Have you seen what they do to our men? They video tape sawing peoples heads off, in my book pissing on someone who more than likely got killed because they were TRYING TO KILL ME, isn't that terrible. Childish, sure, but some horrible terrible thing that should never have happened, nope....
These men are trained to kill... We have no clue what they deal with and how much this affects them mentally. Until you have been at war and dealt with what they have been dealing with you probably shouldn't judge them so harshly. I agree that it shouldn't of been recorded and posted.
If you are all for using children as human explosives, ok with women being stoned to death then go right ahead and defend those guys being peed on.
Yes it was wrong and it shouldn't have been recorded, that is just plain stupid.
BUT
These men are fighting these people that blow up their friends everyday, use children as shields, and just some of the worst things you could ever imagine.
So when they do catch them, they are pretty ticked off. And rightfully so.
Don't judge them until you are in their boots!
I hate to imagine what they do to OUR men when they get their hands on them. I'm sure much worse.
it shouldn't have been recorded, that is just plain stupid.
BUT
These men are fighting these people that blow up their friends everyday, use children as shields, and just some of the worst things you could ever imagine.
So when they do catch them, they are pretty ticked off. And rightfully so.
Don't judge them until you are in their boots!
I hate to imagine what they do to OUR men when they get their hands on them. I'm sure much worse.
Pinme --- 13 min ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments These men.are trained to kill... We haves no clue what they deal with and how much this affects them mentally. Until you have been at war and dealt with what they have been dealing with you probably shouldn't judge them so harshly. I agree that it shouldn't of been recorded and posted.
If you are all for using children as human explosives, ok with women being stoned to death then go right ahead and defend those guys being peed on.
I don't think it should have been recorded or published on YouTube...
But let's all remember WHO they are peeing on...it's not like they are peeing on children and wives...it's the scumbags who degrade their women, f their animals, blow up their children and torture our men. So if peeing on them is a disgrace than I guess I'm a bad person for not getting upset over it.
I see nothing wrong with the video besides the fact that they shouldnt have put it on YouTube. Taliban do much worse to our Men and women over there than what Pee can do!! If peoples offended by it than maybe they should remember 9/11 and the way they treated our military and their own people. Or just dont watch it!!
No one has the right to judge these boys unless you have walked in there shoes. Yes it should not of been uploaded up Youtube and released for the world to see but you dont know what these boys have been through, what they have seen. What I dont like is the media is going to take this and use this against our military, our Marines. The people that dont understand what our boys are going through over there are going to use this to degrade and talk down to the people that put their life on the line for them. That's what is sad, not that some Marines peed on some guys who most likely where out to to do horrible things to these Marines.
I agree with most of you, it should not have been posted. There are so many angry military people out there, that should have been done private. I can't even imagine understanding how they feel after what they have seen. My hubby one time saw this man beat his kid for taking candy from him. He said he was in tears thinking of our kids. If my husband saw him dead as mean as it sounds, he may have smiled.
How is peeing on a DEAD body such a terrible thing? Beheading someone who is still alive is a terrible thing (which guess what that happened if you don't remember AND was posted to the internet and televised.) Peeing on someone that is already dead and more than likely was trying to kill you(general) is not bad.
I see what you are saying. We all do things sometimes our of anger that people should not see. I know I have done immature things( not like that) but things that I am embarrassed about. All we can do is learn and find a better way to deal with it. I also have not been through what they have.
These Marines are just people. Yes they are Marines so they should be held to a higher standard but how long does it take for someone to break when watching there brothers be blown up, watching these Afghanies beat and rape woman and children, use women and children as shields, and every other horrible thing they do. Marines are just people too. My husband has told me horrible stories from Afghanistan and I don't think I would be able to hold my composure or beable to be compassionate. Not everyone over there is bad but these are men who were shot and killed because they were most likely a threat.
Yes it was poor judgment, but this was the act of just a handful of people. Now idiots are running around trying to judge the whole USMC based on this. That's ignorant.
Those Marines are no better than the Taliban they urinated on.
Has no one ever heard of the Geneva Convention?
Believe it or not, there are rules of war. One of those rules have to do with the desecration of a soldier killed in war. While Iraq & Afghanistan may have not agreed to the terms of the Geneva Convention, the United States DID and as such, She and the people that represent Her are bound to those terms.
How do you know the men that were pee'd on were terrorist? You don't. I get none of us have stood in their shoes but seriously the marines are there to do a job. Not disgrace another human being? What if those men's children saw their fathers dead body being pee'd on? You all would be in a uproar if that was a video of 2 dead marines being disgraced. Trying to say oh well they were terrorist so they deserved it is ridiculous. Just because bad people do bad things does not mean Marines should especially when they represent America!
IMO it wasn't right, but it wasn't wrong either. I don't think it should have been recorded or posted. These 4 and the one that recorded it will be held accountable for what was done, just like the ones in Iraq that took pictures in the prison and posted them. It was immature for them to do it.
Sounds like there will be some more sensitivity training. Also they aren't Afghans technically they are Taliban people seem to get that confused. It's horrible what they did but it's war.
Those Marines that you are speaking of know the smell of death, know what its like to have their best friend die in their arms, missed births, possibly kissed their spouses for the last time, have seen the most god awful things and here you guys get to judge then based on them peeing on dead bodies. Trust me when I say this isnt the worst thats happened.
Those Marines that you are speaking of know the smell of death, know what its like to have their best friend die in their arms, missed births, possibly kissed their spouses for the last time, have seen the most god awful things and here you guys get to judge then based on them peeing on dead bodies. Trust me when I say this isnt the worst thats happened.
I don't know what to think of Marines doing this. Part of me is thinking "Damn right, should have done more than pee on those ______" and the other part of me thinks it wasn't right....
The only problem I see with this is that it was caught on video and posted to youtube....
I could not agree with this or the other stuff like this being said.
And what really pisses me off is that our own American news shows this SO quickly, but they NEVER seem to post the wonderful stuff they do for those people over there.