Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Should modding be a transparent/honest process?

who's talking here?

CourtesyFlush 14
Donny 6
petit oiseau 1
Hokey*Pokey 2
Green Chick 22
Housewife Say What 3
Phragmipedium 2
Basia 4
xVivaLaDollx 2
Scrappy 6
Kara 4
Sarah H aka Boot 1
ItchyWitch 1
foxed 14
BosssLady 2
Cindyisback4U 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should modding be a transparent/honest process?

Do you think the mods should re-install the 'who did what' names-next-to-actions in the moderator log? Should they be held accountable as a group, or should each mod have to own up to their every mod-action?

No names! They are a single unit. Vote
 
 11.5% (6)
Names! Let each be judged according to their own actions. Vote
 
 82.7% (43)
There is no other. Vote
 
 5.8% (3)
foxed --- 15 years ago -

Do you think the mods should re-install the 'who did what' names-next-to-actions in the moderator log?

Should they be held accountable as a group, or should each mod have to own up to their every mod-action? 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

If there are no names, they have no recourse/proof if admin/Kara takes mod action and the people aren't happy with it. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

If there are no names, they have no recourse/proof if admin/Kara takes mod action and the people aren't happy with it.

Actually this isn't true because we can go to the mod page and copy/paste who did what if you reeeeeeeeeeally wanna know :) 

Cindyisback4U --- 15 years ago -

I think it should be transparent; we had the mod revolt thing so that people we elected would be fair. How can they be held accountable if there is no account? 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

Plus I will tell you if it was me. I am not worried about it. I personally don't think it should be shown because you don't really know what was edited/deleted when several things are happening at once. You can just speculate. Also, and the previous mods who voted to do away with it in the first place, that sometimes a quick decision has to be made to delete something or ice someone. It might not always be the best decision by by golly this isn't a paid job ;) lol 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

Actually this isn't true because we can go to the mod page and copy/paste who did what if you reeeeeeeeeeally wanna know :) 

I'd prefer a screenshot ;) But I get that you guys have instant access to that info. The majority of us little people don't, though lol 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

I put "there is no other" because I don't really care either way, lol. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

I'd prefer a screenshot ;) But I get that you guys have instant access to that info. The majority of us little people don't, though lol

As long as Kara won't spank me, I have no problem putting up a screen shot over something questionable. Some of the naughty language would have to be cleaned up of course, but like I said before I have been trying to mark the threads that I have edited so no one has to even go back and look. :) 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

I voted no names.

If people spent more time worrying about themselves then what the mods are doing this place would run smoother.

The mods are perfectly capable of dealing directly with the people involved and don't need to explain themselves to everyone else.

People that aren't happy with a mods actions can always take it up with admin.

Self-moderate yourselves like adults and there is nothing to worry about. 

Cindyisback4U --- 15 years ago -

Self-moderate yourselves like adults and there is nothing to worry about.

this 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

but like I said before I have been trying to mark the threads that I have edited so no one has to even go back and look. :) 

It would be the total bee's knees if you guys could implement your own system of signing your actions, like OC. You're right, it would be way more convenient for the community. 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

Either way, I think people will complain about editing.

Donny said it perfectly, "Self-moderate yourselves like adults and there is nothing to worry about." 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

Self-moderate yourselves like adults and there is nothing to worry about.

Preach it brotha :) 

CourtesyFlush --- 15 years ago -

We shouldn't have MODS in the first place. Having MODS OBVIOUSLY creates more drama, but I guess that doesn't seem to sink into the "admins" brains. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Since the new mods have been put in place I have noticed some nasty comments people are leaving is being changed instead of just leaving the kindly deleted comment. I personally don't like that and it's confusing. If you are going to edit a comment don't change what it says to what you want it to say, just delete the comment. I also think it should show what mod does what. 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

The mods are perfectly capable of dealing directly with the people involved and don't need to explain themselves to everyone else.

In most common sense situations, I agree. Occasionally mods get out of hand, though. They are using their own discretion/judgment on policing the community, and so they shouldn't have any reason to want to hide them.

People that aren't happy with a mods actions can always take it up with admin.

Not on this site. Admin is sporadic in their attention. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

Admin is sporadic in their attention.

If you don't like something you can flag it if there is no mod on, or if a mod misses something. :) 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

If you are going to edit a comment don't change what it says to what you want it to say, just delete the comment. I also think it should show what mod does what. 

Exactly. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

If you don't like something you can flag it if there is no mod on, or if a mod misses something. :)
 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

The MODs have been told in the past and present to edit out swear words (including creatively spelled swearing), graphic content or anything inappropriate on the site.

Deleting entire comments or threads are usually warranted. If you have a q about why your comment or thread was altered or deleted, pm me or a MOD. 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

If you don't like something you can flag it if there is no mod on, or if a mod misses something. :)

This isn't the topic. The topic is the accountability of those granted special permissions over the community. 

CourtesyFlush --- 15 years ago -

Kara we haven't always had babysitters. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

This isn't the topic. The topic is the accountability of those granted special permissions over the community.

Right, but then you commented that admin is sporadic. If an admin doesn't catch something, flag it. 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

This isn't the topic. The topic is the accountability of those granted special permissions over the community.

These were the mods the community chose because they are the fairest and best suited for the job though right?

So where's the trust? Why should the community need to micro-manage the mods they elected? 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

So where's the trust? Why should the community need to micro-manage the mods they elected?

It is more fun to stir the pot than just be on here commenting like a normal person lol 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

I want to know how this is already starting when there hasn't even been any drama with the new mods over accountability or any type of deletions? 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

Admin is sporadic in their attention.

Would you like to see me more involved? 

Sarah H aka Boot --- 15 years ago -

These were the mods the community chose because they are the fairest and best suited for the job though right?

So where's the trust? Why should the community need to micro-manage the mods they elected? 


You make me laugh lol. I love the statement dripping with sarcasm ;) Seriously I do lol 

foxed --- 15 years ago -

Right, but then you commented that admin is sporadic.

I was responding to Donny's off-topic comment: "People that aren't happy with a mods actions can always take it up with admin." 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

It is more fun to stir the pot than just be on here commenting like a normal person lol

:D 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground