Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Breast-feeding VS Formula...dun dun dun!!

who's talking here?

Maureen 1
sweetcheeks 2
Apocalypse 1
2Gems4Ever 4
christina 2
Calimommy 4
Pink Taco 1
kris 1
Taminator 1
bballmom 2
YouReallyThinkSo 1
Wisconsin Sarah 2
Charlies mama 1
BadMomma2 1
Momma2Fur 1
LastManStanding 1
YoursTruly 2
panda soup 1
Poe 1
HavingaBOY 1
AZbound 2
Jayne Wayne 9
kristin40 1
DramaLlamasMomma 2
shizzlemydizzle 4
Murph 1
accountnickname 1
Idez7 1
alwaysright 1
reinacat 1
That Lady 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

HavingaBOY --- 14 years ago -

I was reading about this today...I am curious what everyone's opinions are? I've heard so many different sides to both...

I plan on breastfeeding. But I'd never ever look down on someone who wouldn't want to. But I've heard of women criticizing formula moms like crazy, what do you ladies think?? And yes I'm bored :) lol. 

Jayne Wayne --- 14 years ago -

Formula should be prescription only is my opinion. 

DramaLlamasMomma --- 14 years ago -

oh lawd. I would lock this now lol ;P

Personally I breastfeed and supplement with formula. I'm the first out of my entire family (mom, aunts, cousins) to breastfeed so I am the one that is looked at like a weirdo. 

2Gems4Ever --- 14 years ago -

She did ask for opinions but this may get ugly. There should be a thread started by PU's very own crunchy mama Jane Wayne. It's about the Target nurse in. 

BadMomma2 --- 14 years ago -

my thoughts are whatever it takes for a happy & rested mom and thriving baby 

DramaLlamasMomma --- 14 years ago -

my thoughts are whatever it takes for a happy & rested mom and thriving baby 

x2! Less stress is best. 

Calimommy --- 14 years ago -

I did both, liked either one. Whatever works for you and the baby. 

bballmom --- 14 years ago -

You should just make one thread HavingABoy named Pregnancy/baby questions and just keep all your questions you ask daily there??!?!

Also, there are a TON of threads about this topic already. 

bballmom --- 14 years ago -

Damn LDG2 back to the dungeon already?!? Oh well, at least I have my phone to keep me entertained =] 

alwaysright --- 14 years ago -

Formula should be prescription only is my opinion.


10000000x agree 

Momma2Fur --- 14 years ago -

I've done both. The bond with breastfeeding is amazing. I miss it. But I feel a mother should have a choice. All studies aside, my bottle fed child has been so much healthier than my breastfed one. Go figure. lol 

shizzlemydizzle --- 14 years ago -

Whatever works for the family is what's best.

It's a personal preference. 

AZbound --- 14 years ago -

I don't see anything wrong with either way. 

2Gems4Ever --- 14 years ago -

Whatever works for the family is what's best.

It's a personal preference. 


This ^^^. You will get tons of opinions but ultimately it's up to you and your body. 

kristin40 --- 14 years ago -

BadMomma2 --- 22 min ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
my thoughts are whatever it takes for a happy & rested mom and thriving baby 


^^That^^ 

Maureen --- 14 years ago -

BadMomma2 --- 53 min ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
my thoughts are whatever it takes for a happy & rested mom and thriving baby 



Definitely agree! 

Idez7 --- 14 years ago -

If you are privileged and able to breast feed then I think you should do it. Formula should only be used if you do not produce at all. Our bodies were built to produce and provide food for our children. 

panda soup --- 14 years ago -

Where I'm originally from, breastfeeding is totally unheard of. I didn't even know it was an option until I joined a pregnancy forum. I was like "people people give breast milk to their babies????" But the more I learned about it the greater it sounded so I decided to breast feed. Like another poster said, I was the first in my family to do so and all my mom could say was 'gross. What are you going to do when the baby needs milk and your at the store?' lol But I only did it for 8 weeks. The hubs and I were stationed at separate bases with a 7 hour drive between them and I was visiting him often while on maternity leave and the personal leave i took after that because he was going on deployment soon. Because of the frequent and lengthy drives my supply slowly dwindled more and more because it just wasn't practical to stop and pump or breast feed.

With all that said, I would recommend breadtfeeding to anyone because it's a special feeling, being able to give your baby the the absolute best food for him or her. But I don't judge people that choose not to breastfeed. It's a choice and formula is the next best thing.

Also some advice- if you breastfeed don't take antibiotics unless you absolutely have to! I did for a UTI after giving birth and I regretted it because it killed my supply and it was a lot of work trying to build it back up and it also gave my son thrush. 

Pink Taco --- 14 years ago -

I breastfed my son a whole year and it's the best decision I ever made, IMO.

He's a healthy boy and rarely ever gets sick, cold, flu, etc.

I'm hoping I can breastfeed this baby the same, but we will see if I produce the same amount and if he takes it.

Plus, I like that I never dealt with bottles. Then again, my son was an easy baby overall, he gave me no trouble. 

sweetcheeks --- 14 years ago -

I breastfed my son, he's almost never sick! 

Poe --- 14 years ago -

My nephew was formula fed, I've never seen that kid sick.

I so far plan to breastfeed simply because its cheaper, I'll be a single mom and don't want to have to buy formula unless I absolutely have to. I think both ways are great and each do their job which is all that matters. 

kris --- 14 years ago -

I think everyone should atleast try, if its not working or you don't want to continue you can switch to formula.
I breast fed both for about six months. I stopped breastfeeding my son at seven and a half months because I was five months pregnant and I wanted to wean him and have time before my daughter was born. I did have a supply frozen so he had about two months of breastmilk before going to formula completely. With my daughter I bf till she was around six months and she just didn't want it anymore and I didn't have time at work to keep up my supply. I again had a two month supply frozen. 

AZbound --- 14 years ago -

Both of my kids were formula fed & they're hardly ever sick. 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

I was not breastfed but I knew that it is the best food for my babies so I decided to do it. I was lucky and was able to provide breastmilk all 4 times without any issues. The longest I nursed a baby was 19 months. Given my circumstances -- my husband and I being comfortable with it, having no problems and knowing it is the best possible food for baby -- it would have been crazy to not. However I understand that there are a lot of societal issues and circumstances that can make it much harder for some women. I wish that we could do better in helping with the issues that can be helped such as the way some in society views breastfeeding to allow more women to be successful at it. I don't think that anyone should EVER feel bad about not being able to do it, however. Formula is a good substitute. It might not provide everything that breastmilk can, but it does provide good nutrition for a baby and that is the most important part. 

Charlies mama --- 14 years ago -

Formula isn't bad. Breastmilk is just better. Don't laugh at me but I see it like choosing veggies and fruits that are organic or not. Breastmilk or organic fruits and veggies are better but eating regular fruits and veggies or formula isn't detrimental to your health in the slightest.

I think every mom should try breastfeeding. It's very rare that a mom can't breastfeed. I know moms from bfing support groups who were able to bf when no one thought they could: moms to preemies, moms to twins, moms to triplet, mom who had to go through medical treatments to start lactating to bf adopted children. I know a particularly brave mom who breastfed twin babies, a 2 year old, and still pumped enough to donate milk to her sisters premie baby.

I think every mom should try to nurse their baby. But it's a big commitment. It's very hard to start and without a proper support system a mom may quit because she's discouraged, stressed, and feeling pressure from unsupportive family and friends and possibly even their doctors.

I try to be as supportive and helpful as I can. I know that I can sometimes sound anti formula when I tell moms trying to bf to not use it. But that's not the intention at all. In the end it's about what works best for your family. 

LastManStanding --- 14 years ago -

Both of our boys were formula fed only, and both are perfectly healthy. 

Apocalypse --- 14 years ago -

I'll feed my kid with what I want and you can feed your kid with whatever you want.. That's my standing.. As long as the baby is getting fed. 

christina --- 14 years ago -

Ok here is my opinion, I think that everyone should at least try to breastfeed their babies. If you are not willing to use the free supply of milk that you have, you shouldn't be able to get wic. I think if wic were not so readily available more people would try to nurse. 

shizzlemydizzle --- 14 years ago -

If you are not willing to use the free supply of milk that you have, you shouldn't be able to get wic

Not everyone receives WIC.

If you don't breast feed, you don't get as much from WIC anyway, so WIC does "penalize" for not breast feeding.

Breastfeeding is a PERSONAL choice and shouldn't be forced on anyone.

Not everyone is comfortable with it.

It also doesn't fit in with everyone's schedule/lifestyle.

Some women require meds that are not safe for breastfeeding babies. Should they forego their meds just to appease the crunchy mommas? 

Jayne Wayne --- 14 years ago -


If you don't breast feed, you don't get as much from WIC anyway, so WIC does "penalize" for not breast feeding.



That is not true at all. Not even a little bit.

They will give a family formula from day 1. When I was on WIC, we got 9 cans of formula a month which was plenty.

But I do think WIC is one of the BIGGEST problems when it comes to BFing success. It's like 90%+ of the people on WIC don't BF.... Why? Because they get formula for free. If they actually had to buy it they'd think twice, I'd bet 1 million dollars.

I personally think they shouldn't offer it for the first 6 weeks. (without RX of course.) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground