I definitely don't think that they should limit themselves. Some kids are naturally talented and should stand out for that! It'll give them opportunities in the long run and boost their confidence.
What are your thoughts on forcing children to limit themselves in a game?
not seen parents do this - i mean not everyone can be the biggest, fastest, best and where one is good at something the other is good at other things
but then again our last baseball team was broken up after the season championship because we...... ummmmm, we lived the play hard or go home attitude and other parents found us a bit scary but we really were just having a great time but were pretty vocal about it
If your referring to the Youth Sports rules, I feel your frustration. What can you to though? they could play out in town for bookoo bucks. I thought the policy change was dumb when the started enforcing it. It doesn't prepare kids for real sports in jr or high school.
If your referring to the Youth Sports rules, I feel your frustration. What can you to though? they could play out in town for bookoo bucks. I thought the policy change was dumb when the started enforcing it. It doesn't prepare kids for real sports in jr or high school.
My husband is a coach and he's getting yelled at by refs. He even moved players around, benched people, but they still scored. The kids on the team are 10-13
If the refs do it again. Tell hubs to have the kids just "stand" in there places and let the other team score.
LOL. I doubt they would listen :P. I will say that our parents are overly encouraging to their kids (no cussing or anything) but he's also talked to them. There isnt much he can do. Unless a parent is cussing or something.
this is news to me - ive not heard of this. i mean there are some teams that struggle but not everyone can win, what happens when little johnny gets older and finds out its not a free ride
My kids have played youth sports for 2 years & the hubs has coached too. I have never heard of limiting their potential. I do know that the whole reason they do "drafts" now is so one team is not super dominant. Maybe your husband can call youth sports or talk to the refs before the game. If the kids are scoring fairly there is nothing you can do about that. Youth sports is great up about the ages of 10/11. After that if you want them to play in high school then you need to go out in town. Pop warner football is $300 just to sign up & $150 you need to personally raise so total to play is $450!!! :0 Youth sports is all about fun though and not preparing them for "real sports" out in town.
Some parents take youth sports on base entirely too seriously.
It's a $25 season and everyone can play. Even in the sports where there are "try-outs" or "placements" everyone still plays their sole purpose is to try to make even teams.
Mercy rules are in effect which is what i believe this post is about. I've never heard of "limiting potential", but i have seen coaches move kids around or pull them out to rest them when they are slaughtering another team.
It's demoralizing to kids to get beat every week, they stop having fun and end up not liking sports if it becomes a pattern. Some parents simply don't know or have forgotten what Good Sportsmanship is all about...
If you think your child is "that good", pay the money and put them out in town in competitive or club leagues....You'll get a reality check real fast. Base sports is purely for fun it's a whole other World out in town or in High School.
Oh, and one of the soccer refs is the Freshman OHS soccer coach. He refs all ages and if he spots talent he finds the parents of the kid and suggests they try out for the Oceanside Breakers soccer club league which he and all the OHS coaches also coach.
Some parents take youth sports on base entirely too seriously.
It's a $25 season and everyone can play. Even in the sports where there are "try-outs" or "placements" everyone still plays their sole purpose is to try to make even teams.
Mercy rules are in effect which is what i believe this post is about. I've never heard of "limiting potential", but i have seen coaches move kids around or pull them out to rest them when they are slaughtering another team.
It's demoralizing to kids to get beat every week, they stop having fun and end up not liking sports if it becomes a pattern. Some parents simply don't know or have forgotten what Good Sportsmanship is all about...
The point of the post is my husband volunteered to coach and is being yelled at even though he...
1. Benched two of the best players (couldnt do anymore because we have to have the same # of players)
2. Moved players around (goalie was benched, non-goalie was put into goalie, forwards were put to defense, defense to forward, etc.
This isnt someone who is upset about not being allowed to drive up the score. I realize that it hurts to lose.. but thats also what life is about. I personally would rather my daughter lose to a team who gave it all rather than a team who just stood there because they were better. My child is NOT a good soccer player and the team isnt expert player either. They have just been lucky with hard work and dedication.
The last two points this week (end score 7-0) was scored by the other team when they kicked the ball into their own goal twice. Our players only actually scored 5 goals.
The point of the post is my husband volunteered to coach and is being yelled at even though he...
1. Benched two of the best players (couldnt do anymore because we have to have the same # of players)
2. Moved players around (goalie was benched, non-goalie was put into goalie, forwards were put to defense, defense to forward, etc.
This isnt someone who is upset about not being allowed to drive up the score. I realize that it hurts to lose.. but thats also what life is about. I personally would rather my daughter lose to a team who gave it all rather than a team who just stood there because they were better. My child is NOT a good soccer player and the team isnt expert player either. They have just been lucky with hard work and dedication.
It happens. We had a game like that two weeks ago. We moved players around, dropped down a player, dropped down two players, put someone in goal who had never played goalie before...we still scored two more goals and our coach was yelled at too by the other teams parents.
Only thing that helped was our coach was explaining to the refs what he was doing the whole time after the ref came over at half-time saying "it's 7-0, mercy rule".
Sometimes a team is that bad, sometimes kids who aren't normally very good step up and make a play, sometimes you try to make it fair and for everyone to have fun and it still doesn't work...
It happens. We had a game like that two weeks ago. We moved players around, dropped down a player, dropped down two players, put someone in goal who had never played goalie before...we still scored two more goals and our coach was yelled at too by the other teams parents.
Only thing that helped was our coach was explaining to the refs what he was doing the whole time after the ref came over at half-time saying "it's 7-0, mercy rule".
Sometimes a team is that bad, sometimes kids who aren't normally very good step up and make a play, sometimes you try to make it fair and for everyone to have fun and it still doesn't work...
My son has played one season of high school and also club soccer for 7 years. He has been on both sides of a 10-0 game more then once. If a team is leading by several points and it is clear that the opponent does not have the potential to tie it up, a good coach will use the time to improve skills. What all of his coaches have done is instruct players to pass the ball...and keep passing. If the kids need to be told to pass 20 times before taking a shot on goal then that is what should be done. Or, maybe individual players can use that time to work on special footwork during a game that they can't do against a strong opponent.
Also, it is customary for coaches to tell their players this new strategy in a discret manner. The other team is already embarrased, so why make it worse. Although the entire point of the game is winning, as a parent I want my son to improve his skills, which does not always happen just by scoring.
I don't care for it. Kids need to learn how to lose gracefully. They also need to realize when a particular sport just isn't for them, and their talent lies elsewhere. My daughter did soccer before realizing it looked a lot more fun than it really was. She had to finish the season she committed to and she didn't sign up any more. She went on to try gymnastics and her natural talent came out. She competes now, because she's worked hard, and not because someone let her slide by. It has done wonders for her self confidence.
I believe in the old fashioned rules of playing. If you aren't good, find something your good at. Maybe it's art, and not sports. If that's the case, embrace it. Don't bring the rest of the team down because you just simply want to play on a team.
we had the opposite happen here.. we put my son in tackle football this year. the first couple of weeks went well everyone was included in practice .(this was even before any games). then they started singling 5 kids out. my son included.. they would tell mikey to sit watch and learn. which honeslty would be ok... but it ended up being every practice for over a week and it would be for atleast 40 minutes a day.. we were pissed! we just sucked it up and pulled him out of it. we didnt pay 240 bucks for him to sit and watch.they werent giving him the chance to learn even.. so now we put him in baseball again. hes really good! hes on the 9 year old team and is right at the skill level with the other kids/
I can't believe that refs are being so ridiculous... I don't have kids yet, but when I do and if they want to play sports, then why the HECK bother playing if you're not actually gonna PLAY?! Geez, are they trying to teach them not to try? That if they are good at something then they should be ashamed of themselves? Because that is what kids will remember. They don't view things the way adults do. And it's not playing "fair" if one team is forced to play a certain way, just so everyone gets to win... If it were me on the "winning" team, I would not feel like I had won anything. Not fun.
Interestingly enough... Many people I know would say much the same things about the Marine Corps lately, and how Mother's Of America are pulling much the same thing when it comes to "my son deserves to be a Marine too, so don't make him do the Reaper/ don't hold him to the same standards as bigger guys/etc." It's bull, and all it's doing is weakening the overall strength of the force. Sorry to get all seriousness, I just saw the similarities.
I can't believe that refs are being so ridiculous... I don't have kids yet, but when I do and if they want to play sports, then why the HECK bother playing if you're not actually gonna PLAY?! Geez, are they trying to teach them not to try? That if they are good at something then they should be ashamed of themselves? Because that is what kids will remember. They don't view things the way adults do. And it's not playing "fair" if one team is forced to play a certain way, just so everyone gets to win... If it were me on the "winning" team, I would not feel like I had won anything. Not fun.
They do it because it's Youth Sports on base which is all about just being fun. Like stated above, you need to go out in town for more competition, and to really prepare your kids for high school sports.
I just don't think they are doing the kids any favors. It's not fun to win and know that you were "allowed" to win. It takes the fun out of it for both teams.
Telling your kids not to play to their potential is the craziest thing I've heard lately. I'm all for everyone getting their chance to play, but there will always be a winner and a loser.
How are kids being taught to handle the real world in a situation like that???
My brother got a baseball pitching scholarship that put him through college. If my parents and his coaches had tried to limit him maybe that wouldn't have been possible.
And seriously did someone say that if your child is skilled and a good player that you should have to pay extra money and put them in another league? That's insane.
I agree but again it's Youth Sports. That is their policy and parents are more then allowed to go out in town where it's a whole different world. Youth sports does not prepare your kid for a higher level of playing, it is about fun.
Things must be different out here than where I'm from. Up until middle school, there is only parks and rec ball...so either parks and rec prepares you for school ball or nothing does.
I don't understand why you keep saying "it's youth ball" as if it makes it different. It shouldn't matter at what age children learn to play fair and play to their full potential. As long as we are teaching them to be graceful winners, and not sore losers, then what is the problem. Children of all ages are capable of learning these important life lessons and values, and it is irritating to me that "it's just youth sports" is viewed as a good excuse to not teach our children to be good people. It's part of growing up geez. You think because your kid is 7 means they don't have the capacity to understand how to win and lose? In fact, I would think that the earlier they are taught these things, the better a person they would become. And then what happens when they get to middle school ball, and they don't let them win, then those less skilled players are going to feel really bad about themselves. It's stupid to sugar coat something as simple and necessary a lesson as sometimes, you win, sometimes you lose. You're not doing these kids a favor.
All sports are about fun... The fun of competition. I mean, if it were my kid, and it didn't bother my kid, then I'd be like fine. Or, I would just enroll my child in little league or something off base. but you are right that parents can just not play on base. It's pretty simple a solution as well.
I agree so much, why suppress a child, I seen an article about this a couple of weeks ago with a junior high football kid that was told to stop scoring, I personally think its good for a child to FAIL this is what teaches them lessons in life. Sorry everyone can't be a winner all the time!!! People are dooming our future society it's ridiculous.