Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: fix what's broke or start new?

who's talking here?

Princess B 1
Just MerBear 5
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 1
ashleyx3 1
FasHi 1
*Sarah H* 1
El Doosho 1
☼J∃ηиi 1
Starr 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: fix what's broke or start new?

ness's poll got me thinking...so i literally don't know what to do with my car. i have a 2002 acura mdx, with about 175k miles on it. it will be paid off in november of this year; however, it needs a new transmission (est. at $5k for all repairs). the car itself is worth about $2k. at this point, the repairs are worth more than the vehicle itself. my thoughts are, maybe i should just trade in my current car for something newer, smaller, and more fuel-efficient if i can get the monthly payments the same/less than what i'm paying now b/c obviously it's already in my budget. but that would mean having a car payment for 4 or 5 more years. = / everyone i ask just says "oh i dunno, mer, just do whatever." so tell me, what do you think i should do?

keep current SUV, pay $5k to fix it and pay it off in novemer Vote
 
 4.8% (1)
trade it in, plus a lil extra $$ down, and get a new car with same monthly payment Vote
 
 95.2% (20)
Just MerBear --- 16 years ago -

ness's poll got me thinking...so i literally don't know what to do with my car. i have a 2002 acura mdx, with about 175k miles on it. it will be paid off in november of this year; however, it needs a new transmission (est. at $5k for all repairs). the car itself is worth about $2k. at this point, the repairs are worth more than the vehicle itself. my thoughts are, maybe i should just trade in my current car for something newer, smaller, and more fuel-efficient if i can get the monthly payments the same/less than what i'm paying now b/c obviously it's already in my budget. but that would mean having a car payment for 4 or 5 more years. = / everyone i ask just says "oh i dunno, mer, just do whatever." so tell me, what do you think i should do? 

*Sarah H* --- 16 years ago -

I say trade it in. 

ashleyx3 --- 16 years ago -

You'll get more money for it if you sell it yourself instead of trading it in. With that said, if it were me I'd just try and sell it myself and use the money I get from the sale for a down payment on a new car. 

FasHi --- 16 years ago -

thats a hard one. If you think about it.. once you pay it off and get it fix, you wont have anymore car payments and its so nice not having any car payments! 

Just MerBear --- 16 years ago -

You'll get more money for it if you sell it yourself instead of trading it in. With that said, if it were me I'd just try and sell it myself and use the money I get from the sale for a down payment on a new car. i still owe on the car, though. if i trade it in to the dealership, then they would pay it off and roll the remaining balance in to a new loan. 

☼J∃ηиi --- 16 years ago -

trade it in. If you're going to be paying 5K to fix it couldn't that be put towards the new car? If you were going to finance the repairs your still going to be making payments when you pay off the car. Either way you'll have a payment, or a good down payment. Just makes sense to get something new that will last you a while. 

Princess B --- 16 years ago -

I'd trade it in, you need something reliable for those boys! I won't lie though, i'll miss the partymobile ;( 

Just MerBear --- 16 years ago -

thats a hard one. If you think about it.. once you pay it off and get it fix, you wont have anymore car payments and its so nice not having any car payments! aargh, i knowww.....that's why i have this dilemma! i've been paying for cars since i was 17! i dunno what it's like to be without a car payment LOL 

Just MerBear --- 16 years ago -

I'd trade it in, you need something reliable for those boys! I won't lie though, i'll miss the partymobile ;( lol heck yes it was the san o party bus! haha....SAN ONOFRE B!TCHES 

Starr --- 16 years ago -

I had this exact same dilemma 2 years ago. My Tiburon needed a new Transmission too and it was going to cost more than the car was worth at that point. I decided to trade it in and the dealership tried to convince me to try and sell the car on my own and use that money for a down payment. I didn't cause my DH was deployed and I wasn't comfortable doing that by myself plus who was going to buy an old car that needed a new transmission? So I ended up trading it in, they paid off the car and rolled whatever was left into the car I have now. Good luck with your decision! 

Just MerBear --- 16 years ago -

thanks, everyone, i think it's obvs what i need to do. it's exciting to be looking for a new car, but stressful too...this is a huge decision! 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Trading it in is a suckers bet. Fix it and invest the money you WOULD HAVE been spending on a car payment otherwise. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

Whoever said you will get more if you sell it yourself is right. Especially if you clean it up very nice. Print off bluebook values for people who look at the vehicle. This way they already have the research and see how much it is worth. So when you throw out a 2k prictag, they might only haggle you down a bit. You trade it in...you are prob not going to get much. Now...you can always go into a dealership and have them take a look and tell you how much they can give you no obligatiions. Just dont let them trick you into running credit or picking out something else first blah blah blah. Tell them you are in the market...you would like them to preapraise your trade in first though. Make sure its clean and looks fab before you ask though. That matters. I would def get something fuel efficient and that doesnt cost much. Really check into a lot of things bc right now there are a lot of rebates going on with different companies. Also...fyi....just bc dealerships get rebates from the manufacturers doesnt mean they have to "offer" them to their customers. So you really do need to shop around. Sometimes dealers get kickbacks for older (current year) merchandise that they do not publicly offer to customers. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground