To Whom it May Concern,
Pursuant to Article I, Section 2, Clause 3 of the Constitution, the only information you are empowered to request is the total number of occupants at this address. My name, sex, age, date of birth, race, ethnicity, telephone number, relationship and housing tenure have absolutely nothing to do with apportioning direct taxes or determining the number of representatives in the House of Representatives.
Therefore, neither Congress nor the Census Bureau have the constitutional authority to make that information request a component of the enumeration outlined in Article I, Section 2, Clause 3. In addition, I cannot be subject to a fine for basing my conduct on the Constitution because that document trumps laws passed by Congress.
Interstate Commerce Commission v. Brimson, 154 U.S. 447, 479 (May 26, 1894)
Neither branch of the legislative department [House of Representatives or Senate], still less any merely administrative body [such as the Census Bureau], established by congress, possesses, or can be invested with, a general power of making inquiry into the private affairs of the citizen. Kilbourn v. Thompson, 103 U.S. 168, 190. We said in Boyd v. U.S., 116 U. S. 616, 630, 6 Sup. Ct. 524,―and it cannot be too often repeated,―that the principles that embody the essence of constitutional liberty and security forbid all invasions on the part of government and its employees of the sanctity of a mans home and the privacies of his life.
As said by Mr. Justice Field in Re Pacific Ry. Commission, 32 Fed. 241, 250, of all the rights of the citizen, few are of greater importance or more essential to his peace and happiness than the right of personal security, and that involves, not merely protection of his person from assault, but exemption of his private affairs, books, and papers from inspection and scrutiny of others. Without the enjoyment of this right, all others would lose half their value.
Note: This United States Supreme Court case has never been overturned.
Respectfully,
A Citizen of the United States of America
name, sex, age, date of birth, race, ethnicity, telephone number, relationship and housing tenure
Well wouldn't the age help with funding for schools and such? And I'm sure the race would help with statistics.
Hmmm.
Interesting though...
Well wouldn't the age help with funding for schools and such? And I'm sure the race would help with statistics.
That is what I thought? Why are some people against the census??
Well wouldn't the age help with funding for schools and such? And I'm sure the race would help with statistics.
Hmmm.
Interesting though...
I don't think it's wrong if you feel the need to fill it out, but not everyone is comfortable with it. It's just good to know what your rights are, ya know. :)
That is what I thought? Why are some people against the census??
Because some hold the ignorant view of "invasion of privacy". I mean geezus, they aren't asking when you start or how your sex life is. Calm down people.
I don't think it's wrong if you feel the need to fill it out, but not everyone is comfortable with it. It's just good to know what your rights are, ya know. :)
Exactly :)
That is what I thought? Why are some people against the census??
Some feel that it's invasion of their personal privacy and don't want the government to have that information.
Some feel that it's invasion of their personal privacy and don't want the government to have that information.
And that's ridiculous. It's like say if I go to the doctor and refuse to give him my medical history because I'd feel "violated". How can he treat me properly without my medical history? Same thing here.
why not just fill it out? They do one every 10 years.. what's the big deal? Is it harming you?
The ten year one is required, but all you have to fill out is how many people are within your household. The longer version, which is sent out to 300 million per year, is a little bit more invasive. I just posted it for those who are uncomfortable with filling out all of that information about their income, family, expenses, ect.
And that's ridiculous. It's like say if I go to the doctor and refuse to give him my medical history because I'd feel "violated". How can he treat me properly without my medical history? Same thing here. How can the government fund properly without your information?
I don't need the government to fund anything for me. Some may feel differently, though.
I don't need the government to fund anything for me. Some may feel differently, though.
Oh, really? You don't need tax money to go to the local schools? You don't need them to fund the construction of the roads you drive on?
HAHHAHAHAHAHAHA OK!
What is the big freaking deal??? The govenrment knows more about you(and your household) from your taxes then it will ever learn from a census. Just fill it out. Geez!
Oh, really? You don't need tax money to go to the local schools? You don't need them to fund the construction of the roads you drive on?
HAHHAHAHAHAHAHA OK!
I actually don't plan on putting my son in public school, but besides that...that is what the ten year census is for. It asks how many people are within a household. Why does it matter how much I make, my race...ect?
Well wouldn't the age help with funding for schools and such? And I'm sure the race would help with statistics.
Hmmm.
Interesting though...
Wrong. Funding for school comes from the State. Not the federal Govt. and what can them knowing your race help do.
Oh, really? You don't need tax money to go to the local schools? You don't need them to fund the construction of the roads you drive on?
The Fed Govt does not pay for any roads EXCEPT interstates. Any streets or freeways are paid for by the state.
I actually don't plan on putting my son in public school, but besides that...that is what the ten year census is for. It asks how many people are within a household. Why does it matter how much I make, my race...ect?
I don't remember it asking how much you made.. but hello, taxes? You have to share that info anyways.
What is the big freaking deal??? The govenrment knows more about you(and your household) from your taxes then it will ever learn from a census. Just fill it out. Geez!
That is your opinion. I'm just saying it's not illegal to choose to NOT fill out the extended version. It's optional. If you want to fill it out, then that's fine.
I don't need the government to fund anything for me. Some may feel differently, though.
That's straight.
Then you are no longer allowed on any public roads, sidewalks, highways, schools, buses, etc.
You can build your own!
And build your children their own school :)
How's that sound?
WOW, you don't have that "this is stupid" filter on your brain.
Unless you're doing something illegal or don't want people to know you have kids or if you're white or hispanic etc.. (Which would be silly) then I don't see a valid reason for avoiding the census. Really, what are you hiding??
El Doosho - You have made a point that the federal government doesn't fund some of the things that we are bringing up.. Don't you think they share that info with the state?? Just asking.
El Doosho - You have made a point that the federal government doesn't fund some of the things that we are bringing up.. Don't you think they share that info with the state?? Just asking
Yup :)
That's straight.
Then you are no longer allowed on any public roads, sidewalks, highways, schools, buses, etc.
You can build your own!
And build your children their own school :)
How's that sound?
WOW, you don't have that "this is stupid" filter on your brain.
The government takes out taxes for that regardless if I fill out the extended census form or not.
Wrong. Funding for school comes from the State. Not the federal Govt. and what can them knowing your race help do.
The federal government provides supplemental funding for education throughout the country implemented by things such as the no child left behind act.
El Doosho - You have made a point that the federal government doesn't fund some of the things that we are bringing up.. Don't you think they share that info with the state?? Just asking.
Other than how many people live in their state, your State CAN NOT release any of the other info to the Fed Govt.
The government takes out taxes for that regardless if I fill out the extended census form or not.
Yes, they take the taxes out.. but things like the census help them determine WHAT to spend the money and WHERE.
Other than how many people live in their state, your State CAN NOT release any of the other info to the Fed Govt.
No, the other way around.. Would the fed govt share the info with the state govt? That way the results of this census help the state determine how to use the $$ they collect from taxes.
No, the other way around.. Would the fed govt share the info with the state govt? That way the results of this census help the state determine how to use the $$ they collect from taxes.
No they do not.
Yes, they take the taxes out.. but things like the census help them determine WHAT to spend the money and WHERE
Wrong again. Look up the purpose of the census.