Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: to take away or not!

who's talking here?

ALEM 3
Abra 1
hailstorm 1
grantsmommy 1
Nyki 1
Green Chick 1
xVivaLaDollx 1
ImHisPrincessL314 1
Doo Schnugget 1
Sarah H aka Boot 1
LilShutterbug 1
BosssLady 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: to take away or not!

I'm debating on taking away Logans binky. His speech is severely delayed for his age, but then again he's a lil delayed for most of the milestones as well. That said, I wanted to take away his binky in hopes that it may make him be more vocal. What do you think? I've thought about letting him have it just when he goes down for a nap too.

Take it away Vote
 
 90.0% (54)
Don't take it away Vote
 
 1.7% (1)
Other (explain) Vote
 
 8.3% (5)
ALEM --- 15 years ago -

I'm debating on taking away Logans binky. His speech is severely delayed for his age, but then again he's a lil delayed for most of the milestones as well. That said, I wanted to take away his binky in hopes that it may make him be more vocal. What do you think?

I've thought about letting him have it just when he goes down for a nap too. 

BosssLady --- 15 years ago -

Now is better than never. 

xVivaLaDollx --- 15 years ago -

I've thought about letting him have it just when he goes down for a nap too. 

Other This ^

Start taking it away unless he is going down for the night or nap. Once he gets over that give him something else like a silky blanket or something he likes to sleep with to replace the binky. 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

how old is he??? i would start slowly but yes maybe its time. 

ALEM --- 15 years ago -

Viva, he has his cow that he sleeps with too.

hes almost 13 months. 

Sarah H aka Boot --- 15 years ago -

hes almost 13 months. 

I didnt know kids were speaking words at that age.

Anyways, I would take it away, it wouldnt hurt. 

ALEM --- 15 years ago -

I didnt know kids were speaking words at that age.
well...baby babble included he doesnt do it. 

hailstorm --- 15 years ago -

I took my sons away cold turkey on his 1st birthday. Today was the first time he has ever tried to steal another kids. Lol. He has been fine though. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

He's old enough to teach him to take it out and leave it in bed if he isn't ready to get rid of it completely. 

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

my niece was saying mommy and daddy at 11 months and saying 5+ words at 12 months and that was all after her binky was taken away during the day at 10 months and eliminated completely at 12 months. My sister said she definitely saw an increase in her vocabulary very quickly right after binky was gone 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

by 13 months my son said 30+ words. He never had a binky, but I don't think that has anything to do with it for him---he's just always been a talker. Some babies are and some babies aren't. even at 2 he still babbles a lot, but its slowly being replaced by toddler words and then by grown-up words (ie "peen" vs "plane")...

so, your son will probably continue to mostly babble for a long time to come and that is normal for usre (my son was about 1/2 babble 1/2 words at age 2), but most of my friends have noticed their kids becoming more verbal when they take away the binky. partially because when their mouth isn't full they find it easier to speak their wishes instead of just gesturing.

I'd say take it now for sure...and if he is really dependent for naps MAYBE give it to him then...but in general a clean break is easier on kiddos than a "here" and then a "no" and then a "here ya go" and then "nope" if you catch my drift. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

My son didn't really start babbling till after 14 months or so and he has a binky he only uses at naptime and in the car. So I know it has nothing to do with that. Unless he has it all day long there is no reason why it should be interfering with his speech at that age. Some kids are talkers and some aren't. My son still doesn't say a word at 19 months old although I know other kids who use their pacifier more often and speak more than he does. It all just depends on the kid. There is never a wrong time to take the pacifier away though. Mine will be 21 months when I take it away after he adjusts to daddy leaving on deployment. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Yes. Try giving him a cup of milk to help him settle down for the night (not in bed of course, but before) and sit with him until he falls asleep. 

ImHisPrincessL314 --- 15 years ago -

Take it away completely. Walk over to the trash can with him and have him drop ALL of them in the trash and say bye bye. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground