Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

small claims

who's talking here?

ALEM 2
Abra 1
Green Chick 9
AJx2 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

Has anyone ever gone to small claims court here in California? Our ex-roomate EAS's on Wednesday and its looking like he is going to try to stick us for the 2k in damages. Im more looking for how it works if he is moving out of the state, and how it works if I dont know his wifes new address. I want to bring them both into court.
I also need to know what kind of documents I need to bring in when I file the claim. I have the quote for the grass and I will be getting one for the window.

Also, does anyone know what I am legally allowed to do with the stuff he never picked up? Is it ours now? 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

Do you have any concrete proof that he caused that much in damages?

The reason I ask is because the landlord/tenant law favors tenants 9 times out of 10. 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

Do you have any concrete proof that he caused that much in damages?

The reason I ask is because the landlord/tenant law favors tenants 9 times out of 10.


I have admissions from him that his dog caused the damages and facebook messages and text messages promising to make the repairs. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

I have admissions from him that his dog caused the damages and facebook messages and text messages promising to make the repairs.

You would have to serve him, and prove that you were able to serve him, which means you will have to pay someone to do it right. In small claims court you can have anyone over 18 serve the person, but if you don't have proof he was served they can throw it out. You will most likely have to serve him in whatever state he is moving to.

If you don't know the address I am not sure you can even file it unless small claims accepts serving via public record in a newspaper as sufficient.

If he doesn't show up after you serving him properly you will win by default. However, the judgement will only go on his credit and unless you can find him to have his wages garnished, you are kind of SOL. 

ALEM --- 15 years ago -

FYI: if you serve them, they touch the papers and drop them on the ground....leave them there hes technically been served! 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

FYI: if you serve them, they touch the papers and drop them on the ground....leave them there hes technically been served!

If you don't have a signature in small claims court it can get thrown out. Our land lord tried to sue us for breaking our lease early. It was a fail because the SCRA protected us. They claimed he had fake orders and tried to serve him while he was deployed. Morons.

Anyway, as I was sitting in court I learned a lot about how many small claims cases get tossed. The only ones who "won" were the ones whose defendant did not show up.

Wait. There was one lady who won some money, but the judge reamed her up one side and down the other then said "good luck trying to collect that" LMAO 

ALEM --- 15 years ago -

i've won both of mine. one showed one didnt. the one who showed, was served, and after he realized what someone served on him, he droped it and left it there. we left and he was still considered served because he was told, touched then dropped. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

the one who showed, was served

Did he not have to sign anything? If he had not shown up you would have had to show a signature proving he had been served. 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

If you don't know the address I am not sure you can even file it unless small claims accepts serving via public record in a newspaper as sufficient.

I know where she works on base. Can I use that address?However, the judgement will only go on his credit and unless you can find him to have his wages garnished, you are kind of SOL.

I have his parents address and that is where he will be living for awhile.

I have a friend who is a Sherriff. Would she be able to serve the wife on base?(the couple is getting divorced but they both lived here and both promised to fix things.) 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

You will most likely have to serve him in whatever state he is moving to.

Yea, I figured that. He plans on working for the police department where he is moving to so I am sure he wont want a judgement against him on his record. I also read on the website I can ask for the fees from having them served in the judgement. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

I know where she works on base. Can I use that address?

Did she live there, or is it him you are wanting to sue?

I have a friend who is a Sherriff. Would she be able to serve the wife on base?(the couple is getting divorced but they both lived here and both promised to fix things.)

I am not sure, but I got a phone call from base legal asking for my husband. When I told them he was deployed they said I didn't have to even go down there to receive the papers if I didn't want to, and that the land lord would have to figure out another way to serve us because if the guy had come to my house I could have had PMO escort him off base. I don't know all the ins and outs, I just know that base legal is where the person has to go in order to try to serve someone on base. You would have to probably go to base legal to find out that kind of information for sure. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

I also read on the website I can ask for the fees from having them served in the judgement.

Yes you can, but you have to pay for it all up front and if you don't win you are out the money you paid to file and serve. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

As far as his things, there is a time limit before you can do anything with it (idk what that would be in cali) but if you do keep it, you can charge him for storage. 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

I want to sue both of them. They both lived here and are still legally married. That way one cant claim its the others responsibility.

I will go to base legal and see the small claims advisor in a few weeks. My work schedule is too packed to do it soon.

We are paying for the repairs up front and are wanting reimbursement. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

As far as his things, there is a time limit before you can do anything with it (idk what that would be in cali) but if you do keep it, you can charge him for storage.

Oh shoot that is right. I do remember reading that the landlord has 21 days from the time the lease ends to give an itemized statement to the tenant, or you cannot legally charge them. Now, since he lived in your home and you have messages from him saying he would pay you that might be totally different. You might not be able to use a lease as anything against him, but you might be able to just show that he destroyed your personal property while staying with you.

I want to sue both of them. They both lived here and are still legally married. That way one cant claim its the others responsibility.

I believe you only have to serve one of them, but they can tell you whether that is true, or not at legal. 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

I was stupid and didn't have them sign a lease. I did give them a notice of eviction and a list of repairs that they did not refute. I may ask the advisor if I even have a chance because its been several months. I was trying to be nice and give them time to get stuff done but I got screwed. Go figure. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

I may ask the advisor if I even have a chance because its been several months. I was trying to be nice and give them time to get stuff done but I got screwed. Go figure.

It might end up in your favor though that you didn't have them sign a lease. If you did, then you would be beyond the time limit to notify them of the repairs. This way they were friends living in your home that destroyed your personal property that they have admitted they did.

Honestly court is such a big PITA that if I were you guys I would send them a certified letter offering them a payment plan and see if that helps. Even if you win in court you might never see the money. It might be more beneficial to try to give them the option of making payments and telling them if they agree to the payment plan and don't keep their end of the deal you will be forced to take it to court.

All that is assuming you have not offered that to them yet, lol, but court is so risky in my opinion. 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

Total repair cost is a little over 3k. Not including the repairs we are not making them do. As of now his parents paid me $1400. I doubt they will do a payment plan in his eyes that's all he owes us. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

Total repair cost is a little over 3k.

Holy crap what the heck did they do? 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

Their dog tore up my backyard and I told them I wanted artificial turf and they said ok. That's 3k right there. Then their dog broke our window, I havnt gotten a quote from that yet.

The things I am not charging them for is permanent staining of the cement from dog crap, fixing the hole in the side of my hot tub, a hole in the bedroom door, scratching the inside and outside of the front door and damage to the side of the house from the dog jumping the fence. Ohh and cleaning the nasty mess they made of their room. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground