Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Can I punch that guy in the face?

who's talking here?

O G docswife 5
EastCoast 2
Donny 1
Giggle Butt 1
SusseTraume 1
Tits McGee 2
Colonel LizZoo 7
Taminator 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tits McGee --- 15 years ago -

NBC VIDEO

"If everyone asked for a dog, we'd have 15 dogs in the classroom."

Well, SIR, this is why you screen the NECESSITY of the animal in the classroom.
If I was the mother, I would trust the dog, WHO HAS BEEN TRAINED TO ACCURATELY AND EFFECTIVELY ADDRESS THE PROBLEM, more than I would a teacher in charge of 20 other children.
What is your opinion? 

Colonel LizZoo --- 15 years ago -

I didn't watch the video (just saw the title of it). Isn't the dog just considered a service animal? I didn't think they could do that. I agree, we should punch that guy! 

Tits McGee --- 15 years ago -

I didn't watch the video (just saw the title of it). Isn't the dog just considered a service animal? I didn't think they could do that. I agree, we should punch that guy!

The dog IS a service animal, so I'm not seeing where a schoolboard can override the law.
But, however, they are doing just that.
I want to give the mother, son and dog a hug and then give the schoolboard director a glass sandwich. 

Colonel LizZoo --- 15 years ago -

It's absolutely ridiculous!!! 

O G docswife --- 15 years ago -

As someone who has seizures, I can say those dogs are invaluable to the people that use them. The dog can sense when the person is going to have a seizure and alert the person so that they have enough time to move to a safe place. There is no teacher that could sense that unless he had an aid that sat with him the entire day, and was trained to look for signs. I want to punch that man in the face also lol! 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

Indeed/Agreed Lacy!

and yes you can punch him and leave a bruise. 

SusseTraume --- 15 years ago -

I work with autistic kids everyday. There are not enough words to describe how animals are helpful to these kids, whether they be service dogs or therapy animals. I see kids who never smile light up when they're around a dog or a horse. Kids who go home and have nothing to talk about thats comparable to their siblings can talk about how the horse "listend" to them while they were riding it. Kids who refuse to be touched allow animals to snuggle with them and it opens so many doors. I realize this dog is a service dog, but the mom is 100% right, taking away something that works from an autisitc kid is regressive. 

Colonel LizZoo --- 15 years ago -

Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Administrative Center
5775 Osceola Trail
Naples, FL 34109
Telephone (239) 377-0001
Fax (239) 377-0206
webmaster@collier.k12.fl.us

In case anyone else wants to contact this school board to push for them to allow the service animal in the classroom... :) (I'm writing a letter.) 

O G docswife --- 15 years ago -

Thank you so much Liz, I will be forwarding this on to the OC Epilepsy Alliance, and San Diego society also. Hopefully we can light a fire under this school boards asss! 

Colonel LizZoo --- 15 years ago -

You bet! I find this to be outrageous. I don't know why, but it's really got me angry. I have absolutely no personal connection to this, heck, I don't even know anyone with epilepsy, but it just incenses me that they can deny this child the quality of care they need/deserve. 

Giggle Butt --- 15 years ago -

I was in class when the girl in front of me started having a seizure. The teacher yelled at her for goofing off. I yelled back to get the school nurse. Dumb butt! 

O G docswife --- 15 years ago -

EPilepsy, and seizure disorders have a bad rap to say the least. People are really clueless as how to help a person having a seizure. November was Epilepsy awareness month, and my mom and I volunteered at a hospital to help the public better understand the disorder. These dogs save lives, and for them to just dismiss what the dog does is awful. There are currently 2.3 million people in the US with Epilepsy, yet most people do not know proper seizure first aid. 

Colonel LizZoo --- 15 years ago -

Epilepsy, yet most people do not know proper seizure first aid. 

I'm guilty of this. (I'm going to google it though....at least I could have a basic idea of what to do) 

Taminator --- 15 years ago -

The dog can sense when the person is going to have a seizure and alert the person so that they have enough time to move to a safe place. There is no teacher that could sense that unless he had an aid that sat with him the entire day, and was trained to look for signs

My mom has epilepsy and a service dog and he cant tell when she is about to have an episode...yes there are warning signs but they dont come every time! Most of the time her attitude changes, she gets cranky, and starts moving things into different places, I can usually tell so I wouldnt see why a teacher wouldnt. My mom goes almost everywhere with her dog but she never makes a fuss when they ask her to leave him. Im not saying the school is right because it has to be different with a child that also has other medical conditions but I just thought it was weird that you said a dog can sense a seizure (not saying your wrong either just saying I have never heard of it and I grew up around epilepsy) 

Colonel LizZoo --- 15 years ago -

(Turns out I did know the first aid. lol It's been so long, I assumed things had changed, but nope. I'm glad I googled) 

Colonel LizZoo --- 15 years ago -

I just thought it was weird that you said a dog can sense a seizure (not saying your wrong either just saying I have never heard of it and I grew up around epilepsy) 

I believe some can (according to the national geographic website I just read). Perhaps it's dependent on the type of seizure, the dog and the patient? In the video, they said that dog can sense it. 

O G docswife --- 15 years ago -

They believe that some dogs may pick up a scent that forewarns of a seizure, or that it senses a subtly that people sometimes can't detect. Not every seizure dog can do this though.

Depending on the type of seizure also, someone mY show signs that most people would miss. I have had seizures in front of everyone in my family that nobody has known about. But I am sure if they were really watching me they could pick up a small sign, and these dogs that can sense it are awesome. Especially for people that live alone. 

EastCoast --- 15 years ago -

O.M.G. As a mom of a child who has severe seizures and can die from them, Im fuming. To rely on the teachers and staff to react appropriately in the moment is asking too much. People, by nature, do not do well with children having a seizure.

Just a week ago, my baby was in daycare (with a qualified daycare provider who has a daughter with SEVERE epilepsy) and he seized. She absoluetly froze. I walked in and she was 1-holding onto him and 2- holding him on his back. The paramedics were noticably shaken and freaking out. I mean, shouting and grabbing their heads trying to figure out what to do. The dog will never waiver in his reaction. Ever. He has absolutely, undoubtedly already saved that child's life.

Tammy, you being able to pick up on your moms ques and a teacher picking up on a students are completely different. 100%. I will never trust a teacher to react to my son appropriately. I wouldnt place that burden on her/him. As soon as he's old enough to hold the leash, you can bet your last dollar he will have a seizure dog. We may even use our Dane. She seems to be very in touch with him and subtle changes leading up to his seizures. 

EastCoast --- 15 years ago -

Lacy, yes! You may punch him!! If everyone NEEDED a dog, then YES you should have 50 dogs in the d*mned classroom! What a jerk! That poor mom! 

O G docswife --- 15 years ago -

This was what was going on in 1954 in this very country:

*Nineteen states have sterilization laws specifically applicable to epileptics; 17 forbid them marriage (six states make marriage a crime); 16 refuse to let them drive.


i would be locked up in a looney bin. how dare i have 2 kids, and a husband, and drive a nice car! there was still a state in the 1980's that was doing sterilizations on epileptics. it makes me want to vomit. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground