not plan on moving her to her crib until 6mo give or take - I just wanted to see what other mothers did to get them to sleep on their own. 

ALEM --- 16 years ago -

once ash turned 1 i let her really cry it out. but she was put in her crib at 2 months (i needed my space/sleep) without hearing her every move/wimper in her sleep. there were many nights though were i slept on the couch and she was in her swing or bassinet in the pack in play that vibrated. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

The only one of my three that "cried it out" was the middle one, she was colicky like you wouldn't believe. Nothing seemed to work for her except being as close to me as possible. I just don't believe in the crying out method. I also think is ludicrous to think a 4 month old would be "spoiled" by being picked up and coddled. At 4 months old, they want the closeness (smell) and your heartbeat/voice for security, no other reason. 

StephyTX --- 16 years ago -

I also think is ludicrous to think a 4 month old would be "spoiled" by being picked up and coddled. At 4 months old, they want the closeness (smell) and your heartbeat/voice for security, no other reason. If this is to me I understand what your saying. I ddint mean it like spoiled in that way. I mean like if you never put your child down and they are constantly in your arms which they shouldnt be 24/7 then they will want that when they are older as well. I held my kids dont get me wrong and I loved it. I just also had other things to do like keeping my house together and in that time baby was sleeping on their own and in their crib or on belly or something of the sort. they always slept in their crib from the day they were brought home from the hospital 

Charlie'sWife --- 16 years ago -

Now at 2.5 and 13 months my 2 year old is still VERY independant and my 13 month old is VERY clingy. She SCREAMS if I even leave the room and she cant see me! That could also be the stage they are at. In the long run your youngest may turn out to be more independant than the other. My daughter was super clingy at that age (12-18 months), but grew out of it and is now the most outgoing 3 y.o. I think that there are better ways to go about it than letting them CIO. I would hold/nurse until she was almost asleep, take away the food, burp and then rock for a few minutes before laying her down. She was almost asleep, but not completely, then I'd pat her back and sing for about 1 min and leave the room. There is a book called the no cry sleep soultion that I read and loved. 

Kariane --- 16 years ago -

The twins will be 4months old in a week. I haven't had to experience the cry-it out thing yet. They act fussy and tired and I just lay em in their cribs turn the mobile on and shut the door. They've never been in our bedroom either. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground