Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Can you substitute Ovaltine for Hersheys cocoa?

who's talking here?

B*Bright 1
Oliver Clothesoff 1
Vintage_Girl 2
Abra 15
MomOf2inCali 1
saywhat?! 1
~Lauren~ 3
Patrice 1
Tammie 1
SuKitty 2
His Princess 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Yes I googled. I am not getting a definite answer. 

B*Bright --- 15 years ago -

thats a good question...I have no idea but the only time i ever tried substituting something (used applesauce instead of vegetable oil....per google) and it was HORRIBLE!!!!

I no longer substitute...LOL. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

I no longer substitute...LOL.

I don't want to drive all the way to base for cocoa, lol. I happen to just have Ovaltine.

used applesauce instead of vegetable oil....per google)

I substitued applesauce once for shortening. The taste was ok but the texture was off. 

SuKitty --- 15 years ago -

I think So! I grew up drinking Ovaltine ;) 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

I think So! I grew up drinking Ovaltine ;)

This is THE chance to prove to my husband I can bake lol. I don't want to mess it up. 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

Oooh - you are talking about for BAKING. I might not substitute that. It will probably taste a lot different...

ETA: Abra - where do you live? I will be out and about tomorrow doing Christmas shopping...if you are not WAAY out of the way - I can pick some up for you and drop it off. [This is me assuming y'all are at Pendleton - lol] 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Another question. When a recipe calls for honey does it mean artifical like the one in the little bear jar OR the all natural like the one with the honey comb inside? 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Oooh - you are talking about for BAKING. I might not substitute that. It will probably taste a lot different

Google says it will be slightly sweeter? But everywhere else just suggests substituting is fine but no real opinions. 

saywhat?! --- 15 years ago -

Another question. When a recipe calls for honey does it mean artifical like the one in the little bear jar OR the all natural like the one with the honey comb inside?



The one in the little bear jar is still honey. It will work just fine. It does not have to have a honey comb inside it to be real honey. lol 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

The one in the little bear jar is still honey. It will work just fine. It does not have to have a honey comb inside it to be real honey. lol

Yeah I know but my mom has a big pet peeve when it comes to honey, she doesn't like the little bear, lol. I've taken after her so I've never tried it.

The honey comb one is too damn expensive to use it all in one recipe. 

SuKitty --- 15 years ago -

I like the taste of ovaltine better than cocoa ;) 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

ETA: Abra - where do you live? I will be out and about tomorrow doing Christmas shopping...if you are not WAAY out of the way - I can pick some up for you and drop it off. [This is me assuming y'all are at Pendleton - lol]


LOL thanks but I hardly think 29 Palms is on your way, unless you want to head out to Vegas? 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

Google says it will be slightly sweeter? But everywhere else just suggests substituting is fine but no real opinions.

Yeea...I saw that too. No one seems to have a tried and true answer. The one I found on Yahoo answers - well...the OP seemed kind of immature, so I would not trust their judgment. Lol. 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

LOL thanks but I hardly think 29 Palms is on your way, unless you want to head out to Vegas?

ROFL! Yeea - no. :) Sorry ma'am! 

His Princess --- 15 years ago -

Another question. When a recipe calls for honey does it mean artifical like the one in the little bear jar OR the all natural like the one with the honey comb inside?




I thought the one in the little bear was honey!?! 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

I like the taste of ovaltine better than cocoa ;)

I think I am going to brave it. I wanted it to be just right. He is coming home and we missed his bday. I can always buy one if it's not good lol. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

thought the one in the little bear was honey!?!

It is. It has artificial flavoring though. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Yeea...I saw that too. No one seems to have a tried and true answer. The one I found on Yahoo answers - well...the OP seemed kind of immature, so I would not trust their judgment. Lol.

LOL. I did notice PU isn't the only catty place. I went on a recipe site and this girl went CRAZY mad b/c someone reated her recipe a 1 star LOL. 

His Princess --- 15 years ago -

thought the one in the little bear was honey!?!

It is. It has artificial flavoring though.



Really. I need to check so I can start buying pure honey. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Really. I need to check so I can start buying pure honey.

I've never tried it ( the bear) but Pure honey can get pricey if you use it alot. 

Patrice --- 15 years ago -

When I was out a 29 (were talking 6 years ago), on Highway 62 right after you turn off of Adobe rd (heading towards Yucca Valley). There used to be a little organic/natural food store. I know you don't want to pay a lot of money for one recipe, but if you use honey fairly often. They may have some that is produced in the area. Local honey is suppossed to be good for you, especially if you suffer from allergies. Something about the pollen the bee collects being from the area you live can help make you immune from allergies.

I agree though, don't think the Ovaltine will make much of a difference. I have substituted hershey's syrup for unsweetend cocoa powder before. 

MomOf2inCali --- 15 years ago -

For unsweetened baking cocoa NO dont do it. If the rcp calls for sweetened cocoa like you would make chocolate milk with yeah go for it. As for honey if you tasted the "bear" in a blind taste test you would probably never know the difference. We buy local honey and my daughter eats like 1/2 teaspoon every other day. Its made with local pollen from Temecula so it helps build up immunity to allergies. You CAN taste the difference in that one. Its kinda yucky lol. 

Vintage_Girl --- 15 years ago -

For unsweetened baking cocoa NO dont do it.

Exactly. Most recipes call for regular unsweetened cocoa so using Ovaltine would be completely different. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

regular unsweetened cocoa

It doesn't say unsweetened. I went to the grocery store here and the small box of cocoa is 6 bucks! I am going to try the ovaltine. I'll let ya'll know how it turns out :) 

Oliver Clothesoff --- 15 years ago -

I like honey. But everytime I eat it my mind goes
to it's bee regurgitation. And I can't do it. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Ew, I'm going to pretend I didn't read that. 

Tammie --- 15 years ago -

Hersheys cocoa is unsweetened, ovaltine is heavily sweetened. Maybe if you cut way back on the amount of sugar called for in the recipe it will work, otherwise, you are going to end up with something very sweet with not as much chocolate flavor as you'd like. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Maybe if you cut way back on the amount of sugar called for in the recipe it will work

Yes I did. I cut down on the sugar that went into the cake and added just a bit more water.

It came out good! Not as pretty and glassy as the picture. The pic shows it made with the cocoa which is obviously a darker color when mixed but it tastes great. 

Vintage_Girl --- 15 years ago -

I'm glad it worked out for you! 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Thanks :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground