Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Tough Question

who's talking here?

petit oiseau 5
xloux 1
CharlieWhiskey 1
Taminator 3
Barbie 3
Just Sayin 2
xVivaLaDollx 1
Scrappy 2
Doo Schnugget 3
ChefsDoItBetter3 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

petit oiseau --- 15 years ago -

Here's the background:

My daughter's biological father has never been in the picture. He's met her maybe 3 times and she has no clue who he is. When I got married, my daughter was young enough and called my ex-husband daddy. Obviously, we've split up. Now, we rarely see him. My daughter still calls him daddy and asks why he doesn't live with us and why he always has to work. He lives about an hour away but we've both moved on with our lives and they don't exactly include the other person.

So my question is, should I tell my daughter that my ex isn't really her dad or should I just answer her questions about him and hope eventually she stops asking about him? She's 4. I just don't even know how to approach this. I feel awful though. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Be honest with her. She should have known from the start that he was not her BIO dad IMO. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

Be honest with her. She should have known from the start that he was not her BIO dad IMO.

x2!
My kid brother is still mad at my Mom (it's been a year) because they told him my step dad was his real dad. What's sad is she would of kept it from him until the slip up from me. 

Taminator --- 15 years ago -

I would think it would be hard for a 4 year old little girl to understand that her dad (well the only dad she has known) is not her dad. Thats a really hard situation and I really hope your find a sensitive way to help her. Maybe you should talk with a councilor or someone first for a little advice 

petit oiseau --- 15 years ago -

She should have known from the start that he was not her BIO dad IMO. 

If I could do it all over again, maybe I would've gone this route. But I didn't get married expecting it to end one day. I felt pretty secure that he'd always be there for me and my daughter. Things just didn't turn out that way. 

xVivaLaDollx --- 15 years ago -


I would think it would be hard for a 4 year old little girl to understand that her dad (well the only dad she has known) is not her dad. Thats a really hard situation and I really hope your find a sensitive way to help her. Maybe you should talk with a councilor or someone first for a little advice 


This ^ 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

If I could do it all over again, maybe I would've gone this route. But I didn't get married expecting it to end one day. I felt pretty secure that he'd always be there for me and my daughter. Things just didn't turn out that way. 

I understand completely, but it's still deceiving to her to not be completely honest with her from the get go. It's a hard situation and I hope that you find a way to explain it to her without breaking her heart, but she needs to know the truth. 

petit oiseau --- 15 years ago -

I think I should tell her as well. I just don't know how to go about it.

ETA: And when would be an appropriate time. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

I think I should tell her as well. I just don't know how to go about it. 

It's going to be hard regardless of how it's done, because she will want to know why he isn't around anymore. Good luck though. 

Taminator --- 15 years ago -

I think I should tell her as well. I just don't know how to go about it.

I would really recommend you talk with a child physiologist first and see if they can give you any advice. 

petit oiseau --- 15 years ago -

I would really recommend you talk with a child physiologist first and see if they can give you any advice. 

I'm going to look into this. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

Have you talked to him to see if maybe he could come see her every once in a while? Even though he isn't the bio father he was still a big part of her life and should be there for her. 

ChefsDoItBetter3 --- 15 years ago -

I was 4 when my mom married my stepdad. Never had a relationship with my bio father until recently but at that age I understood. Im glad I knew the truth orget than living a lie. Especially since my mom and step dad just split and he'll have nothing to do with me anymore because I'm not his. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Taminator --- 29 min ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
I would think it would be hard for a 4 year old little girl to understand that her dad (well the only dad she has known) is not her dad. Thats a really hard situation and I really hope your find a sensitive way to help her. Maybe you should talk with a councilor or someone first for a little advice 


I agree. A four year old won't understand all that. Does your ex not want anything to do with her even though he's been the only dad she ever knew? 

Just Sayin --- 15 years ago -

Even though he isn't the bio father he was still a big part of her life and should be there for her.

