Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Question :)

who's talking here?

Abra 1
Vanbam 1
~Lauren~ 1
Taminator 1
SinCityGRL 1
DoctorDonna 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1
southernheart88 1
BadMomma2 1
AJx2 1
whatevergirl2 4
Scrappy 7
ooorah69P 2
Doo Schnugget 4
CaNi 1
me just me 1
foxed 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Question :)

Do you think anyone who is in Jail/Prison/Correctional Facilities(or anything of the like), deserve any rights? No matter what they are there for, murder, drug posession, etc. Personally, I think they do not deserve any rights. They gave up their rights when they killed another person, robbed a store, and sold illegal drugs.

Yes Vote
 
 14.0% (7)
No Vote
 
 28.0% (14)
Depends(explain) Vote
 
 54.0% (27)
Other Vote
 
 4.0% (2)
Abra --- 15 years ago -

Explain yourself lol

I don't think they have the right to certain privledges like buying a home while incarcarated (sp)


but I do think they have the rights any other human being has to be treated with physical respect. 

SinCityGRL --- 15 years ago -

I think they deserve basic things... to be treated fairly (in terms of prision treatment, medical treatment, food, etc).

I don't think they deserve much above that. 

ooorah69P --- 15 years ago -

No rights, at all. Not to education, television, air conditioning or respect.

I like how a Sheriff in Maricopa County has them sleeping in military tents, they have to pay for their meals, no cigarettes etc. I think they should be treated like dog poop on the bottom of your shoe. They had no respect or consideration for the law(s) so they shouldn't recieve any back.


He also makes them wear pink jumpsuits. If they can't pay for their food they get a plain baloney sandwich, at least they did a couple years ago.

I like his style.

I think inmates deserve basic human rights, food, shelter, clothing, medical care if needed. But that's it. 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

Everyone deserves basic.human rights. Other then that, not much else. 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

I think they deserve basic things... to be treated fairly (in terms of prision treatment, medical treatment, food, etc).

This.

Though I KIND of like how tent city is run...those COs are freakin' smart (I watched an episode of Lockdown with tent city). 

ooorah69P --- 15 years ago -

I like his style.

Me too. I love how he brought back the chain-gang.


I forgot about the chain gang. Nothing wrong with makin' them work.

Too bad the liberals are out for the Sheriff's blood. Hope he continues to tell'em to F*** off. 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

I think they should have basic human rights, but I don't believe they should be able to vote, own handguns, etc.

I do that Maricopa's style too. 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

Let's deprive inmates/convicts of everything then release these wild beasts into society when they are done serving their sentences. We could do a live experiment on how well that will go over.

I worked in corrections and a work release. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 15 years ago -

Eh, I think basic human rights should be allotted, but nothing more. They are in prison for a reason and do not deserve and luxuries whatsoever. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Depends on what you are talking about. I used to think they shouldn't have tvs, sports, or anything fun but after being a correctional officer for six years I'm here to tell you that that isn't realistic. They need something to do or all they will do is fight and pretty much go crazy. Not saying somedont deserve that however it would make for a very dangerous situation for the officers. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

i think every person is entitled to basic rights - sometimes good people do bad things, doesnt mean they should be caged like animals with no voice

of course some people are a waste of space and air for all the harm and misery they have inflicted - and for these i believe in the death penalty once they are convicted 

Vanbam --- 15 years ago -

i think every person is entitled to basic rights - sometimes good people do bad things, doesnt mean they should be caged like animals with no voice

x2 my brother is in prison for reasons that none of you need to know, and he deserves every right to have a voice.

now on the other hand there are guys in there that are complete dirt bags and deserve to be hung by there man parts.

so i think it depends on the convict. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Depends on what you are talking about. I used to think they shouldn't have tvs, sports, or anything fun but after being a correctional officer for six years I'm here to tell you that that isn't realistic. They need something to do or all they will do is fight and pretty much go crazy. Not saying somedont deserve that however it would make for a very dangerous situation for the officers. 

x2, but really, I mean people make mistakes. Say you get in a car accident, the other person dies and you are convicted of vehicular manslaughter.. even if it was the other person's fault. The justice system isn't perfect, many are wrongly imprisoned. It could happen to anyone, and being treated like a dog is only going to make you want to cause trouble. Like WEG said, what is the point of giving them nothing and then turning them loose on society with no resources whatsoever?

I think they deserve the right to an education, religious services, communication with family, food, shelter, clothing, and the right to work. I think they should earn their extracurricular rights like TV, playing games and sports, books, etc. But most of the time, those things ARE earned, and taken away for bad behavior. They need to be encouraged, seek therapy, etc so that they can become a useful member of society in the future. Taking away their rights would make the prison system 1000x worse.. and don't think for a second it would make them not want to go back. 

southernheart88 --- 15 years ago -

The whole being treated like dog poop really?? all of them even ones that like you said are there for small crimes ? That seems a little unfair. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

As far as the right to work that depends on the nature of the crime. Some inmates can't be trusted with jobs inside the facility. Depends on what custody level they are as well. And then jail is totally different from prison. 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

I think it's easy for people to pass judgement on inmate rights when they have never directly worked with the inmate population. Go work at a Pen for awhile then come back with a more educated view. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I agree weg lol. I used to be like that until I actually worked there. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

As far as the right to work that depends on the nature of the crime. Some inmates can't be trusted with jobs inside the facility. Depends on what custody level they are as well. And then jail is totally different from prison.

definitely, I think all of the rights should be given based on the security of the facility, the record of the inmate, past behavior, etc. But taking it all away regardless is wrong and would only cause more problems. 

me just me --- 15 years ago -

No rights, at all. Not to education, television, air conditioning or respect.

I like how a Sheriff in Maricopa County has them sleeping in military tents, they have to pay for their meals, no cigarettes etc. I think they should be treated like dog poop on the bottom of your shoe. They had no respect or consideration for the law(s) so they shouldn't recieve any back.

you took the words right out of my mouth! 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

I think it's easy for people to pass judgement on inmate rights when they have never directly worked with the inmate population

True.. my brother has been in prison/jail off and on for the last 15 years. I can honestly say that taking away his rights would only make his situation worse. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I worked at two different prisons and one had no ac, it was a punishment to the officers as well as the inmates. Boy I'd love to see some of y'all work a twelve hour shift in a place that is so hot it smells like a$$ and feet not to mention after the first hour you could wring your uniform out because you are drenched. 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

Scrappy- I worked in a med security coed prison. Boy was that fun. Lol.

I think a lot of people don't realize how a prison functions. You get told when it's time to eat, shower, go to classes, the doctor ect. You don't get to decide you want to sleep in and not show up. You get told which classes and programs you have to attend. Everything is done on a movement schedule. There is set times of the hour inmates can go from one place to the other. (at least there was a movement schedule for med security).

Ever tried inmate food? I have. I'd rather starve. 

Taminator --- 15 years ago -

My father is in prison (for a horrible crime) and I dont think he deserves any rights what so ever! I dont think any maximum security prisons need any kind of rights expect for basic walfare!

As for regular prison with theft or small fights...everyone changes and and they are humans just like everyone else. Nothing wrong with them getting a job, good food, and a tv 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

It's funny people complain about them having tvs. They can only have the itty bitty ones. It's not like they get cable in each cell. It's a staticy reception, black and white usually and about 2-4 channels. Lol. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Scrappy- I worked in a med security coed prison. Boy was that fun. Lol.

I think a lot of people don't realize how a prison functions. You get told when it's time to eat, shower, go to classes, the doctor ect. You don't get to decide you want to sleep in and not show up. You get told which classes and programs you have to attend. Everything is done on a movement schedule. There is set times of the hour inmates can go from one place to the other. (at least there was a movement schedule for med security).

Ever tried inmate food? I have. I'd rather starve. 


I worked at a medium prison that had some maximum in seg. The one I worked at was a mens prison. You couldnt pay me enough to work at a womans prison lol. The other one I worked at was a minimum unit. That was the one with no AC and it sucked lol 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

My father is in prison (for a horrible crime) and I dont think he deserves any rights what so ever! I dont think any maximum security prisons need any kind of rights expect for basic walfare!

As for regular prison with theft or small fights...everyone changes and and they are humans just like everyone else. Nothing wrong with them getting a job, good food, and a tv 



I think all people regardless of their crimes are human beings that should be treated with respect regardless. To judge is not our right or our place as humans. Their judgement day will come, we should leave it to someone who has that right. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

oh and according to the prison system they are not there to be punished...they are there to be rehabilitated blah blah more times than not it doesnt work. just sayin lol 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

and I say that because the majority of medium custody inmates are habitual felons. I wish I would have kept count of how many got out and in less than a month were right back in. 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

I don't blindly support all the laws that we have. I think some of them are total bullsh:t. We should re-evaluate that whole mess before we start throwing people into pits.
But I DO think the prison system needs a hard reckoning all around. 

CaNi --- 15 years ago -

No rights, at all. Not to education, television, air conditioning or respect

I believe this is wrong!! The recidivism rate is alarmingly high and what should be done in prisons is not being done. Some of the inmates will return to society and it should be there goal to return a viable citizen citizen to society not a harden criminal. Lets think of this question or discussion....Joe Bob at the age of 9 was playing with his friends outdoors upon the scuffling and playing he critically injured his best friend which in turn later died. Joe Bob was tried as an adult for Manslaughter and sentenced to prison until he was 18. With no education going into the prison system at that age he will never be a viable citizen. Joe Bob was released on his 18th birthday and returned to prison 3 months later. Joe Bob's explanation, he didn't have any skills to get a job and he could not sustain himself in society....So you so NO Education and I have to strongly disagree...This was an actual case but I don't remember the subjects real name. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground