Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Thoughts....

who's talking here?

Vod Kaknockers 5
Giggle Butt 1
*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* 1
3Js mommie 1
AINOKEA 1
Smithwick 7
AmandaNicole19 1
VelvetFire 2
RainbowBright 1
dontyaknow 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* --- 16 years ago -

4 year old can be sued

For those that can't link.

4-Year-Old Can Be Sued, Judge Rules in Bike Case
By ALAN FEUER
Published: October 28, 2010
Recommend
Twitter
comments (353)
Sign In to E-Mail

Print


Reprints

Share
CloseLinkedinDiggMixxMySpaceYahoo! BuzzPermalink Citing cases dating back as far as 1928, a judge has ruled that a young girl accused of running down an elderly woman while racing a bicycle with training wheels on a Manhattan sidewalk two years ago can be sued for negligence.

The ruling by the judge, Justice Paul Wooten of State Supreme Court in Manhattan, did not find that the girl was liable, but merely permitted a lawsuit brought against her, another boy and their parents to move forward.

The suit that Justice Wooten allowed to proceed claims that in April 2009, Juliet Breitman and Jacob Kohn, who were both 4, were racing their bicycles, under the supervision of their mothers, Dana Breitman and Rachel Kohn, on the sidewalk of a building on East 52nd Street. At some point in the race, they struck an 87-year-old woman named Claire Menagh, who was walking in front of the building and, according to the complaint, was “seriously and severely injured,” suffering a hip fracture that required surgery. She died three weeks later.

Her estate sued the children and their mothers, claiming they had acted negligently during the accident. In a response, Juliet’s lawyer, James P. Tyrie, argued that the girl was not “engaged in an adult activity” at the time of the accident — “She was riding her bicycle with training wheels under the supervision of her mother” — and was too young to be held liable for negligence.

In legal papers, Mr. Tyrie added, “Courts have held that an infant under the age of 4 is conclusively presumed to be incapable of negligence.” (Rachel and Jacob Kohn did not seek to dismiss the case against them.)

But Justice Wooten declined to stretch that rule to children over 4. On Oct. 1, he rejected a motion to dismiss the case because of Juliet’s age, noting that she was three months shy of turning 5 when Ms. Menagh was struck, and thus old enough to be sued.

Mr. Tyrie “correctly notes that infants under the age of 4 are conclusively presumed incapable of negligence,” Justice Wooten wrote in his decision, referring to the 1928 case. “Juliet Breitman, however, was over the age of 4 at the time of the subject incident. For infants above the age of 4, there is no bright-line rule.”

The New York Law Journal reported the decision on Thursday.

Mr. Tyrie had also argued that Juliet should not be held liable because her mother was present; Justice Wooten disagreed.

“A parent’s presence alone does not give a reasonable child carte blanche to engage in risky behavior such as running across a street,” the judge wrote. He added that any “reasonably prudent child,” who presumably has been told to look both ways before crossing a street, should know that dashing out without looking is dangerous, with or without a parent there. The crucial factor is whether the parent encourages the risky behavior; if so, the child should not be held accountable.

In Ms. Menagh’s case, however, there was nothing to indicate that Juliet’s mother “had any active role in the alleged incident, only that the mother was ‘supervising,’ a term that is too vague to hold meaning here,” he wrote. He concluded that there was no evidence of Juliet’s “lack of intelligence or maturity” or anything to “indicate that another child of similar age and capacity under the circumstances could not have reasonably appreciated the danger of riding a bicycle into an elderly woman.”

Mr. Tyrie, Dana Breitman and Rachel Kohn did not respond to messages seeking comment. 

3Js mommie --- 16 years ago -

I just read that on yahoo, that is crazy. Sorry for the old lady but to sue that little girl, they should be ashamed. 

Smithwick --- 16 years ago -

but to sue that little girl, they should be ashamed.

At what point due we not hold people (of any age) accountable for their actions?

Who is to say that the 87 year old lady would not have lived to be 100+ if she hadn't been struck down and had to have surgery which lead to her death. The family has suffered a loss and more than likely a financial burden which prompted tham to sue.

Yes I believe the parents (mother) should be held more accountable for the accident, but it also leads to the question what did the child do after hitting the women? Did she stop or keep going? Was she remorseful or ambiguous to what she had done? Do I honestly think that a jury of 12 people will come to finding holding the child responisable no, but the mother maybe. 

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

At what point due we not hold people (of any age) accountable for their actions?

THE CHILD WAS 4 YEARS OLD!!!!!!!! 

RainbowBright --- 16 years ago -

I think the parents should have done a better job of watching the children. Also in that same breath at 4 years old the child does know (well should know) what is okay on a bike if not the child should not have a bike. The parents should have made sure they knew the rules of having a bike and didn't understand stopping especially for older people then they shouldn't have a bike but that's just what i think. 

Smithwick --- 16 years ago -

THE CHILD WAS 4 YEARS OLD!!!!!!!!

Do you have kids? DO you hold them accountable for their actions?

Again read my complete comment or better yet let me quote it for you

Do I honestly think that a jury of 12 people will come to finding holding the child responisable no, but the mother maybe.  

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

Do you have kids? DO you hold them accountable for their actions?


Yes I do have kids. NO I don't hold her accountable for her actions.

Again read my complete comment or better yet let me quote it for you

Do I honestly think that a jury of 12 people will come to finding holding the child responisable no, but the mother maybe.


I did read it all, and I'm not saying not to punish the child but to sue a 4 year old, come on. 

Giggle Butt --- 16 years ago -

Who is to say that the 87 year old lady would not have lived to be 100+ if she hadn't been struck down and had to have surgery which lead to her death. The family has suffered a loss and more than likely a financial burden which prompted tham to sue.

I'm sad for what's going on, but what was the 87 year old doing with out supervision while the children were riding their bikes? There's always two sides.


Well now that you've heard about this, ladies make sure your children ride their bikes in the street so that your children will not be liable and that the person driving the car will. Since bikes have the same laws as cars, make sure to tell them the laws of the road that you are supposed to know in your teen years. 4 years old or 14 you will always be held responsible.

This is a really sad article. She was 87, lived a fairly long life. What a weird thing the family is doing to these children. How many things do you remember from when you were 4. Bet those children never ride a bike ever again. 

Smithwick --- 16 years ago -

NO I don't hold her accountable for her actions.

I hope this works out for you! 

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

NO I don't hold her accountable for her actions.

I hope this works out for you!


It works great she's only 11 months old, so NO she doesn't know better. That is where TEACHING comes in. 

AmandaNicole19 --- 16 years ago -

a 4year old is too young to sue. That's stupid. If anything sue the mother. 

Smithwick --- 16 years ago -

but what was the 87 year old doing with out supervision

Do you supervise your great/grandpatents? Who to say she wasn't walking home from the corner store and stopped in her tracks to let the children ride past, but one of the struck her instead.

AGAIN - Do I honestly think that a jury of 12 people will come to finding holding the child responisable no, but the mother maybe 

Smithwick --- 16 years ago -

It works great she's only 11 months old, so NO she doesn't know better. That is where TEACHING comes in.

OK, if you had a 4 year old would you hold them accountable for their actions? 

Smithwick --- 16 years ago -

If anything sue the mother

Her estate sued the children and their mothers 

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

OK, if you had a 4 year old would you hold them accountable for their actions?

It would really depend on what they did.

Who to say she wasn't walking home from the corner store and stopped in her tracks to let the children ride past, but one of the struck her instead.

Who's to say that the 4 year old didn't loose control of her bike? Also who's to say that the little old woman didn't walk out in front of the kids and they couldn't stop in time. 

Smithwick --- 16 years ago -

Who's to say that the 4 year old didn't loose control of her bike? Also who's to say that the little old woman didn't walk out in front of the kids and they couldn't stop in time.

All of your questions are valid, that is why a jury of 12 men/women will decide the outcome. 

dontyaknow --- 16 years ago -

Wow... I think those people should feel ashamed trying to sue little kids... I think they just money for the death of the old woman... 

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

Wow... I think those people should feel ashamed trying to sue little kids... I think they just money for the death of the old woman...

I agree but if you look her up her husband was a lawyer and her son is also a lawyer. 

AINOKEA --- 16 years ago -

I definitely hold my children accountable for the things they do. My children are 3 and 2 and they DO know the difference between right and wrong. However I don't agree with suing them. I can't say for the most part I agree with the suing of the mother's either. Its not like they told their children to run the woman over and stood there laughing as they did it. Its just my opinion though. 

VelvetFire --- 16 years ago -

However I don't agree with suing them. I can't say for the most part I agree with the suing of the mother's either. Its not like they told their children to run the woman over and stood there laughing as they did it. Its just my opinion though.

Agreed. I don't think it was anyone's fault. Just a tragic accident. 

VelvetFire --- 16 years ago -

I am sure the children involved are already traumatized enough, that they would be forced to relive it over and over again, and have their names put out there is just wrong. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground