Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

5-Year-Old Could Face Murder Charge...

who's talking here?

MylilZombie 2
Skittles 1
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 3
LoveMyBoys! 1
MissMaggy 1
JAZZ 6
Hollyer Than Thou 1
Momzilla 1
whatevergirl2 2
MissTexas 2
Karen25 2
Alessandra 1
MrsDude 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

Not sure if this has already been posted. This is so horrible...

Link 

MissMaggy --- 15 years ago -

Murder, no. I don't think a five year old understands the concept of death and all that. The teenager however will probably end up with manslaughter... Or the parents possibly. That's just really sad. 

Alessandra --- 15 years ago -

Wow... this is really hard either way you look at it. 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

Criminal law was my thing in college. No way will this stand. 

MissTexas --- 15 years ago -

Wow. Maybe she saw it on tv? Or it was a learned behavior? That's horrible, i wonder how they are going to handle it. 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

Murder, no. I don't think a five year old understands the concept of death and all that. The teenager however will probably end up with manslaughter... Or the parents possibly. That's just really sad.

I agree 

MylilZombie --- 15 years ago -

i wanna know why 2 parents left a 16 yr old with a learning disability alone with 3 kids to watch? just wondering its a sad situation all around 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

I know MyMonkey...I'm not understanding why it doesn't say stupid parents charged with murder instead of innocent 5 year old who doesn't understand the concept of death charged with murder! 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

There is a huge process that will have to be done. A child has to know the difference between right or wrong and understand it. There is more but my tired brain isn't processing. No way will a 5 yr old go up for murder.

Plus each degree of murder has certain criteria that must be present. Say 1st degree murder has to be premeditated. Ect. My criminal law class instructor made us memorize these verbatim. (the good old days). 

MrsDude --- 15 years ago -

so, why didn't the 16 year old wake up when the baby was crying? i'm sorry, but i don't understand why nothing about her was mentioned. and that the baby wasn't found until the parents came home?? did the teenager ever wake up, or did she just not check on all the kids? 

Momzilla --- 15 years ago -

I feel really terrible for the victim's family- no one should have to go through this. But, I'm also a little shocked at the fact that the father was asking for donations in fb..?? I can understand someone looking for donations through a memorial page or something. Maybe it's just me, but I think I would be much too distraught to be on the internet. 

MylilZombie --- 15 years ago -

I know MyMonkey...I'm not understanding why it doesn't say stupid parents charged with murder instead of innocent 5 year old who doesn't understand the concept of death charged with murder! 

EXACTLY I dont get it, i really hope they get to the bottom of it b/c the 16 yr old shouldn't have been left alone with those kids in the 1st place 

MissTexas --- 15 years ago -

This is just a hot mess from every aspect. That poor baby only got to experience 18months of life. Ahh I'm off this thread, it's just such a sad thing. I hope the family gives him a nice burial. 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

I feel bad for the baby. I also find myself feeling really sad for that five year old. Right now that child is probably confused and doesn't understand, but one day will have to live with the fact that she killed her cousin. What a horrible burden to carry for the rest of her life. 

LoveMyBoys! --- 15 years ago -

The parents should be charged with unattended juveniles and held responsible.

Can you imagine what that 5 year old is going to have to grow up with? 

Karen25 --- 15 years ago -

How do they know the 16 yr old was sleeping the whole time 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

How do they know the 16 yr old was sleeping the whole time

I'm guessing they are just going by what she told them. I know it read that the 5yr old admitted to doing that to the baby to stop him from crying. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 15 years ago -

The five year old sounds like a little sociopath to me. Or at least the start of one... 

Karen25 --- 15 years ago -

Ooo my gosh its just sad 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 15 years ago -

The 5 yr old doesn't sound like a sociopath to me. She sounds like a kid who really just thought that holding him under water would make him stop crying. I doubt she understood the finality of the action. The fact that she readily told investigators that she was angry with him crying and took him in there bc she thought it would make him quiet shows that. She didn't seem to be hiding. In her mind it seems like she thought holding someone under water was a real way to get them to shut up. I don't think she realized it could lead to death. She probably has had a sibling hold her under water before or something in the pool and knew it makes her shut up. Ya know? I don't think she had intent to kill.
Why you would leave a 16yr old with disabilities home to watch a baby is my question. Granted they didn't elaborate on her disability, so that really could be anything. She might have been someone who could watch a kid, but she was being irresponsible. Either way I think the parents or the 16yr old in charge need to be looked at for the very least child neglect and perhaps manslaughter etc. 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

Granted they didn't elaborate on her disability, so that really could be anything.

I am wondering what her disabilities are too. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 15 years ago -

I am wondering what her disabilities are too.


I think it makes a huge difference. If she had some kind of slight disability that doesnt effect her as far as brain development etc then I think she should be held responsible. It is totally legal to leave a 16yr old home with siblings to babysit for several hours. In that instance the 16yr old is held responsible and the parents do not have legal fault. If she was not fit to actually handle her own well being on her own, let alone another childs, then her parents should be held responsible for neglect etc. That is the same thing if they are leaving the little kids home alone. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 15 years ago -

Oh...and can I just say I am kind of disgusted by hearing that the dad is on FB asking for money. Of all the things to be worrying about, collecting money is not one of them.
Sure I get that you might not have the money for a burial or something, but pander to your own neighborhood or church or something. When you are the one who left your kids alone and it is bc of your authority that the child is dead, I do not think it is right to pander and ask for handouts like some sort of tragedy that you couldn't help just happened. Whether you are not legally in trouble or not, it is still your job to take care of your kids. You should have packed the baby up in the car with you to pick up whoever. 

Skittles --- 15 years ago -

Wow, this is really sad. I will say however, I agree the 5 year old shouldn't be charged with murder. I think the child should be put into state custody and lots of councilling given to her. I think there should be some child neglect charges on the parents and something along those lines of the 16 year old only after they have ruled out that the 16 year old didn't "convince" an innocent 5 year old to do her dirty work. If this is truly just a 5 year old thinking they know a solution and what not then I don't think there should be any murder charges on anyone. I think it should just be charges of child neglect and whatever else along those lines. Children are impressionable and I'd hate for this case to open up with information that the 16 year old bribed the 5 year old to do it. I have a 6 year old and I can tell you that would never be something he would suggest or think about. Maybe what this 5 year old did is/was learned behavior (I think that should be investigated as well)..but I know looking at my son and his healthy happy and being of sound mind if a baby cries he looks for a binkie, a bottle, a toy...or he tells me "mom, I just don't know what baby wants". I know 'cause my friend had her baby at our house all the time and I always thought it was so cute how he would try (he has two younger sisters of his own too). This is why I'm not convinced that it was the 5 year old's idea. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground