Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: How often do you spank?

who's talking here?

petit oiseau 1
Mer Independent Scentsy SSD 1
✧cristina✧ 1
ChestyMcBreasty 1
*Mommy2-2Princesses* 1
El Doosho 2
texasbound 2
♥Cyn♥Esther♥ 1
Pink Taco 3
Shary 4
***C+J*** 1
Tits McGee 3
Carawills 1
☼J∃ηиi 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: How often do you spank?

Recently an article in a major publication was written stating evidence from 'experts' "stronger than ever" against the use of spanking and the like. Personally, I tend to be old school in this area and it works good in our household, whereas neglecting to spank causes tensions to continually be mounting it seems. Anyhow, I was just wondering where others sit with this issue. If you wouldn't mind, mention the age of your kid to help make more sense of the matter, as one would naturally gather a toddler vs. an 8-yr-old would likely be pretty different.

1.) Never have and never will. Vote
 
 22.9% (8)
2.) Have once or twice but don't intend to ever again. Vote
 
 2.9% (1)
3.) A couple times a year. Vote
 
 5.7% (2)
4.) Maybe about once every one or two months. Vote
 
 11.4% (4)
5.) At least once a month. Vote
 
 2.9% (1)
6.) At least once a week. Vote
 
 17.1% (6)
7.) Maybe everyday. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
8.) Definitely once a day, or perhaps a couple times each day. Vote
 
 37.1% (13)
Shary --- 16 years ago -

Recently an article in a major publication was written stating evidence from 'experts' "stronger than ever" against the use of spanking and the like. Personally, I tend to be old school in this area and it works good in our household, whereas neglecting to spank causes tensions to continually be mounting it seems. Anyhow, I was just wondering where others sit with this issue. If you wouldn't mind, mention the age of your kid to help make more sense of the matter, as one would naturally gather a toddler vs. an 8-yr-old would likely be pretty different. 

Pink Taco --- 16 years ago -

Here we go again.... 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

If I'm home every other day or so. While deployed, usually at least once a day. 

*Mommy2-2Princesses* --- 16 years ago -

So.. I remember a post a while ago about spanking with a spoon or hand. Got a Christian book, by James Dobson called Dare to Disciple it actually says to NEVER spank with your hand. Says to always use a spoon because your hands are meant to love on them with not spank. 

***C+J*** --- 16 years ago -

my niece but she loves to get in moods for trouble, she is 4, and they are not very often moods! 

Shary --- 16 years ago -

Here we go again.... What do you mean? (Jfyi, I'm really new to PU and am practically never on it.) 

Carawills --- 16 years ago -

I'm not spanking, since my child is only ten months old...but when he's old enough to act out and flat out defy me, I probably will. I see nothing wrong with it, especially since I grew up being spanked. Often times, my brother and I deserved it. These "experts" must be smoking something. It's usually undisciplined children that act out alot and are generally disrespectful. 

Pink Taco --- 16 years ago -

We had a topic about spanking not too long ago, and things got kinda ugly. I think like 10 pages long. 

Shary --- 16 years ago -

I'm not talking about how you spank or what you use (hand vs. spoon or whatever.) I'm just interested to know how often other folks find themselves doing it in general. 

Shary --- 16 years ago -

We had a topic about spanking not too long ago, and things got kinda ugly. I think like 10 pages long. Oh good grief. Yikes! Well, I certainly don't plan to be online much more than ten minute, so heh.... 

Pink Taco --- 16 years ago -

I only spank my child when it is needed. I don't spank or lay a hand on him for stupid little things. And i'll tell you this much, when he gets older and he talks back or yells at me, you bet i'm gonna smack his mouth. That's how some kids get to be very disrespectful when they're teens, because parents don't discipline them, whatever it may be spanking or not. I don't spank my son often at all, because either me or Daddy will yell or give him "the look" and he knows we mean business. 

✧cristina✧ --- 16 years ago -

I spank my 3-year-old every now and again, but time outs work better for her. When I spank, though, I do it not to inflict pain but rather to hurt their feelings, if that makes any sense. I will give her a warning before I spank, too, and that will usually diffuse the situation, resulting in no spank. So spanking happens, but very rarely. 

Mer Independent Scentsy SSD --- 16 years ago -

Never. Never have, never will. My boys are 4 and 5. 

ChestyMcBreasty --- 16 years ago -

NEVER, NEVER! 

petit oiseau --- 16 years ago -

I have tried it.. I don't like it. Other things work better with us 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

I spank my daughter, hades yes. I don't beat the living sh!t out of her, but I make sure it hurts. If she is doing something she doesn't realize is wrong, I will give her a verbal warning. Then if she continues to engage in this behavior, I spank. She doesn't do it again when I spank. If she talks back to me, she gets a hard thump in the mouth. I am not going to sit back and just tell her "no, no, no" if I've done it once. Spanking is punishment. I was spanked and yes, at the time, I thought "oh my parents hate me, this is abuse!" But looking back on this, I respect them for it because it molded me into a responsible and mature adult and I could only try and be the parents mine were. Spanking is NOT abuse, IMO. It becomes abuse when the child has done nothing wrong and the child is black and blue from head to toe. As Cristina stated, I do not spank to inflict pain, I spank to show them that there are consequences to their actions. Like I said, I was spanked and I have respect for my parents. There is a difference between fear and respect and that's the difference between spanking and abuse. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

All joking aside, there is nothing wrong with spanking. Some people have the heart to discipline their kids that way and others don't. What works for some won't work for all. As to me? I believe that if you spare the rod, you spoil the child. Where did I hear that? 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

All joking aside, there is nothing wrong with spanking. Some people have the heart to discipline their kids that way and others don't. What works for some won't work for all. As to me? I believe that if you spare the rod, you spoil the child. Where did I hear that? EXACTLY! It's discipline. IMO, standing behind the lines and just telling them "no, no, no" will give them zero respect for their parents. But I do agree that different things work for different children. 

texasbound --- 16 years ago -

by James Dobson called Dare to Disciple great book!! I believe that if you spare the rod, you spoil the child. yup if my child chooses to act out over and over again then there will be consequences... depending on the offense, they might get time ot, toys taken, tv time taken, or a spanking.... talking back gets them an automatic spanking. i was spanked as a child... i dont see what the big deal is.. 

☼J∃ηиi --- 16 years ago -

My son is almost 7 and was spanked when he was younger. I don't need to anymore. All I say is Do you want a spanking?! and he listens. Over all he's actually a well behaved kid. He knows what is expected of him and what is tolerated. He gets a ton of compliments from other parents and adults and I'm very proud of the person he's become. He's still a wild and crazy little boy but knows his limits. So in response, Yes I spank and I will if needed with future children. I completely agree with LaLacy. 

♥Cyn♥Esther♥ --- 16 years ago -

I do it incase they think of acting up. 

texasbound --- 16 years ago -

oh and i rarly spank our duaghter b/c it just sets her off more... she usually has to sit in the bath tub until she is done with her fits... 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

My son is almost 7 and was spanked when he was younger. I don't need to anymore. All I say is Do you want a spanking?! and he listens. That's the phrase that scared the bejeezus out of me when I was younger LOL if I heard that, I was Little Miss Perfect for the rest of the day. I have seen numerous children who's parents refuse to spank and they are little sh!ts, no offense to any parents against spankings. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground