Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Plasma or LCD?

who's talking here?

Marygrace 1
Cupcake Addict 1
Cayla 1
*All Smiles* 2
PeachyKeene 1
Donny 3
IrishTwinsx2plus1 2
KayCee 1
Donnye oregonbound bye camp p 1
B*Bright 8
ALS MommaKitty 1
ashleyx3 2
Kariane 1
lucky 1
MissMaggy 1
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 1
Spork Fight 1
SusseTraume 1
Colonel LizZoo 1
Starr 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Plasma or LCD?

Looking into getting a new tv in this household (well, doing the research anyways..) Most of you saw my post yesterday I think about should I buy one now or wait til he gets home. I'm just wondering, would you prefer plasma or LCD screen? I threw "other" out there because I'm sure there will be that one person who says "neither, we like our old school tv" or "we have an LED tv" or "we have a projector"....so whatever...lol.. Which do you think has better quality, etc? Also, keep in mind that I have a 2.5 year old (who knows now to mess with the tv) but will also be having twins very soon. So they will have to learn not to touch the tv and all....but just wondering what you know (pros vs cons) of getting one over the other...thanks!

Plasma Vote
 
 7.8% (4)
LCD Vote
 
 90.2% (46)
Other Vote
 
 2.0% (1)
B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

Looking into getting a new tv in this household (well, doing the research anyways..) Most of you saw my post yesterday I think about should I buy one now or wait til he gets home. I'm just wondering, would you prefer plasma or LCD screen? I threw "other" out there because I'm sure there will be that one person who says "neither, we like our old school tv" or "we have an LED tv" or "we have a projector"....so whatever...lol.. Which do you think has better quality, etc? Also, keep in mind that I have a 2.5 year old (who knows not to mess with the tv) but will also be having twins very soon. So they will have to learn not to touch the tv and all....but just wondering what you know (pros vs cons) of getting one over the other...thanks! 

*All Smiles* --- 16 years ago -

We have both plasma and LCD in our house. I haven't noticed much of a difference. If you or your husband are big gamers I would go with LCD or LED. I highly recommend getting a Samsung though. Their TV's have THE best picture. 

IrishTwinsx2plus1 --- 16 years ago -

We have LCD in the living room and Plasma in our bedroom. I think I like the picture of the LCD better. We have ours mounted to the wall, so no worry about kids messing with them. 

IrishTwinsx2plus1 --- 16 years ago -

 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

well, i found a really good deal on a plasma tv TV Type:: Plasma Flat-Panel Screen Size Class:: 50" Aspect Ratio:: 16:9 Vertical Resolution:: 1080p Screen Refresh Rate:: 600Hz ENERGY STAR Qualified Brightness:: 1000 cd/m² for $699.99 ($831 with tax & delivery to my house) thats a great deal i think, but i'm scared to get plasma b/c of the kids...i could always mount it which would be a great idea actually! But also I just didn't know if one was better than the other... If it's not much of a difference then I could go with plasma then...we play xbox sometimes but we aren't like huge gamers... 

PeachyKeene --- 16 years ago -

I highly recommend getting a Samsung though. Their TV's have THE best picture. agreed. I say no to plasma. 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

I say no Plasma just because they're SO DIFFICULT to move...and I'm sure you'll be moving sooner or later =) 

lucky --- 16 years ago -

Plasma, all the way. An LCD is cheaper to make, so now they are phasing out plasmas. I did a ton of research. I agree with Samsung, we have 2. The TOC edition is awesome!! Good luck! 

*All Smiles* --- 16 years ago -

We've moved with our plasma and it was fine. It actually was moved several times. To and from storage in Hawaii, to storage in CA for 6 months, and then into our house. It's a big one too. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

you should mount it high up on the wall :) worth the 100 for the mount :) 

Cayla --- 16 years ago -

We have lcd's and I like them better then plasma... 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

wow...sounds like everyone prefers lcd (going off the polls)....thanks for your input! I appreciate it! 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 16 years ago -

I learned in my chem class a few years ago that with plasma TV's they dont lsat as long because the plasma leaks out of the little pocket things that hold them. i would go with LCD. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

just bumping to see if i get any fresh answers.... I have asked a lot of people about this and I keep getting conflicting information...that plasma's are crap....they have "burn in" and go out faster than lcd's....etc...but if they are such crap, why do people continue to buy them and they continue to be made???? 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

I learned in my chem class a few years ago that with plasma TV's they dont lsat as long because the plasma leaks out of the little pocket things that hold them. i would go with LCD. I read online on a "plasma vs. lcd" website that said plasma's these days are a lot better about that. They still lose color, but most plasma's have a half life of 100,000 hours. So if you left it on for 4 hours every day, it would have a half life of 68 years. Which would mean at 68 years your tv will be as half as bright as it was when you bought it. But it did say that it depends on the brand...only the better high end brands have that good of a half life.... Oh, also read that while plasmas are more known for having burn in, there is better technology to keep it from happening and besides, common sense can keep that from happening...LOL...don't leave your tv on a still image and you won't have that problem...lol.. 

Kariane --- 16 years ago -

LCD's are easier to move. Well all flatscreens can be a pain to move. But the plasmas you can't lay them on their sides. 

ashleyx3 --- 16 years ago -

LCDS are better for gaming than Plasmas. If you do a lot of gaming the picture can burn into the screen on plasmas. 

Marygrace --- 16 years ago -

Plasma is very delicate. If you're moving alot it will not last period. So many con's than pro's imo. We currently have lcd's. We had plasma but returned it. It's a great picture BUT it's very sensetive to any light if the lights in the room are not turned off it will reflect to your plasma and it's annoying. We are looking forward buying an LED =). 

Starr --- 16 years ago -

I say LCD. Although we are having problems with ours but I'm sure it's just from us and not the tv. First off my DH burned his computer wallpaper to the screen so that sucks. Secondly about 6 months after we got it a giant cluster of vertical lines appeared on the screen. They are always there and are double in size when you first turn the tv on. We need a new one already and we've only had this tv for 3 years. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

i've seen a lot of people say that plasmas are not good for gaming??? why is that?? i mean, ashleyx3 i see you said that it can burn into the screen, but usually the game is moving...the graphics are constantly changing right? so wouldn't that keep it from burn in??? 

MissMaggy --- 16 years ago -

plasmas won't last as long. they burn out, that's why they're gonna be cheaper. 

KayCee --- 16 years ago -

we have a samsung dlp.. whatever that is??lol but it stopped workinf after tmo moved us:( we love our new tv we have now 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

LCD or LED 

Cupcake Addict --- 16 years ago -

We just got a new LED from Vizio a few months ago....best buy EVER. Didn't think there would be a huge difference between LCD and LED......there was. We aren't huge gamers (though we do use our Wii & Ps3 occasionally) but we have tons of favorite shows and love movies. I LOVE it 

Donny --- 16 years ago -

Here is the skinny.... Plasma's offer the BEST picture because they can make true black where an LCD/LED can not. Their downside is the weight of the TV and the glare. They are best used in dark rooms like a bedroom. The burn in and shorter life of them is old news, plasma's no longer do either of those things which is why they are still being made and purchased. LCD/LED- Very light weight and easy to mount on a wall. Great picture and better refresh rates then plasma's which makes viewing nicer during action sequences from a video game, action movie or sports. No glare, you get a great view from any angle so they work better in rooms with a lot of natural light. I have 4 tvs (All Samsung). 3 LCD's (family room and each kids bedroom and a Plasma in my bedroom). A friend just got the new Samsung 55" LED and it's insane how thin and lightweight it is and how amazing the picture looks. The price tag about gave me a heart-attack though... Honestly i see no picture difference between my 52" LCD and his 55" LED, his is much thinner and light, but picture quality is about the same, don't buy into all the hype about LED tv's...sure it's the "new" thing, but they cost more if you don't need one that is ultra-lightweight and thin save the money and get a nice LCD. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

donny- see, i don't remember the website, but i read that plasma's are better for watching the big game (aka lots of action) because they are better at refreshing or whatever...it was something to do with the 120Hz vs 240 Hz part of the specs.....so i'm not 100% but it said that plasmas were better at watching stuff like action...thats why i was wondering why people were saying gaming is better on lcd... thanks everyone for your input! I guess we'll just go with an LCD, but that plasma was on sale for a good price..so i thought it would be nice to have... anywho, this will be our main TV that goes in the living room...and it will be used for tv during the day (not so dark) and tv/movies at night with the hubs (dark) and gaming (usually at night, so it would be dark)...and it will be on a LOT because i hate not having a background noise....so i guess lcd is the way to go.... 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

Plasmas aren't as good for gaming because they aren't able to change picture as quickly as the LCD or LED-LCD (there is no true LED on the market right now). If you aren't an avid gamer, you won't need to worry about it. The difference is a fraction of a second but some people notice a blurring during fast action scenes (including sporting events). Plasmas have blacker blacks and truer color, but as was pointed out by MissMagii, they do burn out. The newer plasmas last much longer than the old ones, but the panel will still eventually burn out. Our old plasma went out in 3 1/2 years, but was still covered by our warranty so we got a new one for free. I love our new Samsung plasma! We don't have the problem of reflecting light mentioned above, it doesn't seem to run hot and it survived a move without any difficulty; however, our next TV will be a Samsung LED-LCD. They are more energy efficient, thinner, and should last longer than the other types of TV. In short, buy the TV that fits in your budget, but whatever TV you get, buy the extended warranty!!! Good luck! 

Donny --- 16 years ago -

donny- see, i don't remember the website, but i read that plasma's are better for watching the big game (aka lots of action) because they are better at refreshing or whatever...it was something to do with the 120Hz vs 240 Hz part of the specs You have the right info just jumbled a bit. 120/240Hz refresh rate displays are LCD tv's... they still suffer from a motion blur effect, where the individual pixels are just slightly out of step with the image on the screen. Plasma's do not suffer from this problem, so you are correct they are fine/better for watching "the big show". I wouldn't even consider a LCD if it wasn't at least a 120 refresh rate, 240 is becoming more the norm so if you can find one with 240hz at a good price jump on it. Avoid 60hz refresh rate LCD's like the plague. With 120/240Hz refresh rate LCD/LED's the motion blur is almost unnoticeable which is why i'd recommend going that route over a Plasma. Honestly you'll be happy with either choice don't be scared out of a Plasma, if you find a deal and are happy with the tv's picture go for it. 

ashleyx3 --- 16 years ago -

i mean, ashleyx3 i see you said that it can burn into the screen, but usually the game is moving...the graphics are constantly changing right? so wouldn't that keep it from burn in???  I really don't have any idea why. When we were buying our tv we were stuck between LCD and Plasma and the person who was helping us said he had a Plasma and the game burned into the screen. I guess he tried to get it fixed but they wouldn't do it and said that Plasmas have a history of getting the pictures burned into the screens. I'd say go with LCD, but if you can afford and LED go with that! 

Donny --- 16 years ago -

Before you purchase anything i'd recommend going onto CNET and trying to find the review of the tv you are thinking of getting. From what i have seen their reviews are spot on. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground