Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Do you think its wrong to have a baby shower for a second baby?

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
L4OT 1
JMR 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 5
Charlie'sWife 3
Mary Swanson 3
KayCee 1
Toodles 1
All Abouts 2
Mrs. Tiki 1
*JuDgE*TJ* 2
Mason's Mom 2
*Mommy2-2Princesses* 7
Giggle Butt 6
the koz's 2
DoRkYbRaTt 1
::♥::andrea::♥:: 2
El Doosho 3
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 4
♥Cyn♥Esther♥ 4
LakerGirl 3
Synderella 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think its wrong to have a baby shower for a second baby?

Ok so basically I want to know what you think of this. Do you really think its not right to have 2 baby showers, that only your first baby should have one. Or do you think the times have changed and its ok for a baby shower for the 2nd baby.

Yes I think you should only have 1 ever Vote
 
 10.4% (7)
No its not wrong every baby is a celebration Vote
 
 83.6% (56)
I have had 2 or more baby showers Vote
 
 4.5% (3)
I will have more than one shower Vote
 
 1.5% (1)
*Mommy2-2Princesses* --- 16 years ago -

Ok so basically I want to know what you think of this. Do you really think its not right to have 2 baby showers, that only your first baby should have one. Or do you think the times have changed and its ok for a baby shower for the 2nd baby. 

Synderella --- 16 years ago -

It's completely up to you. 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 16 years ago -

every baby should be a celebration! Its called a baby shower, not a mommy shower. If it was a mommy shower then yes, only one but its a BABY shower! 

Mrs. Tiki --- 16 years ago -

I don't think it's wrong at all. Every baby is a blessing. 

Giggle Butt --- 16 years ago -

I was under the impression you had one for each child. My children are 6 years apart. They are also boy and girl. I have also heard of people that have one on base with their girlfriends and then they go back home and have another with family. Showers aren't about just the presents, they're about having everyone around and celebrating the baby still being in the belly! :) ha ha... just kidding! 

Giggle Butt --- 16 years ago -

 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 16 years ago -

Ive never had a shower... weve always been able to buy things we needed for baby on our own so we wouldnt feel right asking others to buy things for the kiddos... We had a welcome home baby BBQ when D-rock was born , but never asked anyone to bring anything, although a couple people brought toys or clothes for the munchkin... My babies are also bigger and grow faster than most so having a shower where everyone buys clothes is pointless because they rarely get to wear them unless the clothes are 2t lol... 

Charlie'sWife --- 16 years ago -

I didn't vote, only because the option I wanted wasn't there. Yes every baby should be a celebration, but baby showers are typically given to recieve gifts. If you are having a second child that is the same gender as the first and they are close (5 years apart or less) then have a "welcome to the world" party after they are born so everyone can meet them and you have a nice celebration. ETA: This only applies if you are the one doing all the leg work for the shower, if someone else takes the lead and does everything on their own then go for it. Other wise it seems kind of greedy, but that is just me. 

Toodles --- 16 years ago -

Wrong, no. But maybe not really necessary for most. 

KayCee --- 16 years ago -

i had one for my 2nd baby but not my 1st. i didnt have anything left for a baby since they were almost 5 years apart. but i think its fine. 

*Mommy2-2Princesses* --- 16 years ago -

Im having a second cause a friend out here said she would throw it, i didnt regisiter for anything big really. Just little stuff that i dont have from the first or lost during the 3 moves we have done. I got real mad this am when i woke up to see my very JEALOUS cousin have some smart comment about people having 2 baby showers.. 

*JuDgE*TJ* --- 16 years ago -

my very JEALOUS cousin have some smart comment about people having 2 baby showers thats lame! Its not her place to say anything, if someone is throwing you a shower then YOURE not having to showers. someone ELSE is providing your baby a shower of gifts... tell your cousin to f*ck off lol 

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

I was under the impression you had one for each child. Lol me too. I am pretty sure my mom had a baby shower for at least 5 out of the 6. 

Charlie'sWife --- 16 years ago -

I got real mad this am when i woke up to see my very JEALOUS cousin have some smart comment about people having 2 baby showers.. Ingore her. It's your (baby's) party, if someone else is doing it for you it'd be rude to say no. 

Giggle Butt --- 16 years ago -

Let her be jealous, those are her feelings, do what you want to do with your friends and your family. Just because you register, does not mean you'll get the stuff. PYS is awesome for getting ready for baby! :) 

the koz's --- 16 years ago -

My thoughts on this are.. If the second baby is a different gender than your first, its ok, or if its been a long time since you have had your first then i feel its ok.. I was invited to a baby shower the kids were 2 years apart, and the same sex i didnt go i just got her something when she had the baby.. 

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

I got real mad this am when i woke up to see my very JEALOUS cousin have some smart comment about people having 2 baby showers.. Hater. 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

have a "welcome to the world" party after they are born so everyone can meet them and you have a nice celebration. I like this idea. Showers just seem so tacky to me. I didn't want a shower, but the girls I worked with threw me one anyway. It was a surprise. I had no idea they were planning it. I would have much rather just had a party or something without the gifting, but I understand they were just trying to be nice. 

the koz's --- 16 years ago -

to each there own though.. Me personally i dont think its ok.. Celebrating the baby is ok.. but to have one to recieve gifts i dont think is right 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 16 years ago -

I got real mad this am when i woke up to see my very JEALOUS cousin have some smart comment about people having 2 baby showers.. Hater. pfft who cares...its not HER SHOWER..she ned to attend...:) 

*Mommy2-2Princesses* --- 16 years ago -

Its not her place to say anything, if someone is throwing you a shower then YOURE not having to showers. someone ELSE is providing your baby a shower of gifts... tell your cousin to f*ck off lolĀ  I did she is jealous of my other poor cousin too for being pregnant.. And yah a friend offered to throw it for me . I mainly just want people to come to our new house and have fun, dont care about the gifts i just love having company 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 16 years ago -

makes no sense..if you have diff sexes then you will need some diff stuff...but even if you had same sex babies...its a celebration..NO GRUMPINESS ALLOWED 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 16 years ago -

Personally, I wont throw myself a baby shower but if friends want to do it then let them. I dont have an issue with it. 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

I think the problem in this country (because most other countries don't have the "shower" concept) is that some people tend to rely on their showers for the things their baby will need instead of making sure they can afford everything before getting pregnant. I've known people who got upset because they didn't get some of the high ticket items on their baby registries. 

Giggle Butt --- 16 years ago -

I mainly just want people to come to our new house and have fun, dont care about the gifts i just love having company DITTO! :) It's nice having friends come over. Just another excuse for company. 

*Mommy2-2Princesses* --- 16 years ago -

Just because you register, does not mean you'll get the stuff. PYS is awesome for getting ready for baby! :) Yah i dont expect to get much that is fine.. I just want people to come hang out :) 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 16 years ago -

I've known people who got upset because they didn't get some of the high ticket items on their baby registries. then some people are selfish... not EVERYONE asks for super expensive stuff...some people may ask for basics or some DONT ask for anything and let people bring what they want 

Giggle Butt --- 16 years ago -

My friend and I had our babies three days apart. We had thrown eachother our showers. LOL We shared the shower! :) She didn't have many friends because she was new here. Also, my family is here. They wanted to buy her some gifts too. It was really sweet of them. 

♥Cyn♥Esther♥ --- 16 years ago -

What about a baby shower for an expectant mother who already has one or more children? Traditionally, a baby shower is given only for the 1st child. Most mothers have most of the essential baby items after the 1st baby (like a crib, stroller, child safety items, baby monitors, etc). But each child is special and unique, and so it is very common for an expectant mother to receive a baby shower for each child. And there is just something about a baby shower that makes having a baby more exciting and the mother feels strengthened and loved. Regardless of how many children a mother may have, pregnancy is hard and scary EACH TIME! A baby shower helps in many unspoken and unseen ways. Because a 2nd time mommy already has the "big" essentials, gifts of diapers, burp cloths, baby lotion, formula etc. are excellent. Also, gifts to pamper the expectant mother are wonderful and fun ideas. Plan the perfect shower I think it is ok to have a baby shower for each child, just not to register for the big items. It is assumed the parents are better prepared for each subsequent child. lol *Edit* I actually wouldn't recommend registering anywhere for each child after. 

All Abouts --- 16 years ago -

I think if the babies are less the 3 yrs apart it is no ok, is better to have a welcome baby party . I also dont like seeing cribs and furniture on the baby wish list. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground