Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

what should i do?

who's talking here?

Mrs AJ 1
Mrs Patch 1
Oliver Clothesoff 2
UnicornsR4Gangstas 1
grantsmommy 4
Barbie 3
Trace 1
SinCityGRL 1
Mrs Westray 1
Pics Photography 1
Turquoise 3
Scrappy 1
YOU MAD BRO 2
LullabiesButterflies 2
Sarah H aka Boot 1
Ta Da 1
foxed 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Turquoise --- 15 years ago -

I asked the hospital not to give my daughter a binky. The next day I found a binky under her when she came from nursery. They apologized but the next day a new nurse brought her she said that nobody informed her abt the no binky thing. Now she is 6 days old and she keeps sucking her fingers, bin, etc. I always notice her making sucking movements and she craves a binky. I'm against the binky and never used it with my first child. My mom says I should give in and acts like I'm torturing her by not doing so. Am I wrong? What's your advice on this situation? Sorry so long. 

Sarah H aka Boot --- 15 years ago -

Do whatever you want :) At only 6 days old she probably doesnt even know what the binky is, shes just sucking. She'll be fine without it :) 

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

don't babies normally do the sucking motion? give her the breast and she will probably just suck for comfort... 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

I thought all babies were born with a natural inclination to want to suck? If you don't want to give it to her, stand your ground. I personally don't have the same opinion you do, but it's your child - no one else's. 

Oliver Clothesoff --- 15 years ago -

We lost a child in my family to sids. As soon as they came out with evidence that Binkies help reduce the risk I was on it like white on rice. 

Mrs Westray --- 15 years ago -

Im actually reading about babies now for school. Infants have a natural urge to suck. I dont have babies but id think since she is so young if you took it she would be fine. 

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

We lost a child in my family to sids. As soon as they came out with evidence that Binkies help reduce the risk I was on it like white on rice. 



yes there was some evidence but if your trying to establish breast feeding binkys can interfere with it.. 

YOU MAD BRO --- 15 years ago -

I don't believe the binky messes with breastfeeding. My daughter breast fed fine with a binky and so did all my friends kids. I swear to much "thought" or "study" goes into some crap. But that's just me. To each there own. 

Oliver Clothesoff --- 15 years ago -

yes there was some evidence but if your trying to establish breast feeding binkys can interfere with it..

Can is the optimal word, not Does. I could give a hoot, until you see the look on a mothers face when she is screaming over her dead child... I am saying my personal experience, I would much rather my child have one.

She on the other hand made express directions to not give her baby one, and they went against it. That in it self would piss me off, but this is also her second child so she should know that it is too soon for the child to be "addicted" to a binky,

Also, I would never give my breast for soothing purposes.... there is nursing and being a human pacifier... no bueno. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

I don't believe the binky messes with breastfeeding. My daughter breast fed fine with a binky and so did all my friends kids

My kids never had a problem either

Oliver hearing the reduce on sids is what sold me on them too 

YOU MAD BRO --- 15 years ago -

Same here Oliver with the SIDS comment.. And it hushed her from colic sometimes lol!! 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

Maybe let her nurse more often or let her suck on your finger


Your child, your choice. Your mom gets to enjoy your kids, not make decisions for you. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

I was against a binky but my little one craved it. She took it off and on for about 3 months. Now she wont go near one. lol 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

Your child, your choice. Your mom gets to enjoy your kids, not make decisions for you.

lol I would hate to hear what my Mom would say if I said something like that to her. 

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

Can is the optimal word, not Does. I could give a hoot, until you see the look on a mothers face when she is screaming over her dead child... I am saying my personal experience, I would much rather my child have one
yea its all preference, they say it can interfere but im pretty sure ill use one...i was just saying.. i do know the benefits of one but some people choose not to use one until bf is established.. 

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

Lol you dont really get the choice, some babies hate them (my son!) It would be nice if they would all take one! 


yea i know, but once breastfeeding is established i might offer him one.. 

Turquoise --- 15 years ago -

I'm nursing 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

yea i know, but once breastfeeding is established i might offer him one..

I think it's easier than a bottle, the other day I tried to give my son some juice in a bottle and the kid acted like I was choking him. 

Turquoise --- 15 years ago -

Also. I understand the research abt SIDS but I never pay too much attention to all those findings. That stuff constantly changes so I try not to get so wrapped up in it. 

UnicornsR4Gangstas --- 15 years ago -

She is too young to crave binkys. Babies have the natural urge to suck. My baby does a suck motion when he sleeps and he really never liked binkys. 

Pics Photography --- 15 years ago -

My parents and I raised my niece...we never gave her the binky. She always would suck on her two middle fingers though. Like make the rock and roll sign. 

SinCityGRL --- 15 years ago -

I've got no advice....as none of my kids used a binkie! 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I nursed and mine used a passy. I find it to be a comfort to them and I personally see nothing wrong with it. But like the others have said, it's your child so do what you want. Two times at the hospital isn't going to make her addicted to one though.

My oldest son wouldn't stop eating when he was full. He would eat until he threw up. All he wanted was the comfort of sucking on something so a passy was actually needed. 

LullabiesButterflies --- 15 years ago -

I agree that your baby is waaaaay too young to be attached to the binky. As for a pacifier messing with a nursing newborn's latch, they've found that to be a myth. Some babies just need to suck more than others. I had a colicky baby who needed the bink from day one because otherwise I was her bink. She would nurse alllll day until I gave her a bink. Even still, she nursed for over a year. 

Mrs AJ --- 15 years ago -

***** 

LullabiesButterflies --- 15 years ago -

O and for the ones who didn't use a binky but sucked on fingers, that's exactly why the binky thing is a myth. Some babies just need to suck so they will suck on something whether it's a binky, they're fingers, a toy, etc. The sucking had nothing to do with their ability to breastfeed. 

Ta Da --- 15 years ago -

Nurses never seem to listen do they??

How dare they be human. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground