Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

My son's fish died! :(

who's talking here?

Braydens Mommy 1
ShetoriToe 1
jdoll 4
CLLP 1
Whatevergirl 2 1
JediMommy 1
sleepingbeauty 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jdoll --- 14 years ago -

My son is 4 and his fish died last night. So, here is my question. Do we make a quiet and sneaky swap or tell him about it and let him go pick out another fish on his own? I'm not sure how to go about it. Any input? Thanks so much! 

Whatevergirl 2 --- 14 years ago -

I would tell him. Make it 4 year old appropriate when explaining death, then take him to get a new one.

Death is a part of life. Hiding it makes it the unknown, the unknown is scary. 

jdoll --- 14 years ago -

Death is a part of life. Hiding it makes it the unknown, the unknown is scary.

See, that's what I thought but my husband just wants to replace it. I had to take psychology of death and dying in college, for my major, and i remember when we discussed about explaining death to children. i know what NOT to say so not to confuse them but i just wasn't sure if i should deal with it at this age. 

ShetoriToe --- 14 years ago -

my daughter is 4 and when her fish died, she didnt even care, she was like "oh well, lets go buy a new one" 

jdoll --- 14 years ago -

my daughter is 4 and when her fish died, she didnt even care, she was like "oh well, lets go buy a new one"

it would be so much easier if my son would react this way but i'm not sure that he will. he didn't really check on "walter" very much but he's a bit sensitive to stuff. i feel like he's just going to break down when i tell him. here's another question, now that i'm thinking about it. we are moving back to oklahoma in about 5 months. should we even get another fish since it's going to be hard to transport it? i've never moved with a fish so i'm ASSUMING that it's not an easy task! 

JediMommy --- 14 years ago -

I would tell him and im sure he would be fine with it if he could go and pick out a new fish. 

CLLP --- 14 years ago -

I would agree with most here and tell him. A fish is an easy simple fix but also a good way to explain death. Once explained you can offer to get another one. Tell him the new fish could never replace the old one but it can also become a good friend too. 

sleepingbeauty --- 14 years ago -

Just tell him,why complicate everything so much?dead is something that is going to happen eventually,sometimes the causes are natural sometimes are not,simple as that.. 

Braydens Mommy --- 14 years ago -

You could tell him you'll let him pick out another when you are moved? 

jdoll --- 14 years ago -

You could tell him you'll let him pick out another when you are moved?

that's what we did. we told him that walter died and that we will let him pick out a new fish when we move back to oklahoma. there were tears and it was sad for a few minutes. he asked specifically what "died" meant and there was alot of hugging! after he calmed down a bit, he asked if would build him a fish shaped pond, in oklahoma, so he could swim with his new fish!! lol!! children are so cute and wonderful! :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground