The best one is the one that fits him, keeps him rearfacing, fits in your car, and is easy for you to use properly. I personally always go for Britax but lately a lot of other manufacturers are also making good car seats.
I believe at a year and over 20 pounds he can be forward facing. With my first one thats the info i got at the car seat installation thing at the fire station.
Rf is 1 and 20 lbs... they(apa) say its safer to 2and 40 but my dad who is a police sgt said that kids get injured regardless... RF or FF...and that its all a personal choice. but the LAW is 1 and 20#... my Daughter is 15 months and 25l lbs
The why would the manufactures put forward facing 1 year old,20 pounds. I dont know about all 2 year olds but my 2 year old wouldnt fit in a rear facing carseat. To me he would get more hurt in rear facing if we were in an accident due to the fact his feet and legs would be in the seat. That makes no scenes..
I'm not going to get into a RF v. FF debate with people because it's pointless. As a parent, you make the decision on how to raise and what to do with your own child. I do recommend at LEAST reading up on the new AAP recommendations and going from there :)
@Cookie-There no debate. every parent is diffrent. My son is way to tall to be rear facing. Also i go by the car seat manufactures.
Hmm, worked for me. Not sure why it did not for you?
You are free to make any legal choice you want as the parent. You asked why though and I'm answering. Your reasoning for why not to rear-face is based on an incorrect premise, but if you want to turn your child around at a year that is fine and your right to do. :)
We have two britax marathon car seats and love them. We have nothing to compare to though bec they have always been in britax seats. they are easy to use and they are well worth the money.
I have a alpha omega elite carseat that I bought from the MCX on base. I would check online at the aafes.com website before buying one in town. They might have what you are looking for at a lower price and tax free.
FF vs RF - I switched my daughter over at a year and 20# too but I think with my boys I might wait longer. One reason I switched her so soon was because she got too big for her infant seat and the car seat I bought to replace it was too big to fit correctly RF. I could have returned it, but I didn't. So I turned her around because it was safer for her carseat to be correctly FF than incorrectly RF. With my twins, I got smart and bought smaller carseats so they fit correctly RF. So they will stay there a bit longer. There are a lot of reasons that RF is better. Even with longer legs. I have seen many a video and pictures on advocates for RF websites and these kids are like 3 and 4 years old and still RF! The kids are fine with their legs up like that. It's not uncomfortable for them. My one thing that I know for sure is a good reason to keep them RF for as long as possible is this::
How many adults do you know that have gotten whiplash from not being able to control their necks when they were in an accident? You might not know many, but it is a VERY common incident in a crash. Now, think of how many years an adult has had to gain neck muscle....a LOT compared to the 1 year or 2 years a toddler has had....so think of how hard it will be for them to control their neck if you were to slam on your breaks or be going 65 mph and come to a sudden stop because you hit someone in front of you....Their head is going to fly forward and could *possibly* snap their neck in half. That is a risk you (and myself for my 3 yr old) are taking every time we put them in the car. If they were RF they would still have some impact and could *possibly* get hurt, but the effects would be a lot less than if she had been FF.
ETA: As for following the manufacturers instead of the AAP or whoever, that is your choice, but the manufacturers only put what they are required by law. It doesn't mean it's the best or safest choice. I mean think about it...back when most of us were babies, there probably weren't ANY carseat laws.....that doesn't mean it was safe for us to go riding around without a car seat....ya know?
As for following the manufacturers instead of the AAP or whoever, that is your choice, but the manufacturers only put what they are required by law. It doesn't mean it's the best or safest choice. I mean think about it...back when most of us were babies, there probably weren't ANY carseat laws.....that doesn't mean it was safe for us to go riding around without a car seat....ya know? x2 We have a Britax Advocate and love it. Our little girl is still rear facing at 14 months and she's tall for her age. She still has plenty of room to comfortably be RR so she will stay that way as long as we can. Think about how adults get whiplash when they get rear ended in a parking lot. Rear ending accidents are the most common forms of vehicle accidents and what would give an adult whiplash could internally decapitate a baby. It's not worth the risk to me just to have her seat forward.