Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Birth control not preventing conception..read and opinion?

who's talking here?

sweetcheeks 6
mommyof5 1
Hokey*Pokey 1
Mom25 1
DocsWife 1
shellibeth 2
a3284112uu 1
Nitwhit 1
accountnickname 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sweetcheeks --- 14 years ago -

In 1965, The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) issued a bulletin to redefine the term "conception." That bulletin stated that conception should be understood to mean "the implantation of a fertilized ovum."1 Why this change? The timing of their decision makes it almost certain that it was politically rather than scientifically motivated. The FDA had recently approved the sale of hormonal birth control pills, but "the pill" didn't fit the traditional definition of "contraceptive." Why? Because it doesn't just prevent conception; it also inhibits implantation–or at least purports to. If breakthrough ovulation and fertilization occurs (which is the biological beginning of individual, human life), the embryo may find it difficult to implant because of changes the pill makes to the endometrium. This created an ethical problem for doctors who wanted to assure their patients that the pill is a contraceptive and not an abortifacient. How did they deal with the dilemma? They changed the definition of "conception." By saying "conception," but meaning "implantation," it became possible to market hormonal birth control pills as contraceptives – as something that prevents "conception."

If you look through the ACOG website today, you won't find a glossary of terms, but you will find numerous references to their altered definition of pregnancy and conception. In a pregnancy FAQ, they state that "fertilization, the union of an egg and a sperm, is the first step in a complex series of events that leads to pregnancy" (emphasis added).2 On a page titled, "Contraception," they state that the IUD "can stop pregnancy" by "thin[ning] the lining of the uterus making it harder for a fertilized egg to attach."3 On their Birth Control Pills FAQ, they state that one way the pill can "prevent pregnancy" is by making the uterus lining thin, "making it less likely that a fertilized egg can attach to it."4 By redefining the recognized beginning of pregnancy, birth control methods that would have otherwise been said to end pregnancy, can now be said to prevent pregnancy. These semantic changes do nothing to alter the biology of prenatal development, but they do plenty to confuse the ethical implications. In a 2005 Guttmacher Report on Public Policy, Rachel Benson Gold argued that "according to both the scientific community and long-standing federal policy, a woman is considered pregnant only when a fertilized egg has implanted in the wall of her uterus."5 She goes on to say that though conception is "often used synonymously with fertilization… medically, (it) is equated with implantation." This is clearly an overstatement.

In The Developing Human: Clinically Oriented Embryology, which is a standard teaching text on prenatal development, the authors note that obstetricians date pregnancies in one of two ways – either "beginning from the first day of the last normal menstrual period (LNMP)," or "at fertilization or conception, about two weeks after LNMP."6 Note the interchangeable use of fertilization and conception, which is repeated again in a summary bullet on the same page. No mention is made of anyone aging an embryo from the time of implantation. In the index of Human Embryology & Teratology, the entry for "conception" takes you to a page describing the process of fertilization.7 Nothing is said about implantation. On the next page, it says that, "just as postnatal age begins at birth, prenatal age begins at fertilization." Alexander Tsiaras, who served as the Chief of Scientific Visualizatiion in Yale University's Department of Medicine, did a TED lecture in 2010 which included a sample of the video he created called, From Conception to Birth.8 Not surprisingly, the animated sequence begins with fertilization, not implantation. Finally, Merriam-Webster,9 MedicineNet,10 American Heritage,11 MediLexicon,12 Dictionary.com13 and WebMD14 all define conception as the union of sperm and egg. Only Webster's recognizes an alternate usage that relates to implantation. Four of the definitions explicitly identify "conception" as the onset of pregnancy.

The Guttmacher report is only able to point to one recognized, medical body that makes conception synonymous with implantation and that is ACOG. No mention is made of the Journal of Maternal-Fetal Medicine study which found that 73% of participating ob/gyn's stated that conception is synonymous with fertilization.15 According to that same study, 50% of the OB/GYN's surveyed indicated that pregnancy begins at fertilization. Forty-eight percent indicated it begins at implantation. The study concluded: "Neither ACOG definition has been consistently adopted by its members whose definitions are more consistent with lay and embryologist definitions…. The ACOG is urged to reconsider its definitions." Quoting ACOG, in a text box titled "When is a Woman Pregnant?," the Guttmacher report states that "if fertilization does occur, the zygote divides and differentiates into a 'preembryo' while being carried down the fallopian tube toward the uterus."16 Why do they put "preembryo" in quotations? Because it's not a scientifically-valid term. Human Embryology & Teratology offers this rebuttal:
The term "pre-embryo" is not used [in this textbook] for the following reasons: (1) it is ill-defined because it is said to end with the appearance of the primitive streak or to include neurulation; (2) it is inaccurate because purely embryonic cells can already be distinguished after a few days, as can also the embryonic (not pre-embryonic!) disc; (3) it is unjustified because the accepted meaning of the word embryo includes all of the first 8 weeks; (4) it is equivocal because it may convey the erroneous idea that a new human organism is formed at only some considerable time after fertilization; and (5) it was introduced in 1986 "largely for public policy reasons."17
Reason number five is particularly telling–indicating again that ACOG's decision to redefine pregnancy was primarily a political one. Though obstetricians have largely ignored ACOG's revisionist definitions, government employees have been more willing to buy in–at least in part. In the 1975 version of the Federal Register, in a section titled, "Protection of Human Subjects," the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (now HHS) declared that, "'Pregnancy' encompasses the period of time from confirmation of implantation until expulsion or extraction of the fetus."18 They further declared that, “'Fetus' means the product of conception from the time of implantation until a determination is made, following expulsion or extraction of the fetus, that it is viable." The "Protection of Human Subjects" amendment was first added to the Federal Register in 1973,19 to ensure that no human subjects would be used for medical testing without giving their full, informed consent. The 1974 version proposed adding language to specifically address fetuses.20 The 1975 version was the first to define "pregnancy" and "fetus."

It is worth noting that according to the 1977 version of the Federal Register, the reason HHS federally defined pregnancy as beginning at implantation was because, "No medical tests exist which can confirm conception."21 They call their definition "a matter of practical medical and regulatory necessity," and notice they use the word "conception" as though it were synonymous with "fertilization." Even though it is no longer true that pregnancy can't be detected until fertilization, the definitions established in 1975 have been left unchanged.22 A Third Way memo points to these definitions as "proof" that emergency contraception is in fact, contraceptive and not abortive.23 But those who claim a "long-standing federal policy" of defining pregnancy to begin at implantation are missing a significant fact. As indicated by the 1977 preamble, these provisions were not made with emergency contraception in mind. Contraception isn't even mentioned. The issue was the role pregnancy plays on informed consent. Certain medical tests might be fine for a woman who is not pregnant, but dangerous for the offspring of one who is. The emergence of in vitro fertilization presented other definitional challenges. When does a woman whose ovum is fertilized artificially actually become pregnant? HHS decided to define pregnancy as beginning at implantation, arguing that this was a "practical necessity" since implantation is the earliest point at which pregnancy can be verified. But if that's really the case, definitions based on a practical-ignorance of fertilization should not be applicable to things like embryonic stem cell research or in vitro fertilization, where it is medically known that fertilization has occurred. Nor is it appropriate to argue that since we couldn't test for pregnancy before implantation in 1977, we shouldn't have any ethical concerns about birth control methods that impede implantation today. 

DocsWife --- 14 years ago -

I didn't read that huge novel up there, but this is the reason I don't take any kind of pills or have an IUD or anything like that. It really sucks, but I can't take the chance of being at fault for the passing of a baby of mine. That is how I see it, even if it is only a few cells. I know that in those few cells there is an entire genetic code and that sooo many characteristics, both physical and personality, are decided from the moment a zygote is formed. I know it happens all the time naturally (the passing of one I mean), but I just can't bring myself to do it. My husband doesn't really agree with me and sometimes pressures me to get on some kind of BC, but for now, we just use barriers, as much it sucks to do. 

sweetcheeks --- 14 years ago -

Bb I like the point u made at the end. Honestly I never knew any of that :/ 

sweetcheeks --- 14 years ago -

Oh yeah sorry so long 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

I would never choose an IUD but I have no problem with birth control pills even though I believe life begins the moment the egg fertilizes and then the cells begin dividing. I can easily tell when I am ovulating so I would know if I were ovulating through it. So far it's never happened. I do not take it long-term but rather for medical necessity in short spans. 

shellibeth --- 14 years ago -

A Mirena has built in hormones like bcps while a Paragard does not. So an IUD is not a bad choice for people that want the same outcome as birth control pills, without having to take a pill everyday; they should just choose a Mirena. 

mommyof5 --- 14 years ago -

My first IUD FELL OUT. Second one ruptured my uterus and I got pregnant both times. I know 6 different people all got their IUDs somewhere else all pregnant. 2 of them have NO IDEA where the IUD went. Be careful with those ladies. I went on to have two very successful pregnancies but still be careful. 

sweetcheeks --- 14 years ago -

I would never do iud 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

I wouldn't do an IUD period not even considering if it does or does not prevent an embryo from implanting. 

shellibeth --- 14 years ago -

My first IUD FELL OUT. Second one ruptured my uterus and I got pregnant both times. I know 6 different people all got their IUDs somewhere else all pregnant. 2 of them have NO IDEA where the IUD went. Be careful with those ladies. I went on to have two very successful pregnancies but still be careful.

That's really sad. I worked at an OB-GYN for years and rarely heard issues like these. Hopefully the people inserting them are doing ultrasounds to check for proper placement. I have seen A LOT of people get pregnant on the pill. 

Mom25 --- 14 years ago -

Not a fan of the pill because it does not prevent conception...but was on it twice, short term, for medical reasons...I'm the 1% that get pregnant while using. Barrier methods stink but if no other form fits your lifestyle or beliefs, what else is left? I was destined to have the children I have, pill or no pill. 

Nitwhit --- 14 years ago -

A friend of mine just had to deliver her baby at eighteen weeks, just two days after she found out she was pregnant. She had the paraguard and still ended up pregnant. After hearing about her situation I decided just to use an ovulation calendar. (I am pretty regular) I can't keep up with a pill or patch so I guess if I end up pregnant it is meant to be, I just don't want to risk putting myself (or any potential children in danger). I considered mirena but tricare doesnt cover it with my gynecologist. 

Hokey*Pokey --- 14 years ago -

pull n pray, baby 

sweetcheeks --- 14 years ago -

I'm wondering what happened to that male pill that was going on the market?? 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

pull n pray, baby

Surprisingly it's more effective than you'd think according to studies. 

sweetcheeks --- 14 years ago -

Hokey*Pokey --- 1 min ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
pull n pray, baby 

Lol 

a3284112uu --- 14 years ago -

 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground