Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

breathable vs traditional baby bumpers?

who's talking here?

xloux 2
Barbie 1
EastCoastChik 3
Jersey Shore Chickie 1
Boobs Radley 1
Poe 1
JediMommy 1
accountnickname 3
sassypea 1
Champ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

EastCoastChik --- 14 years ago -

which would you choose and why? 

Boobs Radley --- 14 years ago -

The American Pediatric Association recommends not using them at all, so I would say "neither". 

Poe --- 14 years ago -

Breathable, I'm not comfortable with the traditional ones. 

EastCoastChik --- 14 years ago -

Im getting a crib bedding set made for my son and just wondered what other moms prefer and why. My daughter didnt sleep in a crib lol. 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

Both can cause strangulation, I would go without. I never used one personally. 

JediMommy --- 14 years ago -

i would say neither. My son is 2 months old and i took his off ofter a month. I woke up in the middle of the night to check on him and he had wiggles himself over to it. Thankfully he head was turn the opposite direction. I took it off right then. 

Barbie --- 14 years ago -

The American Pediatric Association recommends not using them at all, so I would say "neither".

x2 

EastCoastChik --- 14 years ago -

Thanks everyone :-) im not going to get one lol. Like i said i had no idea bc my daughter never slept in a crib. 

sassypea --- 14 years ago -

I have the breathable bumper - used it for my daughter and now my son - i know they NOW say use nothing but i have had no issues with it. My son moves around all night and likes to be right up against the corner of the crib so I like to have something to keep his limbs inside. 

xloux --- 14 years ago -

I started off with no bumper. Then once my boy started rolling over he would get his arms and legs stuck between the bars. So I got a breathable bumper. Then once he started standing I had to get a padded one cos he get a little crazy in there, so I was scared he would bump his head. So I would recommend no bumper up until your baby starts to roll over, by that time the risk of sids decreases. 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

I would be more worried about strangulation, personally. I'd rather my child get a limb stuck than be strangled. 

Jersey Shore Chickie --- 14 years ago -

I bought a breathable bumper but it weaved in and out of the crib on the ends. There is no way my son should be able to get tangled up in it. 

xloux --- 14 years ago -

I don't see how a baby could strangle themselves with a bumper, unless they were seriously neglected. 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

If it came undone I suppose. All I know is that the American Academy of Pediatrics says they aren't safe no matter what type they are or how securely they seem to be fastened. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

I've heard of parents coming in and finding their babies head wedged in between the bumper and crib mattress.

We have a bumper weaves between slats (she's almost 2) but we also have it installed where the bumper is put on then the crib matress put in (kind of like the bumper is tucked in between crib/ mattress.

We are 95% sure we won't be using a crib bumper with the baby on the way, but if her arms and legs start getting stuck between the slats we may change our decision.

I do look at aap recomendations, but I usually look toward what other advanced countries are doing. They seem to move at a faster pace then AAP with banning baby items (canada has bumpers banned, a long with baby walkers. Other countries have been big advocates for extended rearfacing in car seats, aap last year finally got with the program. Other countries don't recommend circing, aaps guideline is fence walking (read it, Hah I'm not going near that debate) any who's. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground