Everyone, please take 5 minutes to send a message to your congressman/senators telling them not to take our 20 year retirement! It is on the chopping block, and they will take it away if we do not speak out! I believe they should be cutting welfare or benefits for medical and schooling that illegal aliens receive. If the millions of illegal aliens payed taxes, would we not have a surplus budget? Write your officials before it is too late!
Educate yourself please ! Illegal aliens do not receive welfare benefits only their children. I'm just saying if your going to send a message do it correctly .
Educate yourself please ! Illegal aliens do not receive welfare benefits only their children. I'm just saying if your going to send a message do it correctly .
Read it again southernheart88. It says cut welfare, meaning the aid the government pays to the people not working that could be, OR the things illegal aliens receive ILLEGALLY!
No your statement was specifically aiming at illegal aliens which is fine everyone has the right to their opinion . But as I was saying send the message correctly .
I read it the same way as southernheart, besides I don't think its such a bad plan. My husband is getting out after 8 years so he is now 8 years behind on his retirement because he won't have anything when his EAS comes around. The new plan is more like you will find in the civilian world.
The new plan is more like you will find in the civilian world
Except that they're not civilians. The military should not have the same type of retirement as a person who works a nine to five job, no weekends and is home with their family every night. If they want to start a civilian retirement now with new recruits, go ahead. At least they'll know what they're getting in to. People that are already in should be grandfathered in because it's not what they were promised when they joined.
Except that they're not civilians. The military should not have the same type of retirement as a person who works a nine to five job, no weekends and is home with their family every night. If they want to start a civilian retirement now with new recruits, go ahead. At least they'll know what they're getting in to. People that are already in should be grandfathered in because it's not what they were promised when they joined.
So those of us who didn't do a full 20 years don't deserve anything? We worked weekends, holidays and missed our kids big events too?
My husband is getting out after 8 years so he is now 8 years behind on his retirement because he won't have anything when his EAS comes around. The new plan is more like you will find in the civilian world.
I believe to add the part of the plan to allow military members who do not plan on retiring after 20 years to put money away in a civilian type retirement plan that would transfer in some way to their time after service would be great. What would this plan do to the people with 19 years in, with no time to put money away to transfer? From what I've read, if it is passed there is no grandfather clause.
I'm not very familiar with what the new plan is, I definetly still have to look into it. I just thought she should re think her argument .
Anyone who says walfare should be cut needs to re think their argument. Sure some people abuse it and others could be working but the children in need in our country come first!
This is actually just a proposal from a DOD advisory panel. It's nowhere near being voted on or set in stone. I agree that it's a good idea to let your representatives know how you feel about it though, just in case.
I've got family members who could/would benefit from both sides. My son got out after five years and other than paying into social security, has nothing to show for it, but he knew that would happen if he didn't put in 20 years. His wife and my son in law are still in. I just think to change it in the middle is unfair.
From what I've read, if it is passed there is no grandfather clause.
Then you have read incorrectly, it becomes a tiered system. I will find the link.
Didn't you know this when you joined?
What about those who planned to do a full 20 but had to get out because of personal reasons or medically seperated?
I copied and pasted from the other thread that talked about this issue: Recruits. The newest troops out of boot camp after the proposed change would have no direct incentive to stay for 20 years and would not get a fixed-benefit pension. Instead, they would receive annual contributions to a Thrift Savings Plan account and could leave service with that money at any time although under current rules, they cant withdraw the money until age 59½ without paying a penalty, except in certain specified circumstances.
Five years of service. Troops would immediately begin accruing new benefits in a TSP account. If they remained in service until the old vesting date the 20-year mark they also would get one-fourth of the old plan benefit, or about 12 percent of their pay at retirement, as an annuity. If they separated, for example, after 10 years, they would walk away with no fixed-pension benefit but would have a TSP account with five years of contributions.
10 years of service. Troops would immediately begin accruing new benefits in a TSP account. If they remained in service for 10 more years, they would receive half of the old plan benefit, about 25 percent of their pay at retirement, as an annuity. If they separated after 15 years, they would walk away with no fixed-pension benefit but would have a TSP account with five years of contributions.
15 years of service. Troops would immediately begin accruing new benefits in a TSP account. If they remained in service for five more years, they would receive three-fourths of the old plan benefit, about 37.5 percent of their pay at retirement, as an annuity. 20 years and beyond. Troops who stayed in past 20 years would continue to receive annual TSP contributions.
except that they're not civilians. The military should not have the same type of retirement as a person who works a nine to five job, no weekends and is home with their family every night. If they want to start a civilian retirement now with new recruits, go ahead. At least they'll know what they're getting in to. People that are already in should be grandfathered in because it's not what they were promised when they joined.
Some parts of the military are a lot like a 9-5 job and they are home nights and weekends. Some civilian jobs are just as if not more dangerous as a military job and require those individuals to be away from home nights/weekends/holidays as well.
So those of us who didn't do a full 20 years don't deserve anything? We worked weekends, holidays and missed our kids big events too?
You knew this when you signed up and when you got out. When my husband signed on the dotted line he was told he would get 50% base pay at 20 years. Now they are changing the game.
I am not a fan of this proposal. My biggest issue is that with the new plan, you don't receive any of your benefits until a specified retirement age. Our plan as a family was always for my husband to do at least 20 yrs and when he got out, we would have that retirement income as a cushion in case he couldn't find a job right away or so he could be more selective about jobs and get something he really wants. And it's always been a part of the military that there is that incentive to stay in at least 20 to get the pension. Every other govt job gets a pension when they reach their specified time of employment. Also, service members who are medically separated get a severance package, so they don't leave with nothing
When my husband signed on the dotted line he was told he would get 50% base pay at 20 years. Now they are changing the game.
exactly. Like I said, it's not a bad starting point for a discussion on changing military retirement, but if it's implemented, it should be presented as an option for those currently serving.
exactly. Like I said, it's not a bad starting point for a discussion on changing military retirement, but if it's implemented, it should be presented as an option for those currently serving.
I totally agree. And a lot of civilian jobs have retirement plan choices.
I read it the same way as southernheart, besides I don't think its such a bad plan. My husband is getting out after 8 years so he is now 8 years behind on his retirement because he won't have anything when his EAS comes around. The new plan is more like you will find in the civilian world.
I agree, my husband will complete his 12th year next year and will be getting out, we just got married and plan on starting a family, so the military lifestyle is not something we want for our kids. He loves it, but he will not take time away from me or the kids when they come, so I think this change will be for the best!! Everyone that served will get what they deserve.
Well, there's no one saying they can't contribute to tsp on their own with out this plan. So they could still get out with something. And like I said, police, firefighters, and every other govt job get a pension after 20 years like the military. The military will be one of the only govt jobs that would not be getting a pension. They would get nothing until they turn 65.