Unless he adopted her, which I doubt he did... that will only confuse her further if you're telling her the "step"dad is NOT her father, but then ask him to come around? That's awkward for the guy esp. if he's moved onto someone else. "Hey, my ex-wife wants me to come and visit her daughter since the daughter is confused that I'm her dad and keeps asking about "dad"." It doesn't sound like him and the OP ended things well. 

ChefsDoItBetter3 --- 15 years ago -

I disagree like I said I was 4 when i had a similar situation and I understood and am grateful my mom explained it to me. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

Unless he adopted her, which I doubt he did... that will only confuse her further if you're telling her the "step"dad is NOT her father, but then ask him to come around? That's awkward for the guy esp. if he's moved onto someone else. "Hey, my ex-wife wants me to come and visit her daughter since the daughter is confused that I'm her dad and keeps asking about "dad"." It doesn't sound like him and the OP ended things well.

Over 10 years, a wife and 3 kids later the man I call dad still has a relationship with me. My Mom and him were never married just dated for a while and ended on REALLY bad terms. I guess it just depends on the man. His new (2nd) wife and all of his kids except me as if I was their own family.


Maybe when she's older, just explain there is a difference between a Father and a Dad.

x2 

Just Sayin --- 15 years ago -

Over 10 years, a wife and 3 kids later the man I call dad still has a relationship with me.

But that's him. Everyone is different. If the ex had the same sort of care towards her daughter don't you suppose he would have come around already? Maybe he needs prodding, who knows, but if he turned down the chance he has that right. 

xloux --- 15 years ago -

This is sad. Was your little girl close to him? 

Taminator --- 15 years ago -

Over 10 years, a wife and 3 kids later the man I call dad still has a relationship with me. My Mom and him were never married just dated for a while and ended on REALLY bad terms. I guess it just depends on the man. His new (2nd) wife and all of his kids except me as if I was their own family.

But that's him. Everyone is different. If the ex had the same sort of care towards her daughter don't you suppose he would have come around already? Maybe he needs prodding, who knows, but if he turned down the chance he has that right.

I think she was just saying that some men do have relationships with their step children? 

petit oiseau --- 15 years ago -

Have you talked to him to see if maybe he could come see her every once in a while? Even though he isn't the bio father he was still a big part of her life and should be there for her. 

At first, it seemed like he would still spend time with her. But now, we both have such busy schedules and I think he's adjusted his life to a point that we're not in it anymore. I understand that though.

Unless he adopted her, which I doubt he did... that will only confuse her further if you're telling her the "step"dad is NOT her father, but then ask him to come around? That's awkward for the guy esp. if he's moved onto someone else. "Hey, my ex-wife wants me to come and visit her daughter since the daughter is confused that I'm her dad and keeps asking about "dad"." It doesn't sound like him and the OP ended things well. 

You're right he never adopted her. He does have a gf and she doesn't want him around me, which means around my daughter as well. We are on decent terms though.

This is sad. Was your little girl close to him? 

They were very good together. She still refers to him as daddy and she asks about him and what he's doing. He's moved on though and I guess that means from her too. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Well I don't understand that. You two were a package deal and you don't divorce a child. He was the only dad she ever knew and I'd be so angry and sad if just because you two divorced he decided not to see her anymore. You would think he wouldn't want to do that to her. That's so very sad. Poor girl. 

CharlieWhiskey --- 15 years ago -

My brother was in the same situation. He was with this woman and she had a little girl. The little girl and my brother were very close. She didn't call him daddy because the mom told her right away that she had a bio father somewhere but she was a lot closer to my brother than her father,
Well, my brother and the girl split. It's awkward to go visit the little girl and he misses her A LOT. He even wanted to restart the relationship with the mom just so it would be a good family unit for the daughter but after a couple times of it failing, he had no other option.
Point is, she needs to know that's not her real father and if she asks about her father(s), you can say something like they love you but can't be here. It may be a lie but your daughter doesn't need harsh truth.
She just needs sugar coated truth. She's not an adult, she's a four year old little girl who misses her only known father. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